hoyodude
Monday, January 3, 2011 10:50:23 AM
Ever since I began seeing these I've been tempted to try a 5'er to see if they're all that. Up until last night I didn't see any for a price I was willing to pay but I finally snagged a 5'er of the toros for $13.

Now, we'll see if these are worth 3 bucks a piece or not.

Anyone out there tried these yet?

Stephen1106
Monday, January 3, 2011 11:18:02 AM
Have not tried these but been very tempted to get some
jig+pig
Monday, January 3, 2011 12:36:20 PM
let us know what they're like please. i'm a fan of the regular line.....for what it's worth...lol
hoyodude
Wednesday, January 5, 2011 9:39:46 PM
So, my 5'er of toro's came today. I managed to scoop them off the back porch before they got too cold and, after a grace period for warming up put flame to leaf.

First, the hype (ref.: Cbid):

"Everything about Cuba Libre One demands the spotlight. A beautiful, elegant band. A dark and oily Habano-seed ligero wrapper from the fields of Honduras' Jamastran Valley. A searing mixture of aged long-fillers, including Cuban-seed ligeros from Esteli and Condega of Honduras, with even more ligeros from Honduras. Then, its unique use of two full-flavored binders: a zesty Habano from Jalapa, Nicaragua and a hearty Costa Rican leaf. Complex is an understatement here. Cuba Libre One is Cuban-esque to the core, dishing out rich nuances throughout the slow burn. Expertly balanced notes of coffee, earth, pepper, and cream are complemented perfectly by a dee-lish, semi-sweet finish. This cigar is good, real good, and I suggest you try it soon....I'm confident it'll find its way into your regular rotation after just a couple sticks - if not after just one."

Now, the lowdown:

Beautiful wrapper. Reddish brown, glistening with oil , smooth with smallish veins. The Palio revealed a perfect draw and smoking commenced.

Initially I am struck by a pronounced woody dryness to the smoke. This persisted until about the fifth or sixth full draw when the game changed in a big way. Enter the true soul of this cigar - deeply creamy, leathery and slightly floral with a long, sweet finish. Oh, yumm. What started out rather one dimensional and almost overly woody is now making me lick my lips from the sweet richness I'm experiencing.

There is no doubt the joy I'm getting from this stick is due in large part to the wonderful blend of ligeros used in the wrapper and filler. I have found out in the past year I am evidently a huge ligero fan. Long Live Ligero!!

Anyhow, the middle of the cigar approaches,the richness has intensified and I'm getting a little nutmeg with a dash of espresso thrown in. Such a cool smoke and the burn has been razor straight. Not bad for a minimally rested cigar smoked ROTT. Still, such creaminess! And the aftertaste has an almost minty quality along with the sweetness. What I haven't mentioned is the strength and this toro has balls. I usually don't notice much of a nicotine kick from any but the strongest cigars and I feel that pleasant familiar buzz now. Glad I ate before I smoked this thing. I hate to use the "C"-word but..... this cigar is nothing if not "Cubanesque". There, I said it.

Into the final third now and the cool smoke is still lip-smackingly tasty. No harshness at all just rich, sweet and savory flavors, puff after delicious puff. Only one relight as I approach the nub. The end is a flavor bomb without the slightest heat.

So, wadda ya think? Think I liked this cigar? You would be incorrect. I LOVED this cigar! Forget what you know about th regular line in terms of flavor profile, this is clearly the superior blend. The regular Cuba Libre was a nice smoke, IMO, but nothing more and I probably won't be seeking more. I will most definitely be adding more Cuba Libre One to my humidor in the, hopefully near, future.

I'll be interested to hear other opinions.

JadeRose
Thursday, January 6, 2011 8:29:08 AM

So, my 5'er of toro's came today. I managed to scoop them off the back porch before they got too cold and, after a grace period for warming up put flame to leaf.

