CWFoster
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 3:53:00 AM
We explored what seemed like worthless desert in the 50's, and thought there might be oil. We drilled exploratory wells, there was! We drilled production wells, we built pipelines, we built refineries... and the Arabs nationalized them ALL!How DARE we try to influencetheir affairs! They wouldn't HAVE to roll in all that filthy money if we hadn't handed them a new industry on a silver platter! Why, they could all be herding their goats and leading a nomadic existance if we hadn't given them their entre into the 20th century! They could have relied on foreign largesse to provide medical treatment for their people! They wouldn't have had the money to send their young men and women to medical schools in the West if they didn't have oil income! They could have stayed in the 17th century, and then good folks like Osama Bin Laden, and the Taliban wouldn't have to try to take them back there! We shouldn't force our way of life, education, healthcare, and agriculture on anyone else! We should start keeping all that to ourselves! (Oh wait, now they have enough educated people to teach each other! Too late! we've ruined them forever!) SHAME ON US!

Feel better Adroomi?

dkeage
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 4:55:00 AM
true dat
teedubbya
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 5:00:00 AM
all in the name of unselfish kindness
jetblasted
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 5:09:00 AM
Very True Dat . . .
MACS
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 5:16:00 AM
Clive, my friend... we do a lot of things in this world purely to serve our own interests.

That was one of them. Sure, we've done some good things, but we do more things to serve our own interests and try to pawn them off as charity.

Serving our own interests is fine, that's human nature... it's the part where we say we're doing it for honorable reasons that gets us in trouble.

lofty1
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 7:42:00 AM
it's the part where our beneficiaries don't appreciate what's been done for them that bothers me. no, we didn't do that for them, but they are sitting pretty financially as a direct result. if we were evil, we could simply have taken the oil and the land and whatever else we wanted. we didn't. we made them wealthy. how much do they appreciate it? it's hard to say.
Dr Pepperhill
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 9:16:00 AM
The problem with this argument is it suggests if we (America in Saudi Arabia, and the British in Iraq in Libya) hadn't used our technology to sink the wells, drill the oil, ship it away in our tankers, or store it in the storage tanks we built, then the poor Arabs would just be twiddling their thumbs watching their camels fart.

Since history took one path, examining the other path is impossible, still, it is highly unlikely Nations like Saudi Arabia or Iraq, owners of huge oil reserves, would not have somehow been motivated on their own to get that black gold from the ground and take it to market.

And they did. In an agreement with the US (Aramaco), oil drilling in saudi Arabia started in 1938 in return for ownership of part of the company. They found oil alright, but by 1980 the Saudis owned the entire operation. Strictly a business transaction, not a charity operation.

A similar relationship was enacted between Iraq and Bristish oil concerns in 1927.

In Libya too, during WWII the British controlled the area after defeating the Italians. Knowing there were oil reserves there, the Brits drilled for oil and shipped it off for refining and British use. By the time Mu'ammar al-Qadhafi ran the remaining British & Italians off in 1969, the country laid claim to its own oil resources to serve Libya purposes, not England's; the ungreatful basitds!. The Libyans sure didn't say thank you to the British as the door hit them in the ass on the way out.

Each portion of the middle east (with oil reserves)has its own checkered history of interaction with various European technology possessing countries and oil extraction development; but most middle eastern countries manage their own petroleum industries now days, except for Iraq: where the US concern Halliburton, among others, has been rebuilding the infrastructure destroyed in the war.

I imagine the vast majority of Iraqi citizens do not view America's invasion, destruction, and rebuilding of Iraq's petroleum industry as a benevolent human charity, but rather as an invasion and occupation. I doubt, except for a few profiteerers currently stuffing their Swiss accounts, that few Iraqis will lament the future departure of US personnel, and the return of Iraq to Iraqis.

