CWFoster
Friday, October 20, 2006 6:49:00 PM
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-euroislam16oct16,1,3486411.story?coll=la-headlines-world 

It amazes me at how long it takes some people to recognize the obvious! especially the sophisticated (they think) Europeans!

adroomi
Friday, October 20, 2006 6:55:00 PM
Do you think that play would be welcomed here in America as well?

The severed head of Jesus on a stake, probably wouldn't go over too well in Wilmington, NC.

A playhouse decides not to show a play because it is considered offensive to many members of the town.

So?

We should quit worrying about trivial things such as this, and focus more on the war on terror. They are trying to invade our lifestyle, and just now I saw a brown looking guy walk past my window and look at me funny. Of course, he's Okinawan, and I'm naked, but for all I know, he could be a terrorist.

Dr Pepperhill
Friday, October 20, 2006 7:04:00 PM
Interesting post Foster. I feel bad for the Europeans having to live so close to and intermingled with the Islamic fundamentalists. I notice a lot more people in burkhas in my town, but they pretty much keep their religious views to themselves.

Ironically, a similar, if less ominous trend is occuring here at home however. In paragraph #2 of this article it is said that "Artists and influential leftists are warning that the rise of radical Islam is threatening the tradition of European liberalism." Similarly, here at home, artists & leftists are concerned that conservative regligious fundamentalists are threatening liberalism. Indeed, I often hear the rancerous charge of "liberal" form the nutjobs that frequently vent at me on these very boards, like being a liberal and believing in tolerance is a bad thing or something.

In paragraph #8 of the article, it is said that "We live in Europe, where democracy was based on criticizing religion ... if we lose the right to criticize or attack religions in our free countries … we are doomed." Yet here at home religious zealots are attacking the legal rights of the homosexual minority, and some school districts are even trying to slip religion in to replace basic science curricula for children.

As is often stated, I don't see extremists like Pat Robertson or Rick Santorum making tapes of themselves beheading infidels, but the recent attacks on our constitutional freedoms by conservative extremists is disturbing, if not for me, then for my kids.

Dr Pepperhill
Friday, October 20, 2006 7:06:00 PM
To be fair Adroomi, American photographer Andres Serrano's 1989 "Piss Christ" produced much moaning and grumbling, but no riots or bombings.
adroomi
Friday, October 20, 2006 7:15:00 PM
Yes....I didn't like that display either.

I was going to bomb something, but I opted to get bombed instead.

Dr Pepperhill
Friday, October 20, 2006 7:21:00 PM
I'm pretty boring, not exactly subversive. But today I posted a painting I did of breasts, raw bacon, & parsley in acrylic on the Cbid picture post. The Bacon & parsley was done in the photorealistic style, but the breasts were totally cartoonish. Cbid rejected this cartoon painting of boobs, I'm assuming because they deemed them indecent.

Sometimes I see picture posts of blubbery, out of shape men with no shirts, SHOWING THEIR TITS, but my cartoon drawing of female breasts is somehow deemed obscene. Moreover, often people post pictures of automatic weapons with laser sights, clinical, precision killing instruments, yet my cartoon breasts are somehow obscene.

It's a crazy world we live in if you stop to think about it.