First, the hype (ref.: Cbid):

"Everything about Cuba Libre One demands the spotlight. A beautiful, elegant band. A dark and oily Habano-seed ligero wrapper from the fields of Honduras' Jamastran Valley. A searing mixture of aged long-fillers, including Cuban-seed ligeros from Esteli and Condega of Honduras, with even more ligeros from Honduras. Then, its unique use of two full-flavored binders: a zesty Habano from Jalapa, Nicaragua and a hearty Costa Rican leaf. Complex is an understatement here. Cuba Libre One is Cuban-esque to the core, dishing out rich nuances throughout the slow burn. Expertly balanced notes of coffee, earth, pepper, and cream are complemented perfectly by a dee-lish, semi-sweet finish. This cigar is good, real good, and I suggest you try it soon....I'm confident it'll find its way into your regular rotation after just a couple sticks - if not after just one."

Now, the lowdown:

Beautiful wrapper. Reddish brown, glistening with oil , smooth with smallish veins. The Palio revealed a perfect draw and smoking commenced.

Initially I am struck by a pronounced woody dryness to the smoke. This persisted until about the fifth or sixth full draw when the game changed in a big way. Enter the true soul of this cigar - deeply creamy, leathery and slightly floral with a long, sweet finish. Oh, yumm. What started out rather one dimensional and almost overly woody is now making me lick my lips from the sweet richness I'm experiencing.

There is no doubt the joy I'm getting from this stick is due in large part to the wonderful blend of ligeros used in the wrapper and filler. I have found out in the past year I am evidently a huge ligero fan. Long Live Ligero!!

Anyhow, the middle of the cigar approaches,the richness has intensified and I'm getting a little nutmeg with a dash of espresso thrown in. Such a cool smoke and the burn has been razor straight. Not bad for a minimally rested cigar smoked ROTT. Still, such creaminess! And the aftertaste has an almost minty quality along with the sweetness. What I haven't mentioned is the strength and this toro has balls. I usually don't notice much of a nicotine kick from any but the strongest cigars and I feel that pleasant familiar buzz now. Glad I ate before I smoked this thing. I hate to use the "C"-word but..... this cigar is nothing if not "Cubanesque". There, I said it.

Into the final third now and the cool smoke is still lip-smackingly tasty. No harshness at all just rich, sweet and savory flavors, puff after delicious puff. Only one relight as I approach the nub. The end is a flavor bomb without the slightest heat.

So, wadda ya think? Think I liked this cigar? You would be incorrect. I LOVED this cigar! Forget what you know about th regular line in terms of flavor profile, this is clearly the superior blend. The regular Cuba Libre was a nice smoke, IMO, but nothing more and I probably won't be seeking more. I will most definitely be adding more Cuba Libre One to my humidor in the, hopefully near, future.

I'll be interested to hear other opinions.

hoyodude wrote:

Well...glad to get an opinion . I am kinda figuring I will like this cigar but now that this review has been posted, I will have to let prices die down a bit. This is why I never post reviews. I'm in competition with you clowns.

schusler
Monday, January 17, 2011 10:43:57 PM
just won a 5er of Churchills for $13. waiting on them to arrive....
hombre
Monday, January 17, 2011 11:16:52 PM
I had my first one, also a toro size over the weekend. I was not expecting much but was also suprised. It was really good. Thing Jaime Garcia ---ALMOST! Not as good as the Jaime but pretty darn close. Got a little bitter int he final 1.5 inches or so. Other then that it was pretty tastey. Fairly one dimensional, certainly not complex but very very tastey. I would by more..
rfenst
Tuesday, January 18, 2011 12:13:23 AM
This was a sought after brand during th "Boom".

The name was also changed back then.

I think they were rolled in Hialeah, Florida. Are they still rolled there?

JavaLang
Saturday, April 2, 2011 8:46:43 AM
Thread necro but....

This is a great smoke for someone looking for a well constructed, strong cigar for not a lot of coin. If you can score some on the cheap, do yourself a favor and pick some up.

Smoke1!
Saturday, April 2, 2011 9:54:58 PM

So, my 5'er of toro's came today. I managed to scoop them off the back porch before they got too cold and, after a grace period for warming up put flame to leaf.

