vfrtwice
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 9:45:00 AM
Ok..this Ohio state wide smoking ban still has me fired up. I have a few questions about something I know nothing about...Government.

For starters, How or what decideds which laws get to be voted on by the public (smoking bann) and what laws are just made law by the goverment? Why cant we vote to raise the speed limit on state routes??

I just dont understand how we allow people to vote on something that they are not really involved in. How a bunch of hypocritial overweight people that dont even go into a bar and from the looks of them, dont really give a crap about their helt are ABLE to vote on an issue that that will never affect them???

Kind of like a school levy passing when people with kids force people with no kids going to a school pay higher taxes for something they will never get a benifit from?

It just really burns my ass that somoene that never goes into a bar can tell me who goes in at least once a week that I cant enjoy a good cigar and a beer. Let alone the same persone voting on an issue that is SUPPOSE to be about their helth..casting a vote when their colesterol is thorough the roof and they are 20-50lbs over weight!!! I just SEEMS WRONG!!!

I'm REALLY pissed that I cant go to my favorite bar and have a cigar any more!!! It just doesnt seem right!!

thanks,

v

00camper
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 10:43:00 AM
vfr,

Put your crash helmet on. You're going to need it before I'm finished.

You and the millions of people just like you who freely admit that they don't know anything about their government are responsible for what is happening all across the United States.

If you (and the millions like you) understood that the US federal system and the individual states are organized as republics and not democracies then you would know that our elected officials - the senators and representatives in Washington and your state senators and representatives in Columbus (the Ohio capital) - consider the issues and decide matters on your behalf. The same is true at the county and city level. Even the school boards are elected in some states like Kentucky.

You don't get to vote on the speed limit, smoking bans or school taxes because that's what your General Assembly, County Commission and City Council (and/or school board) does on your behalf.

If the majority of people who vote are voting for representatives who favor smoking bans, lower speed limits and higher school taxes then that's exactly what everybody will get.

This isn't personal, so don't take it that way. I just get really fired up when people ask questions like yours, wondering why government is broken. The problem is the voters - or the lack of informed voters.

GRRRRRRRRRR.

vfrtwice
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 10:59:00 AM
I wasnt asking why the "goverment was broken" I honestly dont know much about how it works...even to know if its "broken" or not.

I was curious why some "laws" you see the public able to vote on them, while others are never put to vote..and conversly why we GET to vote on some things and NOT on others? that was my question.

I guess the whole "majority" rules is not always the right way to go about setting laws on everyone. Expecially in social issues.

It seems that no matte how big your voice is..if it isnt BIG enough..you still have the "majority" imposing their values on you.

The smoking thing is really touchy. Like I said, how you can have people that never go into a bar making it impossible for me, who goes to a bar to do what I want in said bar?

v

00camper
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:07:00 AM
Not understanding why some laws are passed by referrendum (or initiative in CA and AZ) and some via the legislature is part and parcel of the problem.

25 to 40 percent of eligible voters decide most state-wide elections. The percentages are far lower in local elections. More like 10 to 12 percent there.

Again, pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeease don't take my comments as a personal flame against you. Once you understand how the system works you can work to change it by running for office yourself, or working for candidates who share your views.

vfrtwice
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:13:00 AM
thats kind of what i need is an education. I can honestly say this is the first time where i have actually felt the effects of something. And my ignorance bothers me!!! It bothers me that this smoking legislation actually went through!! The hypocrocy of the whole thing is what really pisses me off.

Now I see why the sceen in the movie "gangs from newyork" where they are shaving up bumbs and everyone they can find and rushing them to the polls makes sense!!

no offense taken...i claim ignorance! lol

v

v

00camper
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:28:00 AM
We have a similar situation in Louisville. Comprehensive indoor smoking ban in public places and places of employment to take effect July 1, 2007. Except for Churchill Downs. Smoking indoors will be permitted there. Hmmmmmm. Many people expect a court challenge. We'll see.
Sardious
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:34:00 AM
want to know something more sad. In colorado the votes have always been against smoking. So when we got to vote the vote led to the eventual state wide ban.

I just feel burned cause a private business owner on private land can not allow smoking by his patrons even though buying, owning, using, and sell tobacco is NOT illegal. Personal rights. If you want to work away from the smoke then get a job that is not in a smoke friendly bar!!!

Sorry I will not rant any more about the bans. Probably better for my kids in the future or something

jpotts
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:45:00 AM
vfrtwice:

I've got to agree about 99.9% of 00campers original post.

The one main thing you also need to look at is a candidate's history. For example, in Michigan Senator Debbie Stabenow went aroung prior to an election talking about raising taxes (and ending the Bush tax cut), then during the election touted her record on cutting taxes.

All of a sudden, she's simply forgotten anything she's said about tax cuts, and decided that what she was REALLY sent to office for was to create a universal healthcare plan, ala Canada.

History.

vfrtwice
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:45:00 AM
I just wonder how many people are going to die if a heart attack or heart disease related problems BEFORE those die from smoking!!!

Health issues SHOULD NOT BE VOTED ON..PIEROD!!!

v

bassdude
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:50:00 AM
I hear ya and feel for ya on the smoking issue. My advice is much the same as )0 - vote out the folks that don't truly represent you. To do that you will have to become active.

On the school issue I am happy when any referundum passes to help the children - like it or not they will be your govt soon. Even though you may not have kids you still will be affected by them. It pisses me off to no end when the folks cut school funding. Where the hell is the lottery money going? In IL they cut funding big time and thank God we passed a referendum in spite of the folks with no kids. At least it builds us new schools and my kids can stop having class in the stair wells. It still does not cover all the cuts jackass blagojevich rammed through - hell some of the sports teams had to find private funding or be disbanded.

