dstieger
Monday, March 5, 2012 11:56:35 AM
I'm almost skeered to ask after the Pueblo and 'new' Padilla threads.....but, here goes anyway.....

I see a whole bunch of corojo Vigilantes up for bid. Bands look remarkably similar to the ones sold as RP about 4 years ago. Cbid must have pushed a few thousand in span of 6 months to a year. IIRC, maddies were pretty good deal at less than 2 bucks per. Seems corojos were not quite as good, but smoothed a bit after some nap time. Soooooo.....the ones up for auction now don't mention RP. What's the story on these?

What, if any, relation to the previous Vigilantes?

-Same batch, but recently 'rediscovered' in a corner of a warehouse?

-Completely unrelated, but either there are leftover bands somewhere or someone had the bright money-saving idea of saving cash on one-time art charges for new bands, so recycling name/band? (I won't make the cynical charge of leveraging an old moderately successful name for a totally new, unrelated cigar.)

-New batch, but tobacco somehow similar or related to previous blends?

-RP involved? Not at all..or, a little bit.....or, he is, but his name has some negative connotation lately, so lets not mention it? or.....

dpnewell
Monday, March 5, 2012 1:32:27 PM
Looks like another brand "resurection" that shares nothing with the original but the name.

RP Vigilante - Nic Corojo wraper, Nic binder, Nic, Hon and Puruvian fillers.

CI Vgilante - US Corojo wraper, no binder description, Nic, Dom and Mexican fillers.

niteorday
Monday, March 5, 2012 2:35:40 PM
🌫 I have smoked a cupple 5ers....................not same as original

no more fer me

still have 2 maddie originals................they good smoke

hombre
Monday, March 5, 2012 2:44:37 PM
The originals were a fantastic value... Not going to try the new ones.
Sonnyf78
Monday, March 5, 2012 8:17:06 PM
I still have a few of the old from 08 or 09. Might give one a go soon for the sake of argument. Only if it's not the same blend, not sure I should bother buying the new. They came in such a cool box, too. Not that it matters....just saying.
fishinguitarman
Monday, March 5, 2012 8:23:41 PM

I still have a few of the old from 08 or 09. Might give one a go soon for the sake of argument. Only if it's not the same blend, not sure I should bother buying the new. They came in such a cool box, too. Not that it matters....just saying.

Sonnyf78 wrote:

DUDE! Where ya been!

lou2row
Monday, March 5, 2012 8:45:37 PM
I still have a box or two of both the corojo and maduro originals. Very good stick for the money.
2413
Monday, March 5, 2012 10:04:28 PM

these new Vigilante's are not that good. With other good Corojo's like the Cask Strength, Padilla Miami, Serie '68, Gran Habano Vintage 2002, or Blend #5 offered here for less then $3per, no need to except lower quality. However, I have not smoked any with more then a month's humidor time so maybe they may get better.

Sonnyf78
Tuesday, March 6, 2012 9:07:43 AM

DUDE! Where ya been!

fishinguitarman wrote:

I'm around. I browse obviously more than I post. I should bomb you for old times sake!