victor808
Thursday, September 28, 2006 1:56:00 PM
Okay guys, an interesting subject. One which people seem to have strong opinions on either side. I have a simple question, I don't have the answer to this question and I don't even really know where I fall on the entire topic. So, here goes:

If you are in favor of the use of torture for military intelligence, would it also be acceptable for domestic law enforcement officers to use torture in the process of their investigation? Why or why not.

jpotts
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:13:00 PM
victor808:

First, the United States Military does not torture. I abides, and always has, by the standards of the Geneva Convention. The same tough tactics used to interrogate prisoners are the same tough tactics used on out troops during training.

Second, I'm against torturing prisoners, even if they are spies. I do not thing that the practices used at either Gitmo or Abu Garab were torture. No pain was inflicted, there was no bodily harm involved - this is the classic defintion of torture.

Third, seeing that non-uniformed enemy combatants are not covered given the same protections uniformed soldiers under the Gevneva Conventions (in fact, they aren't given any protections at all, I believe), then what happens to them is fair game.

Fouth, we have laws in this country that prohibit torture by police during an investigation, so yes, I'm against torture by police during an interrogation.

andytv
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:17:00 PM
OK, I'll bite.

I say "no".

In the case of war, you have already engaged the enemy with violent interaction, and the information derived from torture can presumably be used to save hundreds/thousands of lives.

In many cases, in a combat situation, the enemy is either shot and killed, shot and wounded, or captured and interrogated. In any case, it is "acceptable" to kill them.

It is not generally accepted for domestic law enforcement to kill perps unless threatened.

Buckwheat
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:20:00 PM
I'm also split on this issue but there is one thing that I'm sure of and that is that I don't want to be tortured.
cigar breath
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:23:00 PM
where do civilized people draw the line? when is it right to torture? as far as the police are concerned---"who will guard the guards?"

make em smoke joya del jefe's all day now that would be torture!

TBWCW
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:42:00 PM
"make em smoke joya del jefe's all day now that would be torture!"

Where's your sense of humanity? You're an evil man.

victor808
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:44:00 PM
Interesting....

I guess this is what made me think about it. We are in a time when the lines are really blurring. People who may be "tortured" (under whatever definition) may not always be the clear cut cases we imagine in the movies (Such as an enemy sargeant in uniform being smacked around a little to find out where the enemy troops are deploying and thus saving millions of good guys lives). It seems to me that since some of these people ARE "non-uniformed enemy combatants" as Jpotts pointed out, we don't really know that they are enemies at all... they aren't wearing a uniform. This means there first has to be a process of identifying with some certainty that they are the enemy, very similar to how police must identify whether someone is a criminal.

There just seem to be some of the same parallels. For instance, standard suspense movie situation: evil serial killer has 100 women in a cellar, they will die in 2 hours unless freed from his nefarious trap... parallels between this situation and those of a "non-uniformed enemy combatant" who has information about a bomb in a market set to go off in 2 hours are pretty clear.

So, in both those cases there is the risk that you have the wrong guy.

Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:45:00 PM
In science, instead of inventing the wheel over & over, great expense & resources is saved by referring to known data.

Likewise, we have thousands of years of history available to test hypotheses against known precedent without having to repeating the same experiences over and over.

Buckwheat, who is loathe to engage in political debate, at least has the sense to realize he doesn't want to be tortured; a wise basis from which the age old concepts of the golden rule, and karma are derived. But let's say a person is highly subjective, regarding their own wellbeing as primary, and the well being of others as secondary, even insignificant. History can be a guide to the very young or highly subjective by showing why the torture of others is bad policy; bad policy, after all, being that which brings harm to self.

Let's take recent history. A middle eastern country, Iraq, led by an iron-fisted dictator named Saddam Hussein. To keep peace in his volatile homeland, he employs brutal torture on those not of his ruling party. Years of injustice and torture of the majority religious fundamentalists, the Shi-ites, gives the illusion of peace and order. Unexpectedly however, his country is invaded by a foreign nation more powerful than his own, Hussein is deposed from power, and currently the state police are suddenly the formerly oppressed Shi-ite majority, who now torture and kill their brutal ex-rulers. Are they justified? The Shi-ites were tortured previously and considered it unjust, yet out of vengence, they suddenly feel it is justified now that the shoe is on the other foot.

Torture is only justifiable to a shallow mind, and when their group holds the power to offer immunity from such inhumanity by others. Groups that justify torturing other groups will denounce torture 100% of the time if the tables are turned.

Maybe instead of arguing whether torture is ethical, or causes long term damaging effects on those who perpetrate it (not to mention those who suffer it), maybe a better question is "what groups who tortured and suffered subsequent damage to their own group can we locate in history, as a reminder that torture is known bad policy?" The Roman Empire? The Nazis? Imperial Japan?

bloody spaniard
Thursday, September 28, 2006 3:47:00 PM
Torture is an accepted norm in all of the Third World, most of the ex-Soviet Bloc countries, and I'm sure used indirectly by the some of the Western World which probably subcontracts it out.

