Gannett News Service
WASHINGTON -- The Federal Trade Commission is supposed to be big oil's watchdog.
But as oil and gas companies restructured from industry doldrums over the past decade, the FTC approved a string of mergers and acquisitions that agency critics claim have helped create $3-a-gallon gas and record oil profits.
The result is less competition among large oil companies and a consolidated refining industry that has maximized earnings by keeping gas supply tight so that any disruption, be it a pipeline break or hurricane, can cause a shortage.
After dozens of federal and state investigations, no one in authority is saying anything illegal has happened.
"This is a very sophisticated industry," said California Attorney General Bill Lockyer, who successfully fought to keep a major refinery open. "Because of the lack of competition, they don't need to break the law."
Some energy analysts, consumer advocates and lawmakers blame the FTC for allowing this kind of consolidation. These critics contend the FTC either lacks the will, the legal tools, or both, to adequately regulate the oil and refining industries.
FTC officials argue they have been tougher on oil and gas companies than with many other industries in large part because of the basic necessity of gas. They contend the oil and gas industries are no more consolidated than other major sectors and that the government is limited by antitrust laws in how far it can go to block or alter mergers and aggressive industry practices.
"There's a lot of anger and a lot of mystification out there. We're aware of that," said John Seesel, the FTC's associate general counsel for energy. "We take very seriously our mission to find anti-competitive behavior."
Some of the criticism of the FTC comes down to differences between what the agency and consumer advocates consider anti-competitive and how that has affected oil and gas deals, government oversight and ultimately gas prices.
Mergers, memos
A Gannett News Service analysis of oil and gas company deals and practices and FTC oversight found:
-- Between 2001 and 2004, the FTC approved 28 of 33 mergers totaling $20 billion without any of the special conditions often required to retain industry competition, according to FTC records.
-- Under FTC supervision, gas markets in 27 states have consolidated so they're technically classified as "tight oligopolies," or markets where four companies or fewer control 60 percent or more of the gas, according to a report by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations.
Hurricane Katrina demonstrated just how tight the gas market has become as competition has dwindled. As some refineries shut down, gas supplies fell, prices soared and so did industry profits -- up 92 percent in 2005 for top independent gas refiners and sellers, according to a congressional study.
-- Gas suppliers have intentionally limited fuel supplies during price spikes to maximize profits, according to FTC reports. A 2001 commission report on gas price spikes in the Midwest found part of the cause to be "decisions by firms to maximize their profits (curtailing production, keeping available supply off the market)." This is legal so long as there is no collusion between companies while doing it.
A 1999 internal document from BP discusses a variety of tactics for reducing supply, including cutting sales deals "in exchange for capacity shutdown," shipping products to Canada and lobbying for environmental regulations that would slow the movement of gas in pipelines. Company officials said this was merely "brainstorming."
Some lawmakers now believe this kind of supply manipulation should be illegal or at least discouraged. But as Luke Froeb, the FTC's chief economist until last year, recently pointed out, "Everybody maximizes profits -- that's what you do. Nobody has demonstrated that there's anything untoward going on in this industry."
The FTC and state regulators have undertaken more than two-dozen investigations of the oil industry over 20 years and have yet to find any major wrongdoing. This was proudly cited by Red Cavaney, president of the American Petroleum Institute, during a recent media briefing.
FTC officials would not comment on Cavaney's statement, but they did not dispute its basic assertion or numbers.
Cavaney's boasting raised red flags for some lawmakers about how aggressive the FTC has been -- not only in analyzing mergers but in probing complaints of gas gouging after Katrina and investigating practices such as zone pricing, where refiners sell gas to distributors at different prices to exert greater control over a particular geographic market.
"This is a very savvy industry and they now have sympathetic regulators," said Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., who has repeatedly prodded the FTC to be more concerned about consumers.
Tools of the trade
Regulating the oil and gas industries is done within the confines of antitrust laws that outline what are considered anti-competitive practices. Those include bid rigging, predatory pricing, price fixing, collusion and organized group boycotts, but they do not include simply withholding gas to raise prices.
The FTC often must find evidence of collusion to make a case that oil or gas companies are illegally manipulating prices, and this can be exceedingly difficult. Oil and gas companies now typically use third-party consultants and their own sophisticated marketing models to analyze price movements and calculate their ideal position. They're so large and well positioned, they don't need to collude, industry analysts say.
Often what appears to be cheating to the average consumer -- oil companies reaping huge profits after a hurricane, for example -- is perfectly legal.
"There may be something people object to, but it doesn't violate antitrust law," said FTC's Seesel. "We have got to be able to show facts."
That said, when asked by lawmakers if it needs more regulatory authority, the FTC's consistent response has been that the antitrust laws now on the books are adequate.
When scrutinizing merger proposals, the FTC uses economic models to analyze the potential effects on competition, prices and innovation in a series of regional and product markets, such as wholesale and retail gas.
Often mergers are approved only with recommendations, including the sell-off of assets to lessen monopolistic effects.
But agency critics claim huge oil company mergers need to be looked at differently because some produce massive conglomerates that control an indispensable commodity from the source to the consumer -- the wellhead to the pump -- in a way virtually no other industry does.
Some mergers produce conglomerates so large and influential, such as ExxonMobil, they practically force other companies to follow suit or perish. That further threatens competition, critics say.
"I would like to see the calculation of what preserves competition more forward-looking," said Preston McAfee, a Caltech economist and a consultant to the FTC.
Strengthening antitrust codes would require action on Capitol Hill, where oil companies wield tremendous influence, as was recently demonstrated.
After gas prices hit near-record highs in the spring and oil profits broke corporate records, some lawmakers proposed repealing the tax breaks for oil companies enacted in 2005 to encourage exploration.
In the end, only small changes were made: It will take longer for oil companies to recoup their tax breaks. But they will still get most of them.