Second question is directly related to the 1st. I bought a fiver of cigars off of someone, not this site, and one of the f'ing cigars was cut already. It was not in the description of the cigar sale. Am I slightly peaved for no reason or is this unacceptable? I don't know if I should say anything or not. I don't want to make a big deal over one cut cigar but I just never heard of this and I certainly wouldn't sell a cut cigar to someone w/o their knowledge.

What say you?

But I would be pissed if I bought cigars off of someone and received them already cut. If it was a RAOK I would only think it a little strange. But to purchase already cut smokes and not be informed beforehand... that I think is a no-no. Sounds like someone was trying to hide something.

just my 2¢

I would be peaved as well after buying from an individual , not so much that it was cut ,but was it in the dip****tes mouth.

I would probably toss it. Leave the kcuf some bad feedback if possible. If its a pricey smoke cut 2 inches off of it and smoke the fuggar!

Have stated "as is". Know any good atty's? 🙂

^^^^^^^^ what he said

they should've disclosed/mentioned that it was cut already. I would say something to them.

1) Not bad at all, makes no difference at all really. If you cut down the cap too far, then the cigar might unravel, but that's the worst of it. I've had cut cigars in my humidors for months (year?), simply because I forgot about them, with no ill effect when I finally smoked them.

Some manufacturers even make them that way, for example,. J. Fuego Origens Originals.

2) Have you tried contacting him to ask about it? Could be an accident.

Shit happens, it's inevitable. It's how someone reacts and deals with it that tells you their true mettle.