drywalldog
Thursday, June 19, 2008 9:22:00 AM
I saw a program a couple of weeks ago, I believe in was on PBS, but not sure, it was on a new concept of

modular nuclear power plants. They are close to being able to build all components in one place, and ship and assemble on location. Supposedly it cuts costs, redtape, permitting times, and would make for better quality control and less time from conception to going

online. They are much smaller than current plants, but can be spaced out, with permitting going on for more plants at same time. Anyone else see this? How

about electric or hybrid electric cars being charged

from home, anyone know anything about this, or why it wouldn't work. I haven't even heard this broached. With everyone cutting back on short trips, especially around town, seems like it would cut back on oil consumption.

DaQueenBeez
Thursday, June 19, 2008 9:33:00 AM
I think I remember Beez talking about this before - he's a nuclear engineer. I fired off an email to him at work with your question.

Tammy

drywalldog
Thursday, June 19, 2008 9:41:00 AM
Thanks for the help, nice to meet you, Drywalldog
pmn1
Thursday, June 19, 2008 9:44:00 AM
I say we build all the nuclear power plants in ... say Mississippi - that way if anything goes wrong nobody gets hurt.
drywalldog
Thursday, June 19, 2008 9:52:00 AM
Pmn1, Funny I thinkin you live nowhere near Mississippi. I lived near one in Homestead, I'm not

afraid of meltdown, just where/how they put waste.

DaBeez
Thursday, June 19, 2008 10:40:00 AM
Nuclear plants in Japan are constructed at a construction facility. Large assemblies are then shipped by rail to the final assembly location where fabrication is completed. This cuts about two years from the construction time. We haven't done this in the US. The primary reasons are that we don't have a standard design and we haven't started construction on a new nuclear plant since about 1980. There are a number of new construction applications in process with the NRC and several more being prepared for submission. The modular design uses a smaller plant design with multiple plants at any given location. The idea is that one plant in a group of six or eight would be shut down for repairs and refuelling at any given time. Fuel would be reprocessed on site and the waste shipped out to a repository. The smaller plants are much easier to cool after shut down and the safety systems are simpler. As far as waste is concerned, the US has decided not to reprocess fuel due to proliferation (nuclear bomb) issues. We are the only country I know of with this policy (thanks Jimmy Carter). Not reprocessing fuel is like filling the gas tank on your car, driving until you have used about one quarter of the tank, paying someone to dispose of the hazardous gasoline waste, and then buying a full tank of fuel. It doesn't make any sense. The other benefit to reprocessing is that the long lived isotopes (plutonium, americium, etc.) can be used as fuel in the reactor. What is left after reprocessing is relatively short lived (hundreds of years to decay instead of tens of thousands).

As far as electric cars, the technology exists right now for a viable car that could be used in a city. However, the electric infrastructure to support electric cars for everyone in say, Los Angeles, doesn't exist. If everyone went electric next year, the city's substations would probably erupt in a shower of sparks and never work again. The other problem with electric cars is that you are only moving the source of pollution unless the power is being produced by nuclear or a renewable resource. Coal fired plants are dirty, wind is unreliable, solar is inefficient, and hydro is pretty much at capacity (you wouldn't get a permit for a dam in today's political environment, anyway).

The best answer right now is to start building nuclear plants near, but not in, large population centers; upgrade the power grid to handle the load during the six years of construction; develop an approved method for reprocessing the spent fuel; and put the car manufacturers on the road (no pun intended) to supply lots of electric cars starting in about six years. Save the oil to power important things like tanks and bombers.

Andy

jpotts
Thursday, June 19, 2008 11:08:00 AM
"As far as electric cars, the technology exists right now for a viable car that could be used in a city. However, the electric infrastructure to support electric cars for everyone in say, Los Angeles, doesn't exist. If everyone went electric next year, the city's substations would probably erupt in a shower of sparks and never work again. The other problem with electric cars is that you are only moving the source of pollution unless the power is being produced by nuclear or a renewable resource. Coal fired plants are dirty, wind is unreliable, solar is inefficient, and hydro is pretty much at capacity (you wouldn't get a permit for a dam in today's political environment, anyway)."

