Dragan187
Monday, July 31, 2006 5:13:00 AM
Got a 10 year old who wants to play guitar. (Electric) Thinking about getting him an "ibanez" brand. Is that a decent starter guitar or is there something better?
RICKAMAVEN
Monday, July 31, 2006 5:25:00 AM
Dragan187

my son ross knows more about guitars than anyone.

the first thing he will ask is what the hell does

a 10 year old need an electric guitar.

if he wants to learn to play guitar, he should start with an acoustical guitar that is not expensive so when you end up putting it in the garage because now he wants a drum set, you won't be out much money.

i will however forward this to ross and ask him for his suggestions.

when he was 12 or 13 and wanted a guitar, i gave him an old uke and a sopng book i had laying around and told him to learn how to play 4 string first.

i'll be back at you.

Dragan187
Monday, July 31, 2006 5:59:00 AM
Yo RICK,

Thanks for the response. I pondered the acoustic vs. electric theory. Here are the pros i received.

1. Electric is easier to play

2. Less likely for finger bleeding.

3. More interest = more practice

I was raised with the same mentality. If you want to play guitar, start with acoustic because it is more of a stand alone instrument. Problem is, an acoustic guitar is associated with "country" and my boy is into rock. He wants no pqart of it. From the things I've read, it says that your kid will retain interest on an instrument he/ she chooses vs. what you make him/ her play. This includes guitars.

andytv
Monday, July 31, 2006 6:41:00 AM
I disagree Rick.

I have been playing since I was 14 years old, and I think I would not have pursued it past idle curiousity if I had started on an acoustic.

Kids want to play the songs they listen to on the radio (or mp3 players nowadays). It is exciting to be able to play along with your guitar heros........and this breeds interest in learning more/practicing. Also......with a 10 yo, you will need to have an aesthetically appealing guitar as well.

Ibanez is a decent Japanese guitar (or was....I haven't bought a guitar in years).

Be aware though, that you get what you pay for. I think just about every guitar maker makes a starter guitar in the $150 range, an I imagine they are all about the same quality.

If I were you, I'd visit an established guitar shop and listen to their recommendations........even buy used......you could possibly get a better guitar at a lower price.

If you don't want to invest in an expensive amplifier, there are some pretty cool headphone amps out there (one called POD comes to mind) with tons of really cool digital effects........these can be used as preamps/effects processors for larger amplifiers later down the road.

dave97402
Monday, July 31, 2006 7:30:00 AM
The Ibanez is still a decent guitar. That would be a fine choice for begining. They have a lot of choices for cheap small amps that would give a good sound without costing a fortune.

10 years old....good time to get started, and yes, if it was a accoustic he would lose interest fast. He may still lose interest, but being electric has a better chance of staying with it and having fun. I started at 12...that was....um..holy crap. Never mind.

Hope he enjoys it and sticks with it!!

Dave

phurley66
Monday, July 31, 2006 9:45:00 AM
If you go the electric route, be careful of whammy bars on entry level gear. They can make it much more challenging to keep in tune.
andytv
Monday, July 31, 2006 9:59:00 AM
^ yeah..........unscrew it and hide the handle before he figures out what it is.
gerber
Monday, July 31, 2006 10:03:00 AM
I started with classical guitar, but always wanted to play electric. As soon as I saved enough money, I bought a telecaster copy for $100 and have never looked back. So when my 16 year old wanted to learn to play electric guitar a couple years back, we didn't take the acoustic route. He purchased a cheap electric to start with and a tiny amp; more recently, ge upgraded to a Mexican-made Fender strat that's a real beauty. Probably the best solution for your son is to take him to a larger guitar emporium and let him play different makes. At 10 year old, his fingers are probably still pretty small, so you might want to think about a make with somewhat narrower neck and tighter frets. Also, conisder light-gauge strings in the beginning--true, they break more easily and lose tuning more quickly, but your son will have the fun of doing bends and vibratos with more ease in the beginning. Ibanez is always a fine choice, although you can also get some decent entry-level Strats pretty inexpensively. More than likely, if he truly gets the bug, he will be figuring out ways to upgrade in a couple years.
echo4alpha
Monday, July 31, 2006 10:41:00 AM
Find a used Squire Bullet. It's the entry level Stratocaster by Fender. It'll be dirt cheap and if the kid gets tired of it, you can sell it off without losing much.
Cigarick
Monday, July 31, 2006 10:47:00 AM
http://www.americanmusical.com/sort.aspx?electric=guitars&m=02_46 

They have starter packages including a guitar, small amp, book, etc. for less than $150.

