jetblasted
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 9:13:00 AM
British model puts freedom, rights at risk

By BOB BARR - Published on: 08/16/06

American historian Thomas Fleming wrote an essay a few years ago that appeared in a book titled "What If?" The book contains a number of essays by prominent writers and historians speculating on how history might be altered had certain decisions and circumstances happened differently. Fleming analyzes 13 events that could have changed history during our War for Independence, resulting in a British victory and the premature end of our struggle for freedom from the British crown.

Judging by the manner in which many 21st century American pundits have been clamoring for our country to jettison the Bill of Rights and adopt the British model — according to which the government can listen in to whomever it wants and gather evidence without having to first establish a reasonable basis to believe the person or persons did something wrong — it appears many of these modern-day Tories wished Britain had in fact defeated the Colonies way back then.

This latest round of Anglo adoration stems from the fact that British authorities apparently were instrumental in uncovering last week's plot to hijack and destroy a number of passenger aircraft by engaging in investigative techniques that would not pass constitutional muster in the United States. This analysis reflects a fundamental lack of understanding of why we fought a war to secure our independence from Great Britain in the first place, and why we have been, since our victory in 1783, a freer people than our former English brethren.

The British have no Bill of Rights; in fact they have no written Constitution. We have both — and I would proudly stack them up against the legal framework of any other nation on earth (including the U.K.). Yet, those championing a loosening of our right against unreasonable searches and seizures and who hope for the Bush administration to enjoy by law the power to listen in on whatever of our conversations it wants whenever it wants, apparently prefer the British model.

In a time of uncertainty and danger such as we face today, it is tempting to cast longing gazes across the Atlantic and yearn for a truly national police and intelligence force that can investigate and arrest citizens with no more than a hunch or a passing suspicion that someone doesn't look right.

In our system — a system crafted in opposition to Britain's by our Founding Fathers nearly two and a quarter centuries ago — the government must satisfy certain minimal burdens before it can peruse our e-mails, open our letters, search our homes or listen to our private conversations.

Before we start advocating the dismantling of the Fourth Amendment (or the First, Second, Fifth or Sixth) as necessary to thwarting future terrorist attacks, we might want to remind ourselves just what we'd be giving up, and what little we would be gaining. We might also reflect on a bit of American history, something about which modern Anglo-apologists appear blissfully ignorant.

Americans have long possessed a dangerously short collective memory. The latest crisis or danger, whatever it might be, magically wipes from memory prior events and problems. The most immediate problem becomes the most serious ever faced. Thus, the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, have become for government officials and advocates of the so-called "British model" the "most serious crisis ever faced by the American people." The fact is, Sept. 11 was not the most serious crisis we've faced as a nation.

In the first decades following the Revolutionary War, our infant nation's very existence was threatened directly and massively by Britain, which at the time maintained a military hugely superior to ours and wielded economic power that far overshadowed our nascent economy.

Yet despite these direct and massive threats to the very existence of our country (which included an actual invasion in the War of 1812), our Founding Fathers and ultimately a strong majority of our citizens determined that our continued freedom and sovereignty did not lie in the British model of virtually unlimited government power over the individual citizen's privacy.

They — as should we today — correctly concluded that in America, we survive and flourish as a free people not by constantly searching for ways to make government's job easier, but by forcing it to adhere strictly to laws and fundamental principles based on citizens' rights, not government's.

Even during other crises America has faced — the Civil War, or the First and Second World Wars — which also represented far more serious problems than posed by our Sept. 11 tormentors, America resisted the urge to dismantle the Bill of Rights in the search for the Holy Grail of "safety."

It is a shame we have forgotten so much in the past generation that we are now witnessing a resurgence of the insecurity that emboldened Tory sympathizers to nearly scuttle our Revolution before it had barely begun.

HockeyDad
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 9:54:00 AM
Jetblasted,

Have you become a stinking liberal? This essay runs contrary to many of the opinions you have expressed in the past.

rugrunner
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 9:59:00 AM
Jet's personal hygiene is too good for him to become a stinking liberal.

A well quaffed liberal maybe.

usahog
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 10:29:00 AM
http://www.reason.com/0312/cr.jw.bob.shtml 

I agree with him(Bob Barr) on many aspects...

but it has to make one think, with as many elected politicians we have in office today.. that these folks cannot come up with a solution TOGETHER to

A) Secure this Country from Threat! terrorism or otherwise

B) not erode away our Constitutional Rights while doing A above??

Hog

jetblasted
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 10:54:00 AM
I posted this for RICK . . .

He is convinced that BOTL Bob Barr is the Anti-Christ . . .

jetblasted
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 10:59:00 AM
And, although I haven't showered today, but will within the next hour, thank you for asking . . .

I am a Moderate, with Conservative Leanings ...

NOT a Liberal . . .

jetblasted
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 11:02:00 AM
usahog
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 11:14:00 AM
I'm a Patriot!

Hog

RICKAMAVEN
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 8:34:00 PM
jetblasted 5

i would not cinsider the use of the word anti-christ,

this country has always profiled. do you remember when at the start of a movie they woud show th3e characters and the audience could boo or yell horray.

the villan always had that little lip mustach, like bob barr ther mouth behind the impeachment.

He has been married three times -- his second divorce involved a trial in which he lied about his long-term adulterous relationship with a woman named Jerri Dobbin, whom Barr eventually made his third wife. After the divorce, Barr's child support failings led his ex-wife Gail to provide details of her abortion to Larry Flynt.

Barr has been embroiled in controversy several times during his career. In 1998 he delivered the keynote speech at the national convention of the Council of Conservative Citizens, which is viewed by many as white supremacist; he later stated he had not known the group's views until after the speech. His speech did not deal with race, however, and Barr publicly distanced himself from the council. Barr has also suffered attacks for his conservative stance on family values, which left-wing periodical Mother Jones deemed hypocritical: "Married three times and embroiled in a messy court battle with his second wife over his failure to pay child support, Barr had been photographed in 1992 licking whipped cream off two buxom young women's [breasts and nipples]. And this from the man who would later sponsor the Defense of Marriage Act." In the wake of Barr's adamant support for the impeachment of Bill Clinton, porn mogul Larry Flynt paid Barr's second wife, Gail Vogel Barr, for details of the child support battle and of her abortion. This caused significant political troubles for Barr, noted for his strong pro-life stance.

BOO the villan

rugrunner
Wednesday, August 16, 2006 8:40:00 PM
I am not a number, I am a free man!