CWFoster
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 11:56:00 AM
Nobody ever said it was supposed to be charity! The implication I was trying to make, is the U.S. is vilified as the bad guys all the time, when the U.S. (and the rest of the world for that matter) is what it is because the European (some of whom deem themselves fit to judge us) ran around for 450 YEARS interferring with other countries and peoples all over the world!Why don't we ask the Algerians what THEY think of the French? Think the Chechans think much of the Russians? Ask a Zimbabwiean about his/her opinion of the Brits! BUT EVERYBODY thinks the U'S. stinks! and it galls me when some of our own people like to sit and say "yep you're right! Our government sucks! We bring all this on ourselves!" So WHAT have all the Euroean countries brough upon themseves? After TWICE trying to dominate all their neighbors, where do Germans come off saying we had no business trying to enforce UN Sanctions in Iraq? I've got a secret. when we re-flagged tankers in the Iran-Iraq War, we didn't just re-flag tankers going to and from U.S. ports, we re-flagged all of them! the purpose was (of couse) to keep oil flowing so that a) EVERYBODIES economies would still function, even the combattants after the fighting was over and b)to try and keep shipping lanes open for EVERYBODY! We built the Panama Canal, and even during WWII we allowed EVERYBODY to use it! We DID have a squadron of ships waiting at the end for a Nazi ship that went through, but they were allowed to transit! Has anybody else done anything like that? I don't think so! Yes we have our own best intresets at heart when we prioritize what we're going to do! NOBODY can even dream they can take care of all the worlds ills! So do we act on something that'll keep the oil flowing, or do something 100% altruistic that will not do us any good in the long run? I like to think that we take care of our own concerns, and a little of what needs doing for it's own sake! Think of Bosnia, Kosovo. BTW, we sides with the MOSLEMS agfainst people who nominally call themselves Christians in those conflicts! Ever wonder why the Jihadist say we always side against the Moslems, and NOBODY ever throws the BS flag? I do! It's because we are the perennial Bad Guys, the ones everybody likes to kick around! And I think it's high time we stood up for ourselves, and called a spade a spade, and if they waant to skling mud, there's pleanty to sling back!
Dr Pepperhill
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 3:26:00 PM
Foster, you yourself point out the US involvement to stop the genocide of Muslems in the Balkans, but don't mistake other criticisms as blanket condemnation.

Some folks are at the fringes, party loyalists, extremists, sh*t disturbers, but criticism of one branch of government, where applicable, by the people or other braanches of government was exactly what the founding fathers had in mind. It was assumed that the seperation of powers of the three branches & the Bill of Rights would keep folks quasi-honest. Seems to be working so far.

Dissent is as American as apple pie and Harleys, unfortunately, to leave the door open for legitimate and constructive dissent we must tolerate destructive dissent; but we know that game when we see it, so no worries.

CWFoster
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 5:51:00 PM
You're missing the main point of this thread Dr. Pepperhill. As some people like to point out, many people overseas dislike 'Americans' Not President Bush, not the Congress, not the Supreme Court...Americans. they think we are arrogant, with no cause, they think we run roughshod all over everybody, and they think we don't care. And SOME Americans like to fashionably agree with them! The purpose of the intitial post was to sarcastically agree with all the 'evil' things we've done 9and NOBODY else has). Things that make life so mserable for those in the countries we've 'meddled' in. This has NOTHING to do with the Bush administration or anybody else in power at this time, as the chic viewpoint is that we've been begging for it for a long time! And what truely agrivates me, is the broken record seems stuck on what we shoudn't have done, but since you cannot undo things that ARE done, where do we go now? But all I ever hear is "well we never shoulda...." NOTHING to suggest what to do, where to go NOW! And these will be the same whiners who will bellyache about the NEXT series of bad decisions! Or maybe they think we should all fall on our collective swords?
Dr Pepperhill
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 7:02:00 PM
Foster maybe it's not so much that I miss your point, but that I'm in dissension with it. I'm attempting to dialogue here, when maybe you really wantr to soliloquize; well here's my soliloquy then.