The other problem with electric cars is that - unless you want to blow the battery out of its mounting - recharging has to be done on a fractional basis over time...something like 1/10th of the total capacity of the battery (depending on the battery).

Thus, if you drive non-stop with your electric car for about an hour, it might take about three or four hours to recharge (and I think that the actual time is much longer). The bigger the battery capacity, the longer the recharge.

Most electric cars (pure electric) have about a 40 mile range.

And DaBeez is correct: once an entire population starts moving to electric cars, the electrical subsystem will literally melt down. As it stands right now, we get power outages in Michigan during the summer because everyone turns on their air conditioning at once.

Consequently, consumer electrical is a state-overseen monopoly. They don't bother to upgrade the system for more capacity. They'd rather hire more secretaries, and refurbish more offices.

HockeyDad
Thursday, June 19, 2008 12:36:00 PM
Building electric transmission lines and coal-fired power plants are only slightly easier to get approved than a nuclear power plant.

"Not In My BackYard" rules the day.

drywalldog
Thursday, June 19, 2008 12:50:00 PM
Wouldn't it be better to go with nuclear power, than with coal?
HockeyDad
Thursday, June 19, 2008 12:59:00 PM
We can't build either one. That is why utilities strongly encourage conservation of power and offer all sorts of programs to improve energy efficiency and blast us with TV ads about it. Many utilities are running at 100% generation capacity and have to buy power, build a new plant, or encourage their customers to conserve.

The utilities that can build new power plants often are able to do so only because they have existing power plants that were originally permitted at a larger size that was never fully built and they're just adding an additional unit.

Conservation is the most practical.

Gene363
Thursday, June 19, 2008 2:11:00 PM
re 6

Modular standardized power plant would be easier to license, operate and maintain. It will probably require some sort of government standard to prevent utility engineers from tweaking/changing the design.

Fuel reprocessing is indeed required. Electricity consumers, through the utilities, have contributed billions to a government program that was supposed to reprocess spent fuel. There is a completed fuel reprocessing plant here in South Carolina closed before it started operations; thank you Jimmy Carter and Congress for stealing the money and closing down reprocessing.

Even one of the founders of Greenpeace has come to realize nuclear energy is clean, safe and carbon free.

Unfortunately, we will not be successful unless we educate the entire country about nuclear energy. This is required to remedy the hysteria associated with anything nuclear. I love America, but we are stunningly ill informed about nuclear power, spent nuclear fuel and nuclear waste. I hate to admit it but the French have done a great job of getting their people on board.

HockeyDad
Thursday, June 19, 2008 2:42:00 PM
VIVE LE FRANCE!
pacman357
Thursday, June 19, 2008 4:00:00 PM
Actually, I think the current working model contemplates building them inside of Deloreans.
MCAddict
Thursday, June 19, 2008 5:52:00 PM
pacman 357, that is some funny chit.
DaBeez
Thursday, June 19, 2008 6:23:00 PM
Potts: there is battery technology right now that can be scaled up to recharge faster than that. Look at the fast charge batteries that are available for power tools. THere is still some design/perfection; but, six years should be enough to get it to market in a useful form.

Drywalldog: yes, nuclear is practically unlimited. Actually, fusion is a better choice than fission. The problem is the technology is probably 50 years out. Fusion solves most of the waste problems.

Hockeydad: TVA is in the process of bringing a plant on line that was liscensed for construction in 1980. They are spending about 2 BILLION dollars to upgrade the control system to current standards and should be ready for operation in a year or two. There are companies that are pursuing nuclear power pretty hard. The 4-6 billion dollar cost of a plant is becomming pretty attractive as hydrocarbons and coal get more expensive. I don't think that conservation is the answer. As electric prices rise, power intensive industries like steel and aluminum smelting will continue to move out of the country to reduce cost. Reducing electricity usage by reducing production capacity is a very bad trade off, IMHO.

