I used to live on St. Thomas and I also visited St. John, Never went to St. Croix, but I remember at night sometime I could see distant fires that a neighbor told me were refinery stacks on St. Croix.
I wouldn't imagine St. Croix is any different from St. Thomas or St. John regarding the water, flora, fauna, etc.
The islands are very dry, the vegetation rough & thorny except for what's been added by gardeners. The waters however are fabulous. Not the clearest, but pretty clear, visibility maybe 45-60 feet.
Honestly I'd recommend St. Thomas. It's the most populated I believe, more to do there, and St. John, which was almost a virgin paradise is just a couple of minutes away. They're all nice though, nice & tropical.