Too much symbolism and not enough specifics in post #10 to wrap one's mind around. Who or what is 'Americans'? Since no one could ever meet & greet every single American, disliking Americans is an abstract, a reference to a universal symbol. America is the world's super-power, the modern Rome complete with it's storming centurions; how's that for symbolism. Of course many non-super-power nationals, media, etc. are going to resist the dominant paradigm; that's just human nature isn't it? Didn't you ever see Spartacus? You're shocked or upset over that!? Welcome to the primate nature zoo.

As far as the PNAC-ckle guys pulling the wool over the collective masses' eyes, hell yea folks are a bit suspicious now. Oh but lol my friend, let's not dwell on the past, let by gones be by gones, let's laugh and share a drink ... people are looking at this crew with an increasingly jaundiced eye. Seque to moving forward. Trust is significant in moving forward; ask any family law professional. There's wounds here, yea, and I'm not just referring to the 20,000 casualities. Going forward, let's hear the plan ... are we staying the course or adapting now? There's no plan, we're there, civil war's smouldering, civilized societies were already against insane terrorism way before 9-11, the wake up call's been sounded too long and too hard, we hear it, we already knew it; but folks are suspicious and not going to quit being so, and they will complain. People like to complain, a lot; rule #2 in the primate nature zoo.

Continuing with inuendo & symbolism, no collective is going to fall on their sword, but the collective is growing that wants a certain circle of circular circle-jerks to swallow theirs, or GTF out of the way so someone else can have the opportunity to make a plan other than the current Orwellian perpetual war for peace high pressure sales pitch; it's tired, it's lame, and the jaundiced eye crowd's collective eye is getting narrower and yellower. The boy & girls in uniform perform valiantly, so don't confuse the warriors with the suits, of which we need some fresh ones that better suit us.

CWFoster
Tuesday, September 12, 2006 8:29:00 PM
Dr.Pepperhill, I'm not at such total loggerheads with your viewpoint as you think! But before i try to select a new set of 'suits', I want to know, exactly, what their plan is! Sayine we need a change in policy is a broad statement that couold mean anything from all-out regional war, to an immediate withdrawal! WHAT change?

Second, my comments are in reference to our good friend Adroomis seeming usual dinner partners, who constantly complain about "Americans'. Adroomis 'rest of the world' that he likes to refer to. If you think that 'the rest of the world' can't be predjudiced against Americans, why in other threads are you so ready to assume we always are predjudiced? It's a human thing! I talked to a young lady in Mexico about 16 years ago, and she said she didn't like America begause we thought we ought to run everything. She didn't say BUSH, she didn't say Reagan (Clinton hadn't been elected yet) she said AMERICANS! not people in suits! FOCUS good Dr.!

jpotts
Wednesday, September 13, 2006 7:21:00 PM
"...attempting to dialogue here, when maybe you really wantr to soliloquize; well here's my soliloquy then."

"Just when he's got me dead to rights, what does he do? He starts monologing on me!"

jpotts
Wednesday, September 13, 2006 7:29:00 PM
My favorite excuse for hating America is the "foreign policy" policy excuse, which is essentially a net used to recover a multitude of sins. We supported the Shah as part of foreign policy, which the current Iranian regime hated. We turned our back on the Shah, and they still hate us. Some hate us because we've got bases in Saudi Arabia, even though the Saudis asked us to set up bases there. They hate us becase we have bases in Kuwait, even though we liberated that place from Saddam's clutches. And they all hate us because we back Israel - the one and only stable representitive government in the region.

It just goes to show that you can't make everyone like you. So don't bother.

I return to my "terrorism is a big business" credo.

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, September 13, 2006 9:15:00 PM
Christ am I the only one who's seen Spartacus?
burgess_b
Thursday, September 14, 2006 8:44:00 AM
i'm spartacus!
Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 14, 2006 8:49:00 AM
I might be Spartacus too; depends on the slave/Roman ratio.
C-GHOST
Thursday, September 14, 2006 8:55:00 AM
I'm Sportacus from Lazytown.