Two stories ... One, my non-discerning neighbor will smoke absolutely ANYthing and pronounce it a good cigar ... he actually bought Hobos and claimed to like them, but then he drinks wine that comes packaged in a box and likes that too ... after seeing him leave a good cigar half smoked, I vowed to never give him another and I do his picking for him by having one "ready" when I know he's coming or go to get him "a good one" while he pours the wine if I don't have forewarning of his arrival ...
The other concerns a friend who is really a cigarette smoker, but will smoke a cigar from time to time. He has NO idea of what's good and what's not and will typically only smoke cigars that are given to him ... I doubt he's ever bought one on his own ... at his "getaway" home a couple of weekends ago, he invited me behind his bar and proudly showed me his "cigar collection" ... 3 sad smokes in a box ... one, a tubo labled "Hawaiian It's a Boy!", one Gacia y Vega and a Baccarat ... he asked if those were pretty good cigars ... I told him the Baccarat had the best chance of being good, and he asked how long they'd stay good in the paperboard cigar box he had 'em stashed in ... I asked how long they'd been there and he said oh, I dunno, probably no more than a few months ... I was able to maintain a straight face, but advised him he really should get them humidified or smoke them pretty soon ... then, this past weekend, he crestfallenly told me his teenaged son had raided his cigars ... the Baccarat was gone and only the Hawaiian tubo and Garcia y Vega remained ... I told him he ought to make the kid smoke both the others back to back and inhale them both as punishment ...