bullwinkle
Saturday, November 11, 2006 10:37:00 AM
in the mid-late 1700s, Major-General Henry Shrapnel, an English Artillery Officer, used his own time and money to develop the wonderful stuff that we know today - the very stuff that bears his name.

We know it well here. It influences what we do in the form of rockets, bombs, mortars, and grenades.

Shrapnel's affect on people is fairly consistent, except that sometimes it goes straight through and sometimes it lodges casually inside.

If shrapnel visited you in your home, workplace, school, church, or social gathering place, you would probably be concerned, and rightfully so.

Your reaction would be to find out where it comes from, and use whatever means necessary to stop it.

----

Shrapnel visits my home, workplace, school, church, social gathering places, and everywhere in between.

So my question to you is:

Why aren't you letting us do anything about it?

If the police in your neighborhood weren't allowed to stop shrapnel from visiting your neighborhood, would that upset you?

----

Why are Britney Spears and Donald Rumsfeld and gay marriages and abortion more important to you than doing your part to ensure that we are able to stop the shrapnel from coming?

While you were standing in line for your Starbucks today, we were doing our best to be a moving target for a hidden rain of shrapnel. If you couldn't stand in line for coffee, it would ruin your day.

----

Why are people more interesting in which candidate will give their local Union the better **** than which candidate will do more to ensure that their families can take an offensive against those who wish to send shrapnel their way?

Peace through power never worked for cowards. Be thankful that spinelessness didn't infect the highest levels of our government during the 1980s. Be thankful that there's enough basketball on TV that you might just forget to give a flying **** about the shrapnel.

Some degree of elloquence will have to be employed, but the route question is

"Why isn't my son allowed to break the back of the insurgency right NOW"

FOREIGN policy is no longer about what we do overseas. 'Foreign' alludes to something that people just don't know **** about.

dadz
Saturday, November 11, 2006 10:45:00 AM
Bull, got no problem with your posts. What's the point? We lost the election?
bullwinkle
Saturday, November 11, 2006 11:07:00 AM
Nope....nothing to do with the elections...I found this on another scouts page and liked it...Kinda voicing the disgust that the most important topic on the news as of late is Britney Spears divroce...You know...46 people died in Iraq today, including 2 American soldiers, but Britney Spears is getting divorced, and we now go live to our reporter with her, because it is so much more important...

You know, here in San Antone, I got in my truck and drove to PT the morning after the elections, trying to find out what happened, and NOT A SINGLE STATION on the radio, AM/FM mentioned ANYTHING about the elections during the 15 minutes it took me to drive to post, or during the 10 minutes I sat in my truck waiting for formation...Not a single word on the elections...

drew

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 11, 2006 11:45:00 AM
Bullwinkle, it's sort of hard to discourse with a cut & paste propaganda piece, but my understanding of the insurgency, if you're talking about Iraq at least, is that the bombers are ex-Ba'athist ruling party operatives trying to get back control of the oil revenues they enjoyed for so long Under Saddan Husein.

I like Hog's recommendation of us establishing permanent bases in the desert & around major petroleum operations, and letting the Iraqis deal with their own GD civil war, that for better or worse, we set in motion.

Characterizing the ex-Ba'athists as global terrorists that would bomb Peoria Illinois or Tyler Texas to justify the crap going on in Iraq right now is not only BS, but poorly crafted BS. Get our guys out of harms way and let the bastards fight their own civil war.

Then the problem becomes, did we set the stage for a Shi'ite islamic republic like Iran by starting the Iraqi civil war? That's what my ex-patriot Iranian friends tell me, & why we should establish permanent bases in Iraq, like middle eastern Guantanamos.

bullwinkle
Saturday, November 11, 2006 11:49:00 AM
I like Hog's recommendation of us establishing permanent bases in the desert & around major petroleum operations, and letting the Iraqis deal with their own GD civil war, that for better or worse, we set in motion.

