teeitupforgolf
Saturday, August 19, 2006 9:33:00 AM
I have a couple of questions about cuban cigars. First what makes them better than any other cigar? And second, do cuban cigars have their version of dog rockets?
sw48362
Saturday, August 19, 2006 9:54:00 AM
Cuban Cigars

First what makes them better than any other cigar?

Who said they are better. It's All about your own taste profile requirements. Some buy into the hype, some are just after the taste. You can find great cigars made in many different countries, and the leaf grown in a variety of places around the world that are great cigars.

Second, do cuban cigars have their version of dog rockets? Every cigar producing country produce dog rockets. But again a dog rocket to one person is just pure heaven to others.

Now that I have your attention: Uh, I'd like to borrow $5,000.

andytv
Saturday, August 19, 2006 10:03:00 AM
Taste is subjective, so you cannot categorically say that that Cuban cigars are better than cigars made with tobacco from other countries.

There are a great deal of very fine Cuban cigars IMHO though, and "domestic" producers seem to put a lot of effort into associating themselves with Cuba in some way or another (Cuban seed, rolled the old Cuban way, etc).

In MOST cases, if given the choice between a $5 cuban and a $5 domestic, I'll pick the Cuban.......but that is just me.

I have never had a Cuban cigar that I would call a "dog rocket"; I have smoked several short-filler machine made Cuban cigars that cost $2 or less each.......but these have actually been pretty tasty.

usahog
Saturday, August 19, 2006 10:07:00 AM
wrong forum... LOL

Cuban Cigars IMO have a much better taste/smoke profile than any other brands I have smoked. I think it would relate to the Region/Climate and seed of Tabacco.. although I find many Nicuraguan (sp) cigars running a close second and some I have found to be just as good and better then other Cubans out there...

as stated above, yes I have experienced dog rockets in cuban lines.. This question reflects to dates of product Age and many other factors IE: Tasters profile...

Hog

RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, August 19, 2006 11:10:00 AM
the forbidden fruit, is sweeter then all other fruit.

before the embargo cuban cigars represented less then 25% of the market in this country and that was before the growers who cared for the land left the country

a little info about cuban tobacco and it's current problems

Pinar del Rio, Cuba, Sept. 7 -- In hopes of boosting its production of tobacco leaf used for premium cigars, Cuban agricultural officials and outside tobacco experts from Spain may have violated the basic tenant, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it.''

New barns built with asphalt shingles instead of palm thatch have caused at least some of the February-March harvest to be infected by a mold, growers have reported.

As Havana's premium cigar factories began idling workers last winter at a time when the island's cigar production was usually in full swing, it became clear there was an acute shortage of prime tobacco wrapper, the large shade-grown leaves used on some of the most sought after and expensive Cuban cigars.

The leaf shortages, still apparent this summer at factories like Havana's La Corona and Partagas, have been attributed to everything from bad weather to theft.

While nature and a hunger to supply product to Cuba's counterfeit cigar market have contributed to the leaf shortages, attempts to hastily modernize Cuba's tobacco cultivation and harvest practices could also be to blame.

Word out of Pinar del Rio province, the center for Cuba's cigar tobacco production, is that stockpiles of wrapper leaf (Capa) are dwindling and the February-March harvest, while good, didn't completely match expectations.

As a result, some Cuban tobacco and cigar experts predict the lack of supply will continue to slow factory production of large cigars such as Double Coronas, Churchills and the seemingly scarce Cuban Piramides.

Because Cuban cigar sales are the island's third largest producer of hard currency, behind tourism and sugar, it's difficult to get Cuban agricultural and tobacco officials to go on record defining the exact cause of the leaf shortages, or even admit there is one.

What seems clear is that some zealous government officials, seeking to boost tobacco production, attempted to alter traditional Cuban methods for curing harvested wrapper leaves.

Throughout Pinar del Rio province, 2.5 hours southwest of Havana, are small triangular shaped curing barns in the middle of lush tobacco fields.

These barns usually have thatched palm roofs and sides, and some are open at both ends. Inside, resting on dirt floors, are wooden poles that rise to the ceiling and extend horizontally.

On these poles, the harvested wrapper leaf is left to hang (in bunches called "hands'') and dry.

On the bigger tobacco farms, like those of Don Alejandro Robaina, the province's largest exporter of wrapper leaf to the Havana factories, the barns are larger and are similar to those found on farms in the U.S., Canada and Europe.

Even the more modern looking curing barns have thatched roofs, to keep the elements out while allowing air to circulate through the barn, thus promoting drying of the tobacco leaves.

Private tobacco growers in Pinar del Rio (yes, there are private growers in Cuba) claim because a lot of the February- March harvest was cured in new barns built with asphalt shingles instead of palm thatch, the traditional air curing process was altered and much of the crop was infected with a mold.

The mold, not the dreaded "Blue Mold'' that devastates crops in the field, developed and spread inside the barns because the asphalt roofs trapped both heat and humidity.