Gene: Yeah, the Frogs produce 80% of their power from nuclear. We are at a measley 20% and some would like to reduce that. Nuclear power to the grid is the cheapest electric energy available. It costs just under 4 cents per KWH to the grid. Coal is about 4.2 cents per KWH and will continue to increase with the AGW idiots banging their drum. THe best answer is to add a 10 cent per KWH tax to all energy not produced from nuclear or renewable. Hit them where it hurts-the pocket book. It's amazing what people will learn if it saves them money.

Beez

drywalldog
Thursday, June 19, 2008 6:40:00 PM
Dabeez, Thanks for all the info, sounds like a better way to go than drillin off of all the coasts, or at least in addition to it. We really need to get off

petro, and I know alot of people who live a couple miles from their work, so that if they perfect the short trip elec. vehicles, that really could cut into

the gas shortage, along with cutting back on trips, conservation, and bio-fuels other than corn based. A

concerted effort, we could let the arabs sit on their oil.

grmcooper
Thursday, June 19, 2008 6:48:00 PM
I went to a nuke powerplant that is in Richland,WA next to the hanford site last year. It was 90% complete in the late 80s and the bond got yanked. Still sitting there 90% done.

They said they had scrapped the guts out to other countrys and the place is so out dated that it is useless! Bunch of money out the door there!!

Cooper

jpotts
Thursday, June 19, 2008 8:03:00 PM
DaBeez:

"Potts: there is battery technology right now that can be scaled up to recharge faster than that. Look at the fast charge batteries that are available for power tools. THere is still some design/perfection; but, six years should be enough to get it to market in a useful form."

My former boss (who I'm considering asking for a job) now works at a company that makes batteries for hybrids - we've discussed this. I'm aware of the "fast" charge. Low-voltage, low load batteries are one thing, using the same technology in a vehicle is quite another.

That being said, consider the amount of current required to drive a hybrid/electric motor, and then look at what it will take to pipe that down through a line that won't melt when you go to charge your car.

I'm not saying it can't happen, but there are several "logistical" problems with doing a full charge on an electrical car. Some of which haven't been yet addressed.

DaBeez
Thursday, June 19, 2008 8:47:00 PM
Potts-Agreed. However, with the right amount of research the technology can be perfected and there are some other battery types in development. Even so, if you could get a car to go 300 miles on a charge and charge it overnight, it would be a viable option, particularly for city use. The first 300 horsepower all electric car is already on the market, although it's very expensive. She Beez says she thinks you have posted about the Tesla. It still has it's charging issues; but, new battery technology could overcome that - and it can be done sooner rather than later. As fast as the technology is progressing, I think it is realistic. The other option is hydrogen. Again, it has safety issues to overcome. Nuclear plants can be built to supply peak load and, during off peak, use the power to produce hydrogen for cars. The reactor where I work is testing high temperature fuels that can be used for this purpose. This technology is still a ways out without substantial funding.

Obviously I have more experience with the nuclear side. May be time to do some battery research.

Andy

DaBeez
Thursday, June 19, 2008 8:58:00 PM
One other thing-I don't think this is a CO2 issue. The AGW people are ignoring too many things with the environment to have much credibility; however, relying on a foriegn country that hates us for our energy supply is stupid at best. The government needs to take the stand that purchasing foreign oil is a national security issue and take steps to wean us off of it. That would involve streamlining the licensing process, doing a PROPER review of the design and location of the plant, then stop the frivolous lawsuits that stop the plants. I don't mean ignore the safety issues; just address them and move on. If you don't want nuclear power, we can cut the wires to your house and let you live in a simpler time, you know, like the Amish.

Not trying to rant, I'm just sayin...

Andy