CWFoster
Friday, October 20, 2006 7:22:00 PM
It is true that some Christians are offended by the scene referenced by the play, with the severed heads of religeous leaders. But they weren't concerned about offending the Christians, Jews, or Buddhists, just the Moslems. Pat Robertson, and Jerry Falwell may be involved in politics, but they rarely organize public demonstrations, and NEVER violent ones! Yes, there was an outcry over the portait of the Madonna done in excrement. No one firebombed the museum, or killed the artist over it however. You express concern over the "religeous right" why would they have less right to try to influence government through thier participation as a voting bloc than any other group? Do you get upset over the NAACP endorsing candidates or issues? How about the Gay Rights Coallition? Why only single out the "Religeous Right"? They don't have a political party of their own, although they usually back Republicans. They aren't trying to make THEIR religeon officially the state standard, they only want the laws to reflect the ideals and values they hold dear. Don't YOU wish the same? (For YOUR ideals of course) I don't begrudge your political activism, if any, why should you begrudge them theirs? Because you KNOW that they are a majority? Is this a Democracy where the laws represent the will of the majority, or the tyranny of the minority? MAYBE, just maybe, they only want to be able to put a nativity scene in their town square to celebrate Christs birthday, and not have to worry about their kids seeing signs proclaiming "24 hour live sex shows" on their way to school. Is that such a bad thing? If so, why do you think so? I think there are some on these boards who liken the 'Religeous Right' to the Jihadists, and the Religeous Right hasn't beheaded ANYBODY. (at least not in this country, and not in the past 200 years!) Nor would they support someone who advocated that. One of the driving forces behind the Religeous Right has been the INTOLERANCE of the secular humanists! Go figure THAT one!
Dr Pepperhill
Friday, October 20, 2006 7:33:00 PM
"Do you get upset over the NAACP endorsing candidates or issues? How about the Gay Rights Coallition? Why only single out the "Religeous Right"?

Foster you have a lot of balls adducing the politically active religious right who spend money and conduct political terror campaigns to unconstitutionally discriminate against homos. These same groups have bombed a few abortion clinics and murdered a physician or two I believe.

The concerns you cite about the European liberals is the same concerns American liberals have, minus the the radical violence seen with the Muslems. Still, it's a chilling reality when angry, religious extremists want to tell the rest of us how to live.

My kids grew up in North Beach in San Francisco and we passed strip clubs everyday on the way to school; they turned out fine. I have no problem with your or anyone else's style of worship, but when it starts filtering down into lawmaking, that's cause for concern.

CWFoster
Friday, October 20, 2006 7:56:00 PM
Foster you have a lot of balls adducing the politically active religious right who spend money and conduct political terror campaigns to unconstitutionally discriminate against homos. These same groups have bombed a few abortion clinics and murdered a physician or two I believe.

--OK, that's a legitimate concern, IF youalso include NAMBLA, and the Black Panther Party into the mix with the Gay Ruights Coalition and the NAACP. Buit if you're going to include the so-called Christian nutjobs into the Religeous Right, then you have to include the nutjobs into the other groups to be fair! I don't recall pat Robertson ('m NOT a particulr fan of his, OR Falwells incidentally, but YOU and others have held them up, so I'll stay with them for purposes of this discussion) OR Jerry Falwell advocating, supporting, or condoning violence to end abortion. Yes, there ARE those who do. Are you going to include Louis Farakahn in the groups of black civil rights figures, or Rep. Foley in with the Gay Rights Coallition?

The concerns you cite about the European liberals is the same concerns American liberals have, minus the the radical violence seen with the Muslems. Still, it's a chilling reality when angry, religious extremists want to tell the rest of us how to live.

--I have no problems with ANYBODY trying to make their voices heard through the political process. Why should one groups political activism somehow be more valuable and accepted than anothers unless you only want YOUR side represented? Isn't that what your biggest complaint is about the Religeous Right is? What makes YOU so much more holier than thou compared to them? Oh wait, that's another brush you use to tar them! there's an old saying that state what we hate the most in others is what we dislike about ourselves. Another way of putting that is.."Judge not lest ye be judged with the same judgement you judged with" (paraphrased slightly, but the intent is intact)

My kids grew up in North Beach in San Francisco and we passed strip clubs everyday on the way to school; they turned out fine. I have no problem with your or anyone else's style of worship, but when it starts filtering down into lawmaking, that's cause for concern.

-- I'm not saying that kids CAN'T grow up in that kind of environment well adjusted. HELL, I'm not even specifically saying that I support the laws they try to get enacted limiting the distance from schools that a sexually oriented business can operate. Only that they DO have the right to try and influence the legal environment they live in as much as the NAACP, or the Gay Rights Coallition!