It's ironic that Cuba's new wrapper leaf plant, the Habano 2000 hybrid, was developed because of its resistance to crop killers like Blue Mold. Yet, the highly touted H2000 leaf was attacked by mold after it was harvested and infected in what's traditionally a safe haven, the curing barn.

Some Cuban tobacco experts claim about 20 percent of the 1999-2000 crop was ruined by the mold, though there are no official figures available.

Some cigar retailers in Havana said the asphalt shingled roof combined with the use of new heaters in the barns was expected to speed at drying and curing process.

"It's a problem, that's for sure, but I'm not sure that it's as bad as some people are making it out to be,'' said a major Havana cigar retailer who wants to remain anonymous. "It would be good propaganda for other cigar producing countries and enemies of Cuba to say we (the factories and shops) are short of leaf and lacking good cigars, but that's an exaggeration.''

Recent visitors to Cuba have reported fairly good selections of larger cigars, but a Mexican-based Cuban cigar merchant noted there are lingering problems with the supply of leaf.

"The people who roll (cigars) for me in Cuba tell me that last winter's harvest was good but problems developed after the leaves were in the barns,'' said the cigar merchant, who has two shops in eastern Mexico. "I assume the problems had to do with some hiccups from modernization.''

While the extent of these problems will be difficult to pinpoint, it seems safe to say that while boosting premium cigar production through modern means could be good for the Cuban economy, Cuba's time-tested methods for producing some of the finest hand-made cigars on this planet are hanging in the balance.

pacman357
Saturday, August 19, 2006 1:46:00 PM
It seems to me that, given the number of growers who left Cuba and the many lines of cigars available from other locales, that Castro essentially forced growers who left to decide between going out of business or getting creative. I've had a number of lousy cigars, but I've smoked so many good cigars that were made of leaf grown elsewhere, I have to think that Castro's plan may have backfired a bit when he took over a number of plantations and businesses. It'd be nice to have Cubans legal in the U.S. again, but by then they are already going to have some pretty good competition from the likes of Gurkha, Graycliff, Patel, Perdomo, CAO, etc. Not that he caused all of them to develop, just that by the time Cubans are legal here, there's already going to be a lot of other players on the field.

BTW, I've had a couple of cheap Cubans that weren't very good, but I don't think they call them dog rockets there. I think they are cohetes de perros.

RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, August 19, 2006 1:59:00 PM
pacman357

i agree with you. i wouldn't spend ten or fifteen dollars for a cuban cigar. there are plenty of better cigars here at auction for a lot less.

what cuban cigar can beat an onyx mini bellacoso.

pabloescabar
Saturday, August 19, 2006 2:14:00 PM
"what cuban cigar can beat an onyx mini bellacoso"

that's some funny ash chits Rick

teeitupforgolf
Saturday, August 19, 2006 8:20:00 PM
Thanks everyone I have always wondered why the cubans were so sought after and praised. Thanks again for all the input.
Gandalf
Sunday, August 20, 2006 9:05:00 AM
"before the embargo cuban cigars represented less then 25% of the market in this country and that was before the growers who cared for the land left the country

"

True Rick, except that exported cuban tobacco was used in the majority of brands back then.........

Man, how times have changed.

CWFoster
Sunday, August 20, 2006 8:27:00 PM
One reason that the Cubanos can't be fully duplicated anywhere else in the world, is because of a DEPLETION of potassium in Cubas soil. If there was some mineral present that was lacking elsewhere, it could be added and duplicate the soil conditions, but save for starting a huge hydroponic farm, you would never find a place that has virtually NO potassium in the dirt.
MACS
Sunday, August 20, 2006 9:14:00 PM
I believe you're referring to MAGNESIUM. Not postassium.
jetblasted
Monday, August 21, 2006 4:26:00 AM
Pinar del Rio, Cuba, Sept. 7 -- In hopes of boosting its production of tobacco . . .

RICK, just when was this written ?

JonR
Monday, August 21, 2006 4:51:00 AM
"what cuban cigar can beat an onyx mini bellacoso."

All of them.

JonR

jpotts
Monday, August 21, 2006 8:04:00 AM
RICKAMAVEN:

re #5 - Interesting. I hadn't read that, but it doesn't suprise me.

re #7: Agreed.

JonR:

Frickin' commie...

(no, I'm not being serious).

miketv
Monday, August 21, 2006 12:41:00 PM
Actually, Potassium is commonly missing or nearly missing in soils due to it's mobile nature. It is often the first nutrient to leach away, though magnesium closely follows it. This is why many fertilizers have such high amounts of Potassium, and tropical fertilizers, like those for plams, have extra Mg and Mn in the tune of 3%-4%.

Just my two cents on soil quality.

MIke

miketv
Monday, August 21, 2006 12:41:00 PM
palms, not plams
miketv
Monday, August 21, 2006 12:41:00 PM
palms, not plams
andytv
Monday, August 21, 2006 12:43:00 PM
so I should NOT be using a potassium fertilyzer for my plams?
miketv
Monday, August 21, 2006 12:47:00 PM
screw you hippie