big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:00:00 PM
You've made it obvious you are defense atty. It also obvious you are no dummy. Chief have question: Any stats on those wrongfully convicted?

(note: this not a challenge to Pac. Any right thinking person should be wondering this same question.)

Hopefully we can keep this discussion slow; on track; no hysterics, no party-line crap. Let's work for 'understanding' some of the issues.

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:05:00 PM
Chief pose this because 17 years ago, his atty was so inept Chief was understood by the court to be a fraud, a philanderer (sadly, true), and some other bad things.

Admittedly, this was low-court stuff...but still, it became easy to understand that innocent people could be convicted of bad stuff.

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:06:00 PM
^^^^^and I refer to 'divorce court', to clarify.
djk
  • djk
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:14:00 PM
I'm no lawyer, but recently read that out of those folks sentenced to prision time, about ten percent are innocent of the convicted crime.

The old saying is that they probably did something and got away with it in the past, so who cares. ( this is not my view, however).

dan

Thunder.Gerbil
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:31:00 PM
"I'm no lawyer, but recently read that out of those folks sentenced to prision time, about ten percent are innocent of the convicted crime. "

How would they come up with a statistic like that?

Ask the people who were sentenced? "Did you really do it?"

Just believe the ones that claim to not be guilty and can tell a somewhat convincing story?

Retry the cases in their own minds to determine true guilt or innocence?

Just take some random percentage of those that plead innocent but are later convicted?

Survey the prosecuters and ask them how many people they thought were innocent?

I'm not saying that there aren't people who are innocent that have been convicted, I just fail to see any way to deterine any valid number.

djk
  • djk
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:44:00 PM
TG did not waste anytime!

This is a fairly new statistic in light of DNA evidence (and other) that exhonerated and continues to exhonerate 10 percent of the prision population in the Southern state where this was written. The details of the piece are fuzzy to me, forgive me.

Having worked inside a prision for 4 years if you were to take a pole of the prisioners you would learn that about 80 percent are innocent.

djk
  • djk
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:44:00 PM
one handed typing, forgive my grammer and spelling.
djk
  • djk
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:45:00 PM
furthermore i think a 10 percent error rate is pretty damn low all things considered.

Thunder.Gerbil
Monday, July 7, 2008 5:57:00 PM
Ok, exoneration by DNA evidence makes sense.
pacman357
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:08:00 PM
Oh, man. This is a loaded question. If you were to survey inmates in prisons, about 99.5%. Some do admit their crime up front, just say "see what you can do for me", etc. Even some of those people change their tune once they've been incarcerated for a while. I suppose if you ask prosecutors, it'd be move like 0.5%.

The Innocence Project has done a lot to free wrongfully convicted inmates. Individual attorneys do, too. Seems like there are more and more of these stories every year, certainly more than when I graduated law school over 20 years ago. Then again, there have been some serious advances in DNA and other investigative tools. I was just reading a day or two ago about yet another inmate in Dallas County, TX being released after serving more than two decades in prison (on death row, I believe), and the article indicated that county had experiences a high number of exonerations, releases, etc.

The sad fact of the matter is that there really is no way to tell. You could Google, check the Innocence Project to see how many people they have freed, etc. Even some of those freed are still open to some debate, at least in the minds of some people. Judges take issue with prosecutors suppressing exculpatory evidence and order a new trial, but half or more of the witnesses are dead or scattered to who knows where. DNA appears to at least cast serious doubt in some cases, but isn't the reverse of a "smoking gun" in all cases. Witnesses come forward to claim they were pressured by cops, etc.

The system is run by humans. It involves humans at every level. That means errors are possible at every step of every level. And sure, guilty people go free, too. Some people are convicted of crimes less serious than charged (and that they are guilty of) for various reasons. Still others are convicted where they perhaps should not have been.

Illiustrative case: in Washington, it is a felony to threaten to kill another person, even if the threat is made to a third person...I read an appellate case last week upholding convictions for two such threats where it was clear the guy was reaching out to a social work for help because of what looks like was really a problem stemming from a mental illness...said he kept having dreams of killing two particular people and when asked if he thought he wanted to kill them, he said yes...the people weren't even in the room, didn't hear it, and I'd bet that what the guy really needed was hospitalization and treatment, possibly for an extended period of time.

