easymac71
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 7:14:48 PM
So I'm pretty new to actually caring about what I'm smoking and paying attention to the nuances and customs of cigars. I've tried a few from most of the majors, but have yet to try some from a couple others (namely Fuente and Macanudo).

I know the reputation of Arturo Fuente and undoubtedly the Opus X is the end all be all.

My question is What about Macanudo? I had heard of them when I was in high school and have read some reviews and pages about them. All of these sources have been very mixed and often extreme in their charecterization of Macanudo. Some seem to really love them while others can't stand them. I'm just looking for some guidance considering the fact that before I actually delved into the culture I had the understanding that CAO, Macanudo, Ashton, etc. where the premiums. Is Macanudo worthy of this charecterization? and should I be looking to try them?

KPP
  • KPP
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 7:19:06 PM
it's as if the clouds have parted....and a giant light is shining down upon thee!!!
tonyt722
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 7:27:57 PM
PM TJ...he will help u with the Mac decision
fishinguitarman
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 7:30:29 PM
Ahhhh the next Noob Trade Thread target.....uhhhh victim....ummmm Participant!

Need a vet!

tljones1961
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 8:46:21 PM

Ahhhh the next Noob Trade Thread target.....uhhhh victim....ummmm Participant!

Need a vet!

fishinguitarman wrote:

Hello?

donutboy2000
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 9:05:31 PM
Smoke what you like.

Like what you smoke.

mk05
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 10:45:00 PM
bomb donutboy
ZRX1200
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 11:35:29 PM
Macs are well constructed and consistant. But they are VERY mild, and most of the negativity is due to them not having much flavor. Listen to FGM, he is the only sane one here and will get you taken care of in the noob trade thread. Now use the search function to find "C.A.T. Thonginator" picture. WELCOME!!!!!!!!!!
tj2001cobra
Tuesday, January 25, 2011 11:56:36 PM
Most Macs are VERY mild. They do have a couple of lines, such as the 1968, that are stronger and have more flavor.

They are cheap, so buy one and see what you think.

n00b
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 3:32:56 AM

Most Macs are VERY mild. They do have a couple of lines, such as the 1968, that are stronger and have more flavor.

They are cheap, so buy one and see what you think.

tj2001cobra wrote:

Love the 1968. Not quite in the cheap arena though.

Stinkdyr
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 8:23:44 AM
Heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeey macanudo!

\:d/

Lumpa
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 9:29:55 AM
Really liked the Vintage 1997s, now long gone.

Anyone know how the 2000s compare to the 97s?

tljones1961
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 9:40:24 AM
Don't care for any other than the Mac Robust.
dstieger
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 9:51:47 AM
^13. +1 Robust is a very enjoyable morning cigar. Like the 1968's, but I perfer many others at that price point.
daveincincy
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 11:25:18 AM
IMO, the best thing about Macs (the cigar, not the cbid person) is their consistent quality. In a pinch (i.e. if I forget a cigar and someone has a Mac), I will smoke a Macanudo. However, there are many others out there that I prefer. It's like beer. Some people drink Bud Light or Miller Lite, etc and that's all they drink 98.2% of the time. They're loyal like that. Others, like myself, are not loyal to any brand (probably because I don't watch NASCAR) and will drink imports, micro-brews, etc etc. The same goes for cigars. Some people are Mac people and just smoke Macanudos (like my dad was until he ran out and decided to try another brand and liked them just as much). Most Macanudos are mild, but they are well made, and for that reason they are a top seller in the industry.
delarob
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 12:23:41 PM
[quote=easymac71]So I'm pretty new to actually caring about what I'm smoking and paying attention to the nuances and customs of cigars. I've tried a few from most of the majors, but have yet to try some from a couple others (namely Fuente and Macanudo).

I know the reputation of Arturo Fuente and undoubtedly the Opus X is the end all be all.

quote]

You're new yet you make a statement like that? Sounds like your mind is already made up. I personally don't see what makes everyone's panties so wet from these overpriced, overhyped sticks. I'd be willing to bet half the people who fawn over them, if you took the bands off they'd sing another tune not knowing.

Macs are, for the most part, lighter smokes that are quite consistant in flavor. Dave sumed it up pretty well. I don't smoke em myself because I prefer the heavier bodied blends. My buddy loves em. I dig the Mac 1968s (obviously) but who's to say you will. Have a Mac, but try all of them to get a true feeling of the blends and brand. It's not my go to smoke, but when I want something and want to know exactly what I'm getting I'll trust a Mac.

easymac71
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 12:56:21 PM
i've spent more time reading reviews than any person probably should. But every person I know who enjoys cigars brings up the same smoke, the opus x. Besides that there are the padrons but I always hear opus X first. just kind of making a generalization. maybe it isnt to you but the general consensus that i've encountered is that is the smoke you have to have
fishinguitarman
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 1:00:33 PM
Depends on your individual tastes. I really like the opus but is it in my top 5 favs? Nope....But then again, I'm a MaddieheadedHo
daveincincy
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 1:52:19 PM
Well, the Opus line is definitely worth trying. But bang-for-the-buck, you can find a lot of other quality cigars for cheaper. Now Cuban cigars...those are the end all be all. 😰

Depends on your individual tastes. I really like the opus but is it in my top 5 favs? Nope....But then again, I'm a MaddieheadedHo

fishinguitarman wrote:

You haven't tried the Opus X maduros yet?? :-"

delarob
Wednesday, January 26, 2011 1:52:46 PM
Meh... Smoke what ya like, right? I used to worry about what others thought of a cigar and I would end up with boxes that I didn't want. The only smokes I have to have are the ones I like and I could give a rat's patoot what anyone else says I need to stock in my humi. Don't stop reading the reviews and don't think you are the only one that spends a lot of time on them. When you start stacking coolers or cabinet humidors, you end up with a big investment. You'd be a fool not to get some info before you buy.

I wish you luck in your quest for the perfect smoke Cheasymac. 😰

Oh yeah, and welcome aboard. It's nice to see you are doing your homework and research. =d>

Mobile! Terms | Privacy | Contact Us | Help | © 1998-2026, CigarBid.com