Intel
  • Intel
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 4:35:00 PM
Intresting
jpotts
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 4:56:00 PM
That's kinda up there with the female (basketball?) team that called themselves the "Fighin' Whiteies". The thought they had made a real statement about college mascots, up until white people thought it was a great idea.

I think they changed the mascot after that. Shame...I thought it was cool.

Dr Pepperhill
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 6:22:00 PM
I don't buy it. America is founded on slavery, and even 100 years after slavery ended, African Americans were openly murdered, with no criminal penalty, by authorities in the deep south in the 60s during the civil rights revolution, when I was a young child. Legally murdered as if it were some form of honor.

Ok, that was in the mid 1960s, 40 years ago, but racism still exists in America, so does sexism. Look at the percentage of senators and congress people that are females or minorities compared to white males, COEs of business too. When you see bias like that, it's one of two things, ability or bias. People are free to form their own conclusions, but my suspicion is that it's not due to ability. I believe I would win in a scientific showdown in this debate because my opponent would be arguing white males benefit disproportionately in our society because they are more fit.

If you're a white male in America, you automatically have an advantage over minorities & women. Sure some individual poor white bastards are born into poor families, are dumb and ugly just like some from all groups, and are screwed coming out of the gate. But the generalized institutional bias in this country is still strongly stacked against dark skinned people without dicks. It's a leveler playing field, but far from level. There is no institutional bias against white males in American society at large, but there are some affirmative action policies that seek to redress the existing biases that do exist.

Given this backdrop, complaining about minority or female scholarships designed to redress inherent bias in our society, is a code revealing bias.

Those railing over white scholarships for political rhetoric are about as transparent as Charles Rangle's bid to initiate a draft; it's an unabiguous rhetoric with a specific purpose, and not very benevolent in intent.

For the record, there are already scholarships for white people available. My niece recently got a scholarship to UC and has since graduated and is now in medical school in Boston. She's white. My son missed getting a scholarship by two GPA points. He's white. These scholarships are of course based on merit, but since we live in a society biased against non-whites and females, then open subsidies benefit the dominant group the most, as do lending practices, hiring practices, educational opportunities, access to healthcare, and awards like scholarships.

Offering an angry rhetorical white scholarship is as absurd as offering a male scholarship. The very action of these reactionaries affirms the underlying inequity inherent in our society. If racism weren't an empirical issue, those who protest efforts to address it would have no leverage to start with.

adroomi
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 6:41:00 PM
Excellent post DrPep.
jpotts
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:10:00 PM
Dr. Pepperhill:

"I don't buy it. America is founded on slavery."

I agree. Aboriginal Americans kept slaves long before the white man came here.

The beauty of America is that you can succeed regardless of the obstacles placed in your path. Too many people rely too heavily on the crutch of racism, bigotry, sexism, reverse racism, et al that they lose what's best about this nation - that the battle hardest fought, has the sweetest taste of victory.

I have few heroes outside of the patriarchy of my family. Of those, one is General George Patton, and the other is George Washington Carver. Carver I consider the quintessential American, because he perservered through hard work, and endless determination to literally save the South. His genius was not in doing good things with abundant resources, but doing great things with very little at his disposal. And for him, no obstacle was too great to overcome.

I find it odd that those who bellyache and whine about not having enough, or that their goals are unattanable are usually those that produce nothing in life regardless of what they have at their disposal. Those who have determination, simply do, and do again until the eventually succeed.

Oh, and go "Fightin' Whiteies"!

adroomi
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:29:00 PM
Jpotts,

Nice attempt to shift blame to "aboriginal" Americans. Typical. However this does NOTHING to address DrPeps statement that our "country" was founded upon slavery. It simply shifts the blame to a moot group of people.

Walking around with your white backpack of privelege on your shoulders, it's easy to claim that we all have the same opportunities. However, I feel you completely missed the good DrPeps entire point. A simple challenge.....

Get promoted to a lead postition with your company as a white man, and your subs will say, "he deserved it."

Get promoted to a lead position with your company as a black man, and how many of your subs do you think will say, "well, we know WHY he got the promotion, don't we."

If you don't see that in your world, then you are living in Utopia I guess.....

Who knows why

Someday we all must die

Were all homeless boys and girls

And we are never heard

Its such a lonely world

People turn their heads and walk on by

Tell me, is it worth just another try?

jpotts
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:46:00 PM
adroomi:

"Nice attempt to shift blame to 'aboriginal' Americans. Typical. However this does NOTHING to address DrPeps statement that our "country" was founded upon slavery. It simply shifts the blame to a moot group of people."

First, it's not "blame", it's a "fact." Secondly, up until the 18th century, salvery was a fact of life in virtually ALL cultures. This constant hand-wringing about America and slavery is frankly getting a little annoying. The first slaves that came over from across the pond were typically white people - indentured servents. Granted, there were a number of "snatch and grab" raids for slaves on American shores, but then again, there were a number of "snatch and grab" raids done by non-whites up until about the late 1800s.

"Walking around with your white backpack of privelege on your shoulders, it's easy to claim that we all have the same opportunities. However, I feel you completely missed the good DrPeps entire point. A simple challenge....."

Yeah, they're just throwing opportunities at my feet.

Perhaps the most condescending thing that people like you do it to assume that people of "color" cannot be successful in this country without some sort of assistence. Not only does it secure your deep, internal desire to feel superior to someone, or something, but is also cripples the very same people you claim to have compassion for.

"Get promoted to a lead postition with your company as a white man, and your subs will say, 'he deserved it.' Get promoted to a lead position with your company as a black man, and how many of your subs do you think will say, 'well, we know WHY he got the promotion, don't we.'"

