jetblasted
Sunday, August 27, 2006 12:10:00 PM
Forty nine people died Sunday morning when a Comair "Delta Connection" commuter jet crashed shortly after takeoff from Lexington, Ky., on a flight to Atlanta.

Please keep the family members of the victims in your prayers.

Thank You . . .

-Derek

Pufferbelle
Sunday, August 27, 2006 12:22:00 PM
I read about this tragedy. My prayers and thoughts are with the victim's families as they try and get through the coming days and horrors.

PAS

Suzi

erkwgz
Sunday, August 27, 2006 1:52:00 PM
Happened pretty close to me. Last I knew no idea what happened, weather conditions were prety good.

Any news Jet?

jetblasted
Sunday, August 27, 2006 2:53:00 PM
They took off on the wrong runway . . .

Flight 5191 was cleared for takeoff at 6:05 a.m. ET, which was the last communication between the pilot and air-traffic controllers at the airport, Federal Aviation Administration officials said.

The plane crashed about a half-mile from the end of the runway, said Bornhorst, Comair's president.

Two sources told CNN that radar identifying the plane's location shortly before it crashed indicates that it took off from the wrong runway -- one that was 3,500 feet shorter than the other.

The Bombardier Canadian Regional Jet (CRJ)-200 was cleared to take off from runway 22, which is more than 7,000 feet long, the sources said.

Instead, it took off from runway 26, which is 3,500 feet long, the sources said.

That length is "pretty short for that type of aircraft," former National Transportation Safety Board Vice Chairman Bob Francis told CNN.

From what I gather, the plane stalled on take-off due to lack of airspeed / lift . . .

If vee2plus20 was here, I'm sure he could give some more in-depth analysis . . .

The only thing I can figure is just Human Error.

They took off on Runway 22, which is 3,500 ft long. They should have taken off of Runway 26, which is twice that length . . .

Runways are set-up on a 360 degree circle, like a compass. Airports build runways based on historical prevailing winds in the given area. Lots of runways are built Due East and West, which means the runway is called Runway 9 / 27 . . . Based on the compass reading, the Runway 9 would be 90 degrees and the opposite end would be Runway 27 or 270 degrees on the compass. This is so you can line up on landing, ect ...

I can only speculate that when the aircraft got to the end of the airport, they weren't paying attention, and went to the wrong one.

Pilots have Jepsen Manuals, which are maps of the aiport and approach and departure patterns. I guess they weren't checked. There was a Cockpit Jump Seat Rider, which means an additional crew member was riding up front. (Maybe they weren't paying attention and were chatting it up.)

I checked the Flight Plan of an Extra Section that was flown into Atlanta today, and I read the NOTAMS (Notice to Airmen) to see what the physical airport conditions were, and did see that there was listed construction on Runway 4 Threshold causing a 500 Foot Displacement.

This is specualtion on my part, too, because I can't understand all the Flight Plan Abbreviations . . .

There's no telling.

There is certain that several failures were allowed to continue to this conclusion ...

You have to wonder about the Control Tower, I question ASA Dispatchers who wrote the Flight Plan and what was going on in the Cockpit ...

I guess we will have to wait until the NTSB gives it's final word, and that can take months.

Right now they have the Cockpit Voice and Data Recorders. They should yield plenty of clues . . .

It is a tragic event.

I'll be willing to bet that crew rest played a pivotal role, though . . .

-ADJ

CNN just reported from the press conference that the Hotel showed them checking in at 10pm. Which means that they were pushing their minimum rest period.

( They were tired and sleepy )

jetblasted
Sunday, August 27, 2006 2:55:00 PM
I said ASA Dispatchers and I meant COMAIR . . .

If a runway is 36 / 18 that means it was built Due North and South . . .

http://www.fltplan.com/AirportInformation/LEX.htm 

andytv
Sunday, August 27, 2006 3:00:00 PM
3500' is a pretty short runway.

why bother with such a short runway?