Dgar
Monday, July 31, 2006 12:03:00 PM
Cigars and Guitars... Two of my favorite things.

Electric or Accoustic either can be easily played if set up correctly, let the music your son enjoys be your guide. I think there's and advantage to learning accoustic first, but I'm biased thats all I play.

Lessons are great.... with the right teacher!

Good luck to your son, 10 is the perfect age to start. I have a ten year old son that shows no interest, I've tried explaining that guitarist get all the " hot chicks" but he's still to young to appreciate that theory, plus he's seen where my guitar playing has gotten me with the ladies (maybe I need more lessons") ...

Dgar

Buckwheat
Monday, July 31, 2006 12:18:00 PM
http://www.taylorguitars.com/guitars/model.aspx?model=305 

If he doesn't take it up you will get your money back out of it if you decide to sell it. This really is a nice guitar (I have one...along with 1/2 dozen others).

IMO I wouldn't get him anything if you don't also take him to a good teacher (at least for the first 1/2 year to a year).

Nylon/classical guitars are also nice. I have one of these (http://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/SLG100N/). It can be played "silently" through headphones and it sounds great.

Whoever said skip the tremolo speaks the truth. Absolutely stupid on a beginner guitar.

http://www.peavey.com/products/browse.cfm/action/detail/item/113217/number/00461960/cat/64/begin/1/Backstage%AE.cfm 

Nice to have a CD input on the amp so you can play along with a CD.

RICKAMAVEN
Monday, July 31, 2006 1:58:00 PM
andytv

that head set idea is perfect.

RICKAMAVEN
Monday, July 31, 2006 2:04:00 PM
slight thread jack.

has anyone ever heard that ditsy charo play. she is fantastic,

Charo studied classical and flamenco guitar while residing in Murcia. As a result of her training and skill she has been named "Best Flamenco Guitarist" in Guitar Player Magazine's readers' poll. Although she professionally mangles the English language on-stage, she can read and write it fluently; Charo is also fluent in Japanese, French, and Spanish.

As a young girl, she studied guitar under Andres Segovia,

fretkillr
Monday, July 31, 2006 2:13:00 PM
Dragan,

Here's my two cents:

Learning to play on an acoustic makes the electric so much easier to play--so if your kid wants to go to an acoustic from an electric sometime later, those barre chords will be very difficult.

Also, the fingers will hurt, yes, but they'll also develop the callouses much quicker. My daughter wanted to play, so I gave her a cheapie classical, and then she tried on my steel string, and about 9 months later, she was ripping it up on my Strat.

And...to buy anything, two words: "E-Bay"

Stuart

BeatDragon
Monday, July 31, 2006 2:29:00 PM
Yes,

Charo is a fantastic player. Studied with the best.

Epiphone Les Paul or SG Junior.

Look on the Musicians Friend web site. Decent packages that include amps. gig bags, strings, strap etc etc...

Guitarist in my band has been teaching for 10 years, says it doesnt matter what the guitar is, as long as its playable and the kid is truly interested.

StogeeBoy
Monday, July 31, 2006 4:13:00 PM
I have an acoustic electric Alverez that's pretty slammin
Seth Gekko
Monday, July 31, 2006 5:47:00 PM
The entry level electrics are pretty much all the same quality nowadays . . . . you could go Ibanez, Squire, Epiphone . . . . For $200, it's all the same . . . . I have a Korean Ibanez that cost $225, that plays wonderfully . . . . . . it's great advice to avoid the Tremolo . . . it has absolutely no redeeming value for learning to play, and, changing strings with them can be hell . . . .

IMO, for a 10 year old, electric would be a better choice, because it'd hold his interest . . . . Lessons are a must . . . from a competent instructor!! I've seen guitar teachers who spend 75% of their lessons, just playing and showing off . . . . . I'm in Upstate NY, and selling my Ibanez and 10 watt amp for $175 . . . . also, like BD said, musiciansfriend.com is a great place for entry level setups . . . .

Good luck . . .

Dgar
Tuesday, August 1, 2006 11:02:00 AM
As far as acoustics being harder to play, I'm sure its true, but a well set up accoustic should play like butter, mine is set up so well I cant imagine it being much easier to play. I like the Taylor Big Baby suggestion, or you may want to look into an OM model a little smaller than a dred, but it still can produce plenty of sound.

Dgar

Dgar

Dragan187
Tuesday, August 1, 2006 12:08:00 PM
I'm seriously considering taking "echo4alpha's" advice and going for the squire. It's made by Fender and the reviews look good. Top off the 99.00 price with free shipping and it looks like lil Jr. will be set.

Now I just need an amp.