--------------

That is actually what the original plan was..Both in Iraq and A-stan...Go in, topple the regime, stabalize the country, then pull back and let the INP and ANP take care of their own. That is what we did in A-stan, and it was working perfectly until we turned the situation over to NATO, but that is a topic for another day.

drew

dadz
Saturday, November 11, 2006 11:51:00 AM
Bull, strikes me, you're not so opinionated. Good guy.

Get your news from somewhere other than local San Ant.

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 11, 2006 11:55:00 AM
I beg to differ Bullwinkle. From what I can tell the war-weary Afghans are pissed that we installed rich corrupt opium lords and they're left holding the sh*t, while wwe ran off to Iraq and started the civil war over there. There is a real danger of the people of Afghanistan re-inviting the Taliban back, as their strict, Islamic style of rule is turning out to be better than the that of the opium lords.

As far as the IND goes, they've turned out to be just shi'ite controlled death squads that clandestinely capture and turture Sunnis in revenge killings. There's a civil war going on in that country, and the ex-ba'athists aren't taking it lying down. Morphing that reality into a global terror threat by unscrupulous opportunists here at home has been a damn shame. Glad to see the American public called them on their BS.

Maybe now is a good time to re-visit plan-A since plan-B turned out to be such a resounding failure.

dadz
Saturday, November 11, 2006 12:12:00 PM
For Bull's response. Where is plan A or plan B referenced?
bullwinkle
Saturday, November 11, 2006 12:23:00 PM
I'm not denying the civil war...It is brewing..and when it explodes, it will be very, very bloody...We will probably be seeing death tolls among the civilian populace along the lines of what we saw during WWII...

My solution to the problem...Break the damned country apart like Ireland...3 sectors...Shiite, Sunni, and Kurdestan....Create a delegation from each sector to rule, and meet with the other 2...Split oil profits between the 3 sectors...Everybody is happy, nobody is dying...That is until one of the sectors decides they want to encroach on their neighbors...In all honesty..Iraq is a clusterf--k at the moment, and we and the Iraqi people need to find a solution, implement, and it needs to be done most ricky tick.

drew

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 11, 2006 12:37:00 PM
Bull now you're talking. I have been saying the same thing about a tri-partite government on these boards for months.

What's needed is some change in policy. There are currently several options, but the folks with their fingers on the trigger, namely the executive cabinet, are like a deer in the headlights, they're frozen.

I prefer (like anyone gives a damn) your suggestion to pulling back into fortresses and letting a slaughter ensue. Doing so would do irepairable damage to our nation in the world community.

Somehow getting the Sunni's and other ex-Ba'athists back into the picture, into a governmental official capacity, not only mitigates the insurgency, but also the civil war, and ends up making us look better too.

There are other variations of policy changes available, but just leaving the unprepared and inexperienced and ham-strung Shi'ites in the south & kurds in the north in the current situation is senseless. Unfortunately, beaurocratic gridlock on our part seems to virtually guarantee status quo ... in which case I feel pulling back into fortresses would be a preferable option, although not the best.

HockeyDad
Saturday, November 11, 2006 1:09:00 PM
There are a couple of major problems with the three sector approach and it can explain why we aren't doing it and instead trying to make everything magically better and happy.

A Shiite and Sunni sector concept could very likely turn into a mass resettlement run and gun kinda war like India and Pakistan went through during their independence. Not only would we be caught in the middle but we would be to blame for the consequences which could be near genocidal. If this happens there will be no oil splitting because the Shiites will have the half the Kurds don't have and Iran will back them up or invade in their defense. That would be bad for the US and the Saudis.

A Kurdish sector concept that goes any further than the autonomous zone approach right now will result in Kurdish separation and independence. Kurdistan could easily stand on its own right now if we let them out. They have half the oil, are already actively seeking outside investment, and have no need for Iraq. A Kurd breakaway would cause huge problems with our NATO ally Turkey, who has a whole bunch of Kurds that have been blowing up stuff and trying to break away for many years. An independent Kurdistan would ultimately go after Turkish territory and start a war with Turkey with us caught in the middle. Turkey trying to join the EU makes it even worse in terms of picking sides. Leaving the Kurds in Iraq is good for us and Turkey but not good for the Kurds.