Thanks for confirming everything I've said.

"If you don't see that in your world, then you are living in Utopia I guess....."

No, I live in the real world, where success is based off of talent, hard work, and persistence.

The sad part about your world-view is that it robs people of the very thing that inspires greatness, and that is success against what appear to be overwealming odds. George Washington Carver did it, and others less noteworthy did it as well, yet you literally deny them their place in history, and bury the legacy of their accomplishments because of some backa**wards political agenda.

Well, thanks, but no thanks.

adroomi
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:49:00 PM
"Perhaps the most condescending thing that people like you do it to assume that people of "color" cannot be successful in this country without some sort of assistence."

Did I even mention ANYTHING about "some sort of assistance?"

Please do not attempt to misquote me.

It don't work.

jpotts
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:54:00 PM
adroomi:

You'll find it right next to "it's easy to claim that we all have the same opportunities" and right below "well, we know WHY he got the promotion, don't we."

jpotts
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:56:00 PM
adroomi:

And as far as misquoting you, I'm allowed at least one for every of your ten, and you've got quite a backlog going.

adroomi
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:59:00 PM
Jpotts,

You make up too much stuff to be taken seriously.

When you do ask questions, they can't be answered because they are rhetorical.

You paint a picture of each and every American being equal based upon your own middle class upbringing.

You deny that there is hunger in America.

You deny that there is poverty in America.

We speak a different language.

jpotts
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 9:33:00 PM
adroomi:

"You make up too much stuff to be taken seriously."

I "make things up"? Like what? I give examples and illustrations, and go on for pages with facts, only so I can hear you whine that my posts are "too long."

As it is I have to point out where and am and am not flaming you, as well as pointing out when I am and am not being sarcastic - this stuff seems to be over your head. You inability to determine these things only adds to the lenghts of my posts.

And I don't think I'll ever mention "Michigan" again, given your reaction...

"When you do ask questions, they can't be answered because they are rhetorical."

Yeah. Any question you can't answer because it doesn't bolster your position immediately becomes "rhetorical."

"You paint a picture of each and every American being equal based upon your own middle class upbringing."

First, why is it that you ASSUME I had a middle-class life when I was growing up.

Secondly, if I did have a middle-class background, it's because my parents worked to become successful, and didn't go around whining about how things were "too hard" and that they "couldn't make it".

And, as I later dicovered, there were times when they damn near didn't make it.

Third, there is story after story of people who had nothing becoming quite wealthy: Black, Hispanic, White, you name it. I'd go into great detail for you, but then again you'd just complain that all those letters, periods, and punctuation marks are too hard to read...

"You deny that there is hunger in America."

If there is hunger, it is infitecimally small. I said that once, you obviosuly never bothered to read it. Nothing new there.

"You deny that there is poverty in America."

Show me where I said that.

You and your left-wing kook brigade are notorious for assinging things to me that I've NEVER said. If I had done the same thing to you, you'd be howling like the little intellectual cowards you are about how I'm making things up about you.

"We speak a different language."

Oh yeah, that's REAL obvious.

I think the one thing you can't stand is that there are some people out there that say what they mean, and are willing to back up what they say. And when you don't have the intellectual capacity to counter these arguments, you go off calling people liars, telling them that they don't know "how things really are", and so on. To a guy like me, that's just blood in the water, because I know that these reactions are instictive, and born out of ignorance.

You yourself claimed to be horribly poor when you left the miltary, yet you are now successful (if you indeed truely are). You have enough money to buy all these fancy things, travel to wonderful places, wear nice clothes, and have all the trappings of a good lifestyle. Did you get these things because someone felt sorry for you, and handed you a whole lot of dough?

No. You worked for them. You achieved at...well...whatever it is you do, and became successful based off the sweat of your own brow.

However, me pointing that obvious fact out only proves that I live in a "utopian dream world".

Or maybe, perhaps, you've made up your success?

adroomi
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 9:44:00 PM
We don't speak the same language friend.

Sorry.

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, November 22, 2006 10:59:00 AM
Potts, I agree that hard work & determination not only lubricate the way for an individual to get ahead in life, but also that such a philosophy makes society in general a better place for all in it. While I know little of George Washington Carver besides his revolutionary work with peanuts, perhaps the reconstruction-era African American leader Booker T. Washington, founder of the Tuskegee Institute, embodies your example of self-sufficiency even more vociferously Than Carver. As the nations preiminent African American leader after the civil war, Washington preached that the black man must turn all efforts to economic gain for a better life for him and his family, as a struggle for voting & civil rights would only detract from the real goal; to get ahead by becoming an effective capitalist. Washington was certainly a strong voice for independent action, but his right thinking was far ahead of its right time. As W.E.B. DuBois, founder of the NAACP said, African Americans must first gain political rights, like the right to vote & desegregation, prior to worrying about the opportunity for economic advancement. As the wait till 1964 for true civil rights showed, with hindsight, DuBois was right, Washington wrong, though both men had their people's (and the nation's really) best interests at heart.

However, in our own times, using say, statistics, if bias can be seen in a society, and objectively corroborated, it only makes sense to make efforts to redress it; as the converse would be to ignore it: which history has shown to bring down negative consequences for the citizens of such a society (although not for the elite minority who benefit from such bias).

Surely you're not contending We have achieved an acceptable level of social parity for females & non-whites in our society at this date & time? Evidence seems to suggest otherwise. Taking up Booker T. Washington's call to work hard for personal gain became a ripe philosophy after 1964, but DuBois' advice still applies to gray areas of our society, and we would be wise to heed his important message, and respond in kind with good policies.