Hopefully (unlike another board) this discussion can extend beyond folks saying they have X number of Palios/Xikar which work just fine.
I actually used one of these cutters about a year ago. Here are my thoughts:
1. It was created BECAUSE people in the factory did use Exacto/razor blades to cut slits. it mimicks that. If you want to take the time to use a razor to cut five holes, experiment on your own.
2. You had to put the cigar further into your mouth than I normally do as the slits are on the side rather than the tip/head of the cigar
3. The draw is slightly more restricted than a standard cut with a guillotine (Should be obvious since that is a lop off the end)
4. I ended up having the shop owner give me a standard clip after I was through with half of the smoke.
Overall, it's not that is was BAD it was just QUITE different.
IF you're someone who thinks what you have is good enough...well, you're going to feel that way no matter what the new product is.
For someone who chomps the hell out of their cap and the cigar ends up unraveling, this may be for you. The cap (and wrapper) stayed relatively intact throughout my smoke.
M