First, the hype (ref.: Cbid):

"Everything about Cuba Libre One demands the spotlight. A beautiful, elegant band. A dark and oily Habano-seed ligero wrapper from the fields of Honduras' Jamastran Valley. A searing mixture of aged long-fillers, including Cuban-seed ligeros from Esteli and Condega of Honduras, with even more ligeros from Honduras. Then, its unique use of two full-flavored binders: a zesty Habano from Jalapa, Nicaragua and a hearty Costa Rican leaf. Complex is an understatement here. Cuba Libre One is Cuban-esque to the core, dishing out rich nuances throughout the slow burn. Expertly balanced notes of coffee, earth, pepper, and cream are complemented perfectly by a dee-lish, semi-sweet finish. This cigar is good, real good, and I suggest you try it soon....I'm confident it'll find its way into your regular rotation after just a couple sticks - if not after just one."

Now, the lowdown:

Beautiful wrapper. Reddish brown, glistening with oil , smooth with smallish veins. The Palio revealed a perfect draw and smoking commenced.

Initially I am struck by a pronounced woody dryness to the smoke. This persisted until about the fifth or sixth full draw when the game changed in a big way. Enter the true soul of this cigar - deeply creamy, leathery and slightly floral with a long, sweet finish. Oh, yumm. What started out rather one dimensional and almost overly woody is now making me lick my lips from the sweet richness I'm experiencing.

There is no doubt the joy I'm getting from this stick is due in large part to the wonderful blend of ligeros used in the wrapper and filler. I have found out in the past year I am evidently a huge ligero fan. Long Live Ligero!!

Anyhow, the middle of the cigar approaches,the richness has intensified and I'm getting a little nutmeg with a dash of espresso thrown in. Such a cool smoke and the burn has been razor straight. Not bad for a minimally rested cigar smoked ROTT. Still, such creaminess! And the aftertaste has an almost minty quality along with the sweetness. What I haven't mentioned is the strength and this toro has balls. I usually don't notice much of a nicotine kick from any but the strongest cigars and I feel that pleasant familiar buzz now. Glad I ate before I smoked this thing. I hate to use the "C"-word but..... this cigar is nothing if not "Cubanesque". There, I said it.

Into the final third now and the cool smoke is still lip-smackingly tasty. No harshness at all just rich, sweet and savory flavors, puff after delicious puff. Only one relight as I approach the nub. The end is a flavor bomb without the slightest heat.

So, wadda ya think? Think I liked this cigar? You would be incorrect. I LOVED this cigar! Forget what you know about th regular line in terms of flavor profile, this is clearly the superior blend. The regular Cuba Libre was a nice smoke, IMO, but nothing more and I probably won't be seeking more. I will most definitely be adding more Cuba Libre One to my humidor in the, hopefully near, future.

I'll be interested to hear other opinions.

hoyodude wrote:

Hoyo: You suck. 😁 I won a 5 pack of the toros for $9, and with that review you can bet that won't happen again.

Honestly though, I agree wholeheartedly with your review. I had originally scored two of the churchills about a month ago and just smoked the second one yesterday. Wow! I can't compare it to cubans, but I did find it to be a very complex and flavorful cigar. I had a friend who doesn't smoke cigars ask me what it was because he really liked the smell.

It's a hit!

Smoke1!
Sunday, April 3, 2011 8:45:50 AM
Also, FWIW there's a special right now on the sister site where you can get 4 each of the CL One, original CL, Nica Libre and Potencia for $35. Not a bad deal if you're looking to try them.
hoyodude
Sunday, April 3, 2011 3:42:13 PM

Hoyo: You suck. 😁 I won a 5 pack of the toros for $9, and with that review you can bet that won't happen again....

Smoke1! wrote:

😛 Glad I could help, LOL!

nnightmar
Sunday, April 3, 2011 4:11:22 PM
Nice review as always. Can't say I'm excited by "minty" but intrigued. Should really consider picking up a fiver gven this level of praise. Thanks. I have taken to ignoring marketing and recognizing it for what it is. Without this review I probably would not have considered trying this brand.
borndead1
Sunday, April 3, 2011 4:54:44 PM
Smoked a belicoso last night.

Pretty good smoke. I'm not gonna go crazy trying to get more of them though.