Dr Pepperhill
Friday, October 20, 2006 8:11:00 PM
Foster I got Robertson advocating violence right here [http://tinyurl.com/yb83y8]; move over Bin Laden!

I agree with you that religion should not be a test of who gets elected or not. In fact, that's inscribed in article 6 of the constitution. But complaining that Christians are under-represented in contemporary American government is a mighty suspicious complaint!? Maybe you've been in Guam too long; especially when the family values crowd like Tom DeLay & Mark Foley are so utterly full of crap.

I'm not against religion, but I do admit to worrying about religion affecting law. Abortion rights are diminishing, the constitution's being assaulted, and not in the name of secular humanism I might add. I doubt the Salem witch trials are around the corner, or that this democracy won't swing back to the middle, but these days, with all the lies and corruption coming out of Washington, and all the talk of holy wars (on both sides, from the middle east and the American statehouse as well), got me pining for the good old days.

adroomi
Friday, October 20, 2006 8:14:00 PM
I agree, when someone goes into a foreign country, occupies it, and tries to tell it's people how to live, they should take up arms and do ALL that they can to prevent that extremist from spreading "their" way onto them and their countrymen.

If the person or persons don't leave their country and stop harrassing it's people, then the citizens of that country should launch a counter attack.

lets see.....do we have any examples of this to use?

CWFoster
Friday, October 20, 2006 8:30:00 PM
Dr. Pepperhill, yes, Robertson stepped on his peepee with that one! but the link you p[rovided was where he acknowledged that what he said was wrong, and apologized, (a lot more apology and much less admitting it was wrong) has Saddam or osama done THAT much? You said I had balls for comparing the NAACP to the Religeous Right, you have alot of balls for comparing something one man said in frustration to people who have instigated and organized mass murder! Robertson hasn't advocated blowing up abortion clinics, nor blowing up 2000 year old Buddahs. Bin Ladin and the Taliban did BOTH in Afghanistan. You're accusation of ME making invalid comparisons is the pot calling the kettle black.
Dr Pepperhill
Friday, October 20, 2006 8:49:00 PM
Foster I was saying you have a lot of balls adducing the religious right as some oppressed group in America. They control the executive and legislative branch, with big players in the judicial branch as well. Your dreams have come true, why in hades are your bellyaching now? ... celebrate while it lasts I say.

And I'm not making invalid comparisons. "Let's go back to 9/11 four years ago. The ruins were still smoldering

when the reverends Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell went on television to proclaim that the terrorist attacks were God's punishment of a corrupted

America. They said the government had adopted the agenda 'of the pagans, and the abortionists, and the feminists, and the gays and the lesbians[http://tinyurl.com/yzlu6k].' "

See, god attacked America on 9/11, not Bin Laden, at least that's what God's reresentatives, Jerry Falwell & Pat Robertson have said. You need to stay as far away from those two clowns as you would a sandiwch prepared with delicious leprosy spread.

Just because Bin Laden is an evil mass murderer doesn't excuse the insaneness of people like Robertson, nor excuse our current crop of lawmaker's assaults on civil liberties and out of control corruption.

Bin Laden got away with what he did because Afghanistan is a poor, desperate country. Our religious fanatics, the Falwells & Robertsons are kept in check by our wealthy, high-tech society; a sign we should distance ourselves from their apocalyptic message, not move closer to it.

usahog
Friday, October 20, 2006 8:58:00 PM
"Bin Laden got away with what he did because Afghanistan is a poor, desperate country. Our religious fanatics, the Falwells & Robertsons are kept in check by our wealthy, high-tech society; a sign we should distance ourselves from their apocalyptic message, not move closer to it."

I can hear you explaining to God Now, when you are on your judgement day.. Well ya see Pop's I feared Fallwell and Robertson so much I shy'd away from your message to do rightious and kept you on the back burners for my lifes plan...

That's going to be a scorching excuse!

