I am a HUGE Buc fan, and I own multiple boxes of every line.
What you dudes failed to mention was the Bucanero Texas Star, the rarest of the bunch, and a top-notch, super-premium IMO.
The Bucanero Don Douglas, the newest of the Bucaneros, is also an amazing cigar. It has "breakfast cigar" qualities, but is chalk-full of flavor, and just enough spice to rival some ISOM.
All in all, just about every brand of cigars is going to have it's strong points and negatives with different people. The Bucanero is not the "end-all" brand of cigars, but every cigar they make has a special "Ma & Pa" type feel to it, and IMO the flavor never dissapoints.
Meeee maties love theee blasted Peg Leg, arrrrrrggggghhhhhhh! BeatDragon tried a Buc once, and then he walked meeee plank. Arrrrggggghhhh!!!
Dave