The Sunnis hold the short straw right now because they used to dominate the others under Saddam's rule through an iron fist and extermination of opposition. The best thing for the Sunnis is to start a civil war and try to gain numerical advantage. Nobody has been able to draft a viable option or role for them that won't result in an eventual screw job. They know exactly what a screw job looks like because they used to be the ones doing it.

dadz
Saturday, November 11, 2006 1:23:00 PM
I didn't mean Bull.

"For Bull's response. Where is plan A or plan B referenced?"

But now, Dr and Hocky cleared it up.

How, in the world of high level diplomacy, did no one else, but the Monday morning quarterbacks, figure out the obvious?

dadz
Saturday, November 11, 2006 1:25:00 PM
Never mind, "your just a dum****" Many of use have thought of these options for a long time.
HockeyDad
Saturday, November 11, 2006 1:45:00 PM
None of this is new, or secret. For the most part this is 20 year old information. Everyone involved in the planning including military, intelligence, and the White House had to face these issues. President George H W Bush faced all this when he had to decide whether to stick to the UN mandate or launch a full scale invasion of Iraq during Operation Desert Storm. He made a decision.

You war game your best case scenarios and your worst case scenarios and you make a decision. We thought we would be greeted as liberators and then we stayed the course. Here we are.

A war game scenario in 1999 was conducted by General Zinni (CENTCOM). It is known as Operation Desert Crossing and it is declassified. It had a best case and most likely case scenario in its findings. It called for 400,000 troops to be needed and still major postwar security problems.

An interesting finding was that "regime change may not enhance regional stability".

General Zinni was one of those retired generals that spoke out before the invasion as being against it. We referred to them in not very kind words.

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 11, 2006 1:48:00 PM
HD there are a few flaws, in MHO, in your reasoning. Pardon me for not going into detail, but allow me to use a broad brush, because I need to shave here in a few minutes.

You claim "A Shiite and Sunni sector concept could very likely turn into a ... war ... Not only would we be caught in the middle but we would be to blame for the consequences."

Well there is a war currently underway, which I am assuring myself you have noticed. We are presently caught in the middle, and we are to blame. Acknowledging this can take us leaps ahead in the potential for progress. By handing Iraq to the Shia, we're basically strengthening their allies Iran, but by re-inviting the ex-Ba'athists (not all Ba'athists were Sunnis, like the propagandists would have us believe), we not only atone for some of our (Bremer's) biggest blunders, but gain a better toe hold against Iran. Don't you remember your & Cheney's boy Rummy's handshake with Saddam? Let's not get side-tracked by our own soaring claims about freedom and remember what the stakes are here, and who the players are. The good news is we wield more influence than our phony freedom lovin' propagandists have been letting on. Implementation is now the key.

The Kurds want their own state obviously, but will go along with whatever the coalition decides on. The Sunnis (really, the ex-Ba'athists ... we need to quit using Lewis Carroll-ese) hold the short straw because the coalition (the Bush administration) has re-labelled them terrorists, the old tactic used in Vietnam, Operation Condor, & in central America, and has shut them out completely, creating the pressure we see now.

The other option is to retreat into oil-preserving fortresses and let the party begin. This is a better option than the present policy, but the former seems better. Saying it won't work without trying it is exactly what's at play now.

HockeyDad
Saturday, November 11, 2006 2:14:00 PM
Dr Pepperhill,

of course it is flawed, it is Iraq after all!

My point is only that the sector division between Shiites and Sunnis could turn into a violent partitioning that makes what is going on right now look like a peaceful stroll in the park. The areas where they are intermingled may not want to stay that way.