Hog

Dr Pepperhill
Friday, October 20, 2006 9:02:00 PM
We both act on what we see as the best information Hog. The difference is that you condemn me without understanding, while I understand you (sort of) abd dispense with the condemnation. If I got something out of it, like you apparently do, I'd probably throw it in too.
CWFoster
Friday, October 20, 2006 9:57:00 PM
First off, let me comment on your style of argument! I see NONE of the condescention you usually use, and it's refreshing to conduct a civil debate!

Now to the meat of the issue.. I know Robertson and Falwell are not the best posterboys for the cause. I don't care if they get invited to the White House, or if they get courted by congressmen running for office. When little Janie gets shoved aside for a valedictorian address because she intends to give God credit for her success, that's a violation of her 1st Amendment rights. When the 1st Baptist Church wants to set up a Nativity scene on the town square, they aren't trying to force their beliefs down anyones throat, they just want to demonstrate their own devotion to their Lord. They allow Gay Pride parades, why isn't that considered forcing someone elses lifestyle down MY throat? I'm not asking for any special consideration for anybody, just a level playing field! It's exactly the same as you lumping the abortion clinic bombers in with those who just vote their faith, and ignore Nambla, and the Black Muslims, and the Black Panthers when looking at civil rights groups! Let's treat all groups equally, if you're going to include the nutjobs in the Religeous Right, include them in Black civil rights groups, include them in the Gay Liberation Movement. If you think the 1st Baptist Church shouldn't have the right to have a Nativity scene, then limit the rights of the Gay pride folks to have a parade! at least the Nativity scene won't block traffic!

adroomi
Friday, October 20, 2006 10:07:00 PM
CWFoster,

Can you please explain the details surrounding the Nativity Scene and Gay Pride Parade that you are comparing and contrasting?

1. Did they take place in the same city?

2. Did one get approved, and not the other?

In regards to little Janie not being able to talk about God in her speech, I think we've covered this before. The school is multicultural and multi-denominational, and she was attempting to make extreme comments that denounce other Gods and religions, and was going to claim that there was only "one trued god." This would've been offensive to the non-Christian Buddhists, Hindu's, Muslims, and sun-worshippers in the audience, and since that girl was REPRESENTING the school and it's views, they had EVERY right to censor her speech. HER speech was to be offered in THEIR venue and THEIR forum. Sorta like me showing up at a KKK meeting and reading a few Dr. MLK quotes......it's neither the right place nor time, and my hosts have a right to stop me.

CWFoster
Friday, October 20, 2006 10:27:00 PM
Adroomi, no on either one. But show me ONE instance of the ACLU trying to BLOCK a gay pride parade! I can show you several where they blocked nativity scenes! Want offensive? How about the ACLU arguing, and the courts ruling in their favor that the KKK (or was it the American Nazis) could march through Skokie Ill. (a predominantly Jewish community) The town tried to block it, but it was determined that that was an infringement against the Klucker/Nazis free speech rights. I personally believe that the Buddhists are wrong, and that the Hindus are wrong, and that the Moslems are wrong. Guess what they think I'm wrong, Vive La Differance! I support their right to be wrong! Don't suppress my right to say what I think is right!

As to little Janie, I didn't cite any particular case, did I? the one I was actually thinking of was a speech to be given at the beginning of a football game, and she just wanted to say a little prayer, not to call anyone else wrong, but they didn't want that! By the way, they teach yoga in some schools PE programs, did you know that yoga is a Hindu practice to aid in meditation? so in some respects it could be said they are teaching a Hindu doctrine in public schools, but you don't hear anyone getting bent out of shape and attacking Hindus, just Christians! YOU illustrate my point SO well!

CWFoster
Friday, October 20, 2006 10:30:00 PM
BY the way again, on the subject of schools, I've heard of teachers being threatened with dismissal for just WEARING a cross on a necklace, not pushing any doctrine, or preaching, just wearing a necklace! But Staff members wearing an Ankh symbol were OK!
usahog
Friday, October 20, 2006 11:18:00 PM
Doc,

I never condemned you? I don't have a right to do that.. I just thought it important to point out what a topic it would be between yourself and God on Judgement day... no need to get all defensive is there?

Hog