If we had a "guilt" machine to determine who was really guilty of what, we could answer the question. Because no such device exists, it's impossible to answer the question. I won't use the question to crawl up on the soapbox and rail against the system, judges, etc. I've been trained by some truly brilliant people, and I've had cases where jurors spent hours poring over documents, evidence, testimony, etc. Funny thing...I've won cases where people were paying me and others where I was appointed...yet the prevailing theory among many people still seems to be that appointed attorneys are all lousy or expensive attorneys are all good. In my experience, good and bad attorneys exist in both realms.

Win or lose, if a jury clearly, conscientiously deliberates a case, I appreciate their work. I still hate losing more than just about anything in life, but it happens. Some cases leave a bitter taste in my mouth for years, and others I've won and was quite amazed at the outcome. I also get a great deal of satisfaction from winning a hard-fought case, client's guilt clearly in doubt (especially with high stakes, no priors, etc.). Like a pitcher, some days I have better "stuff" than others. Each trial is important and I try give my best effort. Sadly, it is true that others don't or really should be doing some other kind of work.

It's a cliche', but I really do believe we have the best system in the world. It doesn't always work properly, and some times the better lawyer beats a potentially stronger case. I've had some clients I felt were likely innocent (you try to avoid the assessment to maintain objectivity, but it can be tough in some cases, and those keep me awake at night). At the end of the day, all a defense attorney can do is his or her best to try to avoid seeing an innocent person go to jail, and that all clients' rights are protected as fully as possible.

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:24:00 PM
Good, so far.

Let's be careful, though, o.k.? Keep things on a philosophical level. None of the knee-jerk crap.

Personally, I saw how, in a stupid divorce court, I was made to look like...well, like a near-criminal and this was painful and got me really wondering how easy it would be to get one's sorry ass convicted wrongefully of something.

I allow that there are 'appeal' courts; I allow that there are myriad 'stopgaps' to try and ensure the innocent is not wrongfully convicted. But still...

I ask this of PAC because even though he comes across as a bit of a steamroller, he MUST be operating with a basic credo, a sense of right/wrong, a gaddam PHILOSOPHY of approach to his work re: criminal justice.

I'd like to hear what it is--not to enable me or anyone else to condemn him or the justice system--but to enable understanding of whether the 'system' is really working or not.

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:31:00 PM
PAC, I wrote my last one while you were posting your last one.

I think what I was hoping to hear was your comment about how you think that the system is functioning as well as possible.

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:33:00 PM
and a 'thank you' for your thoughts.
pacman357
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:36:00 PM
#11 Wow. Knee-jerk? I thought I was doing a pretty good job of avoiding that very thing. Spent quite a bit of time crafting it.

I'll try one more run here, but another undeserved shot like that, and this paleface is done.

Basically I believe that we all are entitled to the full protection of the laws, no matter what the charge, no matter how guilty or innocent a person appears. To that end, I believe that every person accused of a crime deserves competent and skilled representation, and that the attorney should do his/her best job to get the best result he/she can for the client.

For that reason, I'll probably die with just a few bucks in my pocket. I pay the most I can to attract the best talent I can to rural areas and treat my employees as best as I can. Most folks where my offices are located have indicated they believe we have raised the level of representation from some previous providers. I'd like to think that constitutes walking the walk.

If you still see a knee flailing around, I can't help you any further. I am sorry you had a bad experience with the courts. I hope some day you have a better one under better circumstances, such as a positive time serving on a jury or something.

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:42:00 PM
You missed it!! Dammnn!

I posted referring to posts prior to your post, i.e., I was composing while you were posting.

This was not meant to be confusing, but it is...there was no attack on my part.

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:44:00 PM
as in my #11 was for posts prior to your #10
big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:45:00 PM
and but goddam it is hard to discuss things on the interweb.

I thought your #10 was dam good.

pacman357
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:50:00 PM
#12-13 Thanks. Looks like we were just leapfrogging one another (not without diner an a movie, pal).

I thought you scorched me pretty good, and I was wondering WTF? Thought I stayed down the middle pretty good.

Think we're on the same page as far as that goes. No autopsy, no foul.

Thunder.Gerbil
Monday, July 7, 2008 6:51:00 PM
Chief-

How is what djk posted and my response to it knee-jerk?

He posted some numbers he read, I questioned the methods by which they might have been determined. What's "knee-jerk" there?

big chief
Monday, July 7, 2008 7:05:00 PM
TG, only because it sounded like an argument was beginning.

NOT here to promote that. Not making this thread to promote that. NOT WANTING to see fuss/fight. Just hoping for PAC's suss on the justice system/how he perceives it/is it functioning/etc. Simple.

Yet even THAT was nearly misconceived.

I give.

I'm going back to jackassery and forget any serious thoughts.