00camper
Sunday, August 27, 2006 4:03:00 PM
Why bother with a 3500 foot runway? The answer is that the Lexington, Kentucky airport is small. I might even use the word tiny.
jetblasted
Sunday, August 27, 2006 4:47:00 PM
Lexington Airport was built in the early 40's and runway lengths back then didn't have to be super long based on aircraft of the day . . .

I would venture to guess that the short runway, as with many, many commercial airports that still have short runways, was used primarily for General Aviation, ie; Cessnas and Beechcraft Aircraft . . .

rodehog56
Sunday, August 27, 2006 5:53:00 PM
I am not a rocket scientist.

Small aircrat=small runway

Large aircrat=large runway

rodehog56
Sunday, August 27, 2006 5:53:00 PM
I am not a rocket scientist.

Small aircrat=small runway

Large aircraft=large runway

rodehog56
Sunday, August 27, 2006 5:54:00 PM
I am not a rocket scientist.

Small aircraft=small runway

Large aircraft=large runway

rodehog56
Sunday, August 27, 2006 5:54:00 PM
I got it right the third time!
dup
  • dup
  • Herf-A-Holic
Sunday, August 27, 2006 6:16:00 PM
I just got back home from down in Lexington where it happened. it was terrible!

Me and Susan was going to get up and have breakfast and be on the road by 9:30 or 10 , but with that happening we decided to wait till this afternoon.

I went down to visit my brother and meet up with a good friend of his that just started on here......so it was a little mini-herf sort-of.

It was a real tradegy!!!

Two on board had just gotten married the day before and were going on thier Honeymoon! damn shame!!!!

deepest prayers go out to "all" thier loved ones and families from the flight.

andytv
Monday, August 28, 2006 4:55:00 AM

I have a bit of training and experience in the quality assurance field; and you gotta realize if something CAN go bad, then at some point in time it WILL go bad. When lives are at stake you have an even greater responsibility to "mistake proof" your process (the Japanese call it Poke Yoke).

The reason I commented that it seems dumb to have such a short runway is that it increases the chance of this sort of accident. Small planes can land/takeoff on big runways, but not the opposite. If this was not an active runway, forty nine more people would be alive right now.

Let the Cessnas and Pipers land at any number of smaller airpots in the world.

Bluedevil
Monday, August 28, 2006 5:37:00 AM
The reason for that small runway is Keeneland Race track and private planes.

# 3 where do you set, I'm in Union, KY.

We cryed then prayed at the Burnett Plantation.

We attend both spring and fall events at Keelenland, the finest racetrack in the world!

Gene363
Monday, August 28, 2006 6:36:00 AM
Andy,

I agree with your point, however not all cities can afford separate airport for general aviation. I would imagine there are signs posted indicating the runway Id, perhaps guide lamps and probably markings painted on the runway itself. I wonder what visual traffic control the control tower had to assure the plane was on the correct runway.

Some sort of electronic sensor system to match plane to runway is feasible.

Things should be idiot proof as possible; however, some times automating basic tasks make an operator or pilot rely on technology instead of making a simple visual validation, e.g., flap settings. For the individual it is called Darwin’s Law, but for an airline pilot it is a tragedy in waiting.

jetblasted
Monday, August 28, 2006 7:14:00 AM
"mistake proof" the process is having two pilots . . .

But, obviously that wasn't enough . . .

Aircraft are full of redundancies, and ATC will be questioned, too . . .

PLUS, there was an off duty pilot on the flight deck . . .

Like a Snowball rolling down hill . . .

Buckwheat
Monday, August 28, 2006 8:00:00 AM
Sucks. I'm in Louisville and it was all over the news all day yesterday. My thoughts and prayers go out to family and friends who were aboard the flight.
Charlie
Monday, August 28, 2006 8:26:00 AM
Network opened the Emmy's with a simulated plane crash, poor taste.....another reason I do not watch the major networks.

Pray for the victims and the sole survivor as well!

Charlie

erkwgz
Monday, August 28, 2006 8:57:00 PM
I am 60 miles Southeast of Lexington and the baseball players Uncle lives less than a mile from me and his wifes father runs a big tire store no more than 25 miles away in London Ky. Another passenger owned a very popular roller rink in the same town. Sad,sad,sad situaton.