By holding open elections, we already handed Iraq to the Shia. That was inevitable. Free elections were a great thing and a horrible thing since it is the Sunnis that we are allied with around the world, except in Iraq. It is now the Iraqi government's problem to invite in more Sunnis or ex-Ba'athists. We abdicated that throne. In the end there still is the fundamental problem of forcing three different peoples to participate in a democracy that they didn't create themselves, don't necessarily want, and aren't real familiar with in concept.

The big winner in the middle east since 1990 is Iran and they never even had to fire a shot.

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 11, 2006 2:56:00 PM
Well I'm just Joe nobody, so I may as well call on the Venusians to come down & fix the problem for all my opinion is worth, but I still say your exclusion out of hand at using our iron fist to let the Ba'athists back in at some level is untried and holds great promise. Claiming it's the Shi'a problem now is a non-answer, since they're too busy running death squads to eliminate their rivals (and doing a bad job of it) to be troubled with politics. We should either let our forces genocide the Sunnis, or put together a ruling coalition including that won't kill one another, THEN worry about elections. As it is we've put the horse before the cart. The Shi'a won't give an inch unless we make them, and it is perfectly within our power; we're the occupying force for Christ's sake. Calling rival death squads a democracy is a joke.

On a related note, some sense prevailed in Gaza, as I read today Hamas was vacating leadership there to try and stimulate the return of foreign aid, since they're broke, and Isreal has them pinned down like fish in a barrel.

dadz
Saturday, November 11, 2006 3:20:00 PM
Foil hats folded and put away for the duration.

Dr

The Hamas talk to us because they have had a taste of the West. Fly over the area and see ACs on the roofs. Nowhere else, including Egypt, are the comforts of western cultures apparent. I haven't had the opportunity of flying over other Mid Eastern countries, but I imagine ACs are unheard of in the Bathist neighborhoods.

The Hamas have some motivation to become politically active.

Not so Iraq. They accept their culture without change. Maybe some Shiites are willing to talk, but not the Sunni.

“ but I still say your exclusion out of hand at using our iron fist to let the Ba'athists back in at some level is untried and holds great promise. Claiming it's the Shi'a problem now is a non-answer, since they're too busy running death squads to eliminate their rivals (and doing a bad job of it) to be troubled with politics. We should either let our forces genocide the Sunnis, or put together a ruling coalition including that won't kill one another, THEN worry about elections. As it is we've put the horse before the cart. The Shi'a won't give an inch unless we make them, and it is perfectly within our power; we're the occupying force for Christ's sake”

Are the Shi'a responsible for all the deaths? “Since they're too busy running death squads to eliminate their rivals” and “They are doing a bad job of eliminating their rivals”

What would a good job look like?

How can we use our iron fist? Not possible as proven by Tues’ election.

Occupying force? We won’t see that in our lifetime.

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, November 11, 2006 4:50:00 PM
ACs? AC-130s or air conditioners. Here's that classic clip of AC-130 use in Iraq vaporizing some soft targets [http://tinyurl.com/yk3z7v]. I'm assuming they weren't buddhists.

The point of this whole rant is: what might be plausible policy changes in Iraq as an alternative to current policy?

I'm not the oldest person on the boards but I've seen enough US foreign intervention to know that Democracy means being able to lose and election and live. If losing an election results in the victors getting a green light to rub out the competition, that nation is not ready for democracy; it won't work. Since Iraq is not competent for democracy, what might some military means be for bringing about stability? I don't claim to have the answers but the Bush plan is a failure. It's one thing to admit there's a problem. Admitting there's a problem and continuing to take no action is not progress.

Re-naming the deposed ex-Ba'athist insurgents global terrorists, then fighting covert counter-insurgency ops based on that egregoius equivocation is throwing good money after bad apparently.

nuff said by me in any case

adroomi
Saturday, November 11, 2006 4:52:00 PM
When read that first post, I was thinking that it might've been written by a Lebanese person.