The enemy will have NO qualms about torturing us regardless of whether we torture them or not.

Accept it.

Assuming that we wish to take the high moral ground because we are naive, er I mean morally superior, er meant to say civilized, er you know what I mean...

HOW DO WE EXTRACT VALUABLE INFO FROM THE ENEMY???

Aside from sodium pentathol (truth serum) which is inconsistent, do we tickle them, yell profanities at them, trick them into think we're all friends, serve em' cold pancakes, show 'em vacation slideshows, WHAT?

Buckwheat
Thursday, September 28, 2006 3:53:00 PM
And here I thought that this was a moral debate. Hell i'd waterboard about half the people that I know just because they annoy me.
Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:09:00 PM
Bloody you watch too many Chuck Norris movies. Torture is the norm for governments all over the world, not just ex-eastern block or banana republic countries. The ruling classes go to great lengths to keep the starving masses away from their booty, the poorer the masses, the greater the insanity. In reality, for most of us peons, none of us torture because it's abnormal, we'd be ostracized from civil society as sickos. I live in the Bay Area. My kid goes to school with people from all over the world, none of them torture on a regular basis that I know of; a few mangled kittens in childhood maximum.

You claim "The enemy will have NO qualms about torturing," then, "HOW DO WE EXTRACT VALUABLE INFO FROM THE ENEMY??? ... do we tickle them." You're a conflicted man, stick with your bible and leave the propane torches & ice picks to those who know how to use them.

Gene363
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:12:00 PM

Before you can have an opinion on the application of torture, you must define what torture is.

Torture:

Inflicting physical pain

Bodily damage

Striking

Shocking

Not torture:

Bright lights

Insults

Cultural insults/degradation

Questioning for long periods of time

Crappy food

Solitary confinement

IMO, torture is unlikely to be successful unless it is a time critical situation where the statements of the tortured are immediately verified. If you make things painful enough most any human will admit to anything.

bloody spaniard
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:12:00 PM
You have no evidence for your blanket accusation (everyone does it) nor do you have an answer to my question, do you?
Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:23:00 PM
It's an a priori excercize in logic Bloody. Every country has a criminal justice system, some more organized, some less. Within those systems of justice, punishment occurs that exceeds mere incarceration. Mexico tortures, the US probably less, Canada probably less than the US. You want me to cite sources for you. Do your own damned reaearch.

How do we get information from people? You gotta be kidding. Why the hell are we debating torture in Iraq when the Taliban is surging again in Afghanistan? Hell with torture, we're supposed to be fighting a war. The real torture is watching the suits continue to mess up and politicize what should be an academic military mop up operation.

If I get time, I'll post later citations of torture from the governments of Mexico, the USA, & Canada, so you won't be in the dark any longer. Your on your own with the world's other nations.

Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:34:00 PM
Here's Mexico:

http://tinyurl.com/hwu3t 

The United States:

http://tinyurl.com/2mxp4 

http://tinyurl.com/hgyev 

Canada's a little harder, but I'll come through; count on it. Bear in mind the cases cited are just those on the surface, and that deeper, darker secrets lie not too carefully hidden.

bloody spaniard
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:43:00 PM
What gives you the impression that this country employs torture?

Yeah, we have broken terrorists with music and cold jail cells but what makes you think that we do worse? As I said before, some elements of the Government may subcontract the "work" but is is certainly secretive & not the norm.

Your all-consuming hatred makes you paint with a very broad brush.

Also, (AGAIN) how would YOU extract information that could possibly save countless lives?

You always evade answering my question by evoking some kind of class warfare which consumes you. Yes, the rich are getting richer while the poor get poorer and the middle class shrinks. Great, you've made that point time and time again. So what?!

This thread is an exercise of hot air because there is no alternative answer to that question.

If most of us have the choice of holding the broken bodies of our children or extracting life- saving info from an animal by any means, the animal loses.

Admit it to yourself & accept it.

And don't give me the pap about how we're better than that.

That mindset is what is losing the war Iraq & endangering the lives of our soldiers.

Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:49:00 PM
Dinner time, but here's one on Canada:

http://tinyurl.com/h7rl7 

Damned socialist bastards don't make it easy, but they got ways of doing things; it's in the dark side of us all.

jpotts
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:49:00 PM
Last time I checked, people went to jail over Abu Gariab.

Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:51:00 PM
"What gives you the impression that this country employs torture? Yeah, we have broken terrorists with music and cold jail cells ... " Uhh, I dunno, the citations I posted maybe?

"(AGAIN) how would YOU extract information that could possibly save countless lives?" You're a very conflicted man.

victor808
Thursday, September 28, 2006 4:52:00 PM
"This thread is an exercise of hot air because there is no alternative answer to that question"

Hey now.. don't go insulting my thread when you guys are going off topic!!

The point of the thread is not whether torture is okay or not (as I said, I don't even know), but that IF it is okay in the situations in the middle east (or elsewhere the "war on terror" is fought), then is it acceptable for our law enforcement agencies domestically.