Ok stepping off my soap box. I wish you the best of lcuk on the smoking ban - I am glad MO did not pass their laws.

pacman357
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 11:54:00 AM
vfr, the short answer is that the smoking ban is another example of the majority imposing its will on the minority in the "land of the free". Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness...as long as the majority don't decide to take some of that away from you.

Every state is different, but the majority operate in legislative fashion the same general way. Unless it's a voter or citizen's initiative, which is usually initiated by petition (and in some states, the legislative body can adopt the law petitioned for or let the matter go to the ballot, in others it goes right to a ballot once certified as having enough people signing on the petition), the process usually involves some lawmaker proposing a bill. Other lawmakers may join as co-sponsors or co-authors, especially if the bill is politically popular. The bill goes to the relevant committee. Let's say it's a criminal law, it may go to the state house or senate committee on criminal laws, judiciary, law and justice, something like that.

The committee chair usually has some say over what happens there. If the majority of the committee approves sending the bill to the legislative body, then it may get sent out for a full vote. It could also be re-written before it goes out, can have amendments tacked on, etc. In some states, the committee chair may block sending the matter out for a vote. If that happens often enough, the bill either goes nowhere (dies in committee), gets re-worked, or may go another route. An example of the latter is Washington State's motorcycle helmet law. The chair for the usual committee for such matters blocked it enough times that eventually the law got passed as a health bill, where the chair of THAT committee allowed it to go the the full legislative body for a vote.

Once it goes to the full body for a vote, it can either be amended, voted in as law or voted down. Once a bill or law has been approved, the other legislative body (in a bicameral state, which basically in most states means they have a senate and a house of reps) can either approve it, vote it down, or work on their own version. If the other house approves the bill, too, it usually goes to the governor for signing. If that body has its own version, and the version differs from the bill or law passed by the other body, representatives of the two bodies will need to meet to negotiate a joint or compromise bill. If they work out an agreed form of the bill, that goes back to each body for a vote. Once again, if both bodies approve the bill, then it goes on to the governor.

There are other issues that can come up, such as veto or partial veto, and special interest groups pushing for laws, but that's the basic gist of it.

The short explanation is that it's just The Man's way of keeping us down.

bassdude
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 12:03:00 PM
This may help you, then again it may back fire like Colorado.

The second aforestated power reserved by the people is designated the referendum, and the signatures of six per centum of the electors shall be required upon a petition to order the submission to the electors of the state for their approval or rejection, of any law, section of any law or any item in any law appropriating money passed by the general assembly. No law passed by the general assembly shall go into effect until ninety days after it shall have been filed by the governor in the office of the secretary of state, except as herein provided. When a petition, signed by six per centum of the electors of the state and verified as herein provided, shall have been filed with the secretary of state within ninety days after any law shall have been filed by the governor in the office of the secretary of state, ordering that such law, section of such law or any item in such law appropriating money be submitted to the electors of the state for their approval or rejection, the secretary of state shall submit to the electors of the state for their approval or rejection such law, section or item, in the manner herein provided, at the next succeeding regular or general election in any year occurring subsequent to sixty days after the filing of such petition, and no such law, section or item shall go into effect until and unless approved by a majority of those voting upon the same. If, however, a referendum petition is filed against any such section or item, the remainder of the law shall not thereby be prevented or delayed from going into effect.

vfrtwice
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 6:24:00 PM
In other words...whoever puts the most money in the pockets of senators, house reps, judges ect get what they want 🙂

A law cannot go into affect without their say so. I dont think the "man" really keeps anyone down. We just need to be smarter.

I'm a HUGE gun and hunting proponet. I could not immagine life without it. I need to learn more about this because If they...as the "majority" can take our right to smoke in a freekin bar...lord knows what could happen and has happened in some places in this country when it comes to firearms and hunting.

I still cant believe that spring bear hunting in some areas in cannada was taken away. And after talking to some people on the east coast what they have to go through to have a firearm is CRAZY.

I have always despised and avoided anything that hints of polotics. I cant stand it, but It looks like its something I really need to learn more about. If for nothing else I will know exactly what happend and why for my own sanity when the start taking our guns away.

This whole majority rules thing is actually pretty crazy. Expecially in places like Ohio where you have three major cities Cleveland, Columbus, and cincy influencing decisions for the rest of the state.

States are very divers bodies of land. For a "Majority" of city people to be making decisions for state wide votes for little hick towns where the people could care less is actually kind of nuts.

And to finish...taking the rights away from a guy that worked his ass off to start a business ie a bar..then have a bunch of foofy panzy ass men and women who NEVER will be in his bar tell him that he cant sit in HIS bar and have a cigar or ciggarette is TOTALLY NUTS!!! I just cant believe it can be done!!!

I can see it next where if you have kids, you will be arrested for child endergerment for smoking in your own house.

I just heard that the Honda corperaton near here in Marrysville oh just passed a "law" that their employes are not even aloud to go out at lunch and smoke in their cars!!! No smoking ANYWHERE on the property...and the property is HUGE.

just plain nuts!!

v

pacman357
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 8:25:00 PM
*Sigh*...glad to see the time and effort I spent giving what I thought was a pretty good explanation on how a bill becomes law was well spent. Oh well, next time I'll know better.
00camper
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 3:54:00 AM
pacman357,

Your explanation of how a bill becomes law wasn't wasted. I read it and thought it was good.

bloody spaniard
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 4:15:00 AM
V, a lot of these meddling laws are also passed in order to "protect" the system from money- grubbing lawyers who look for ANY excuse to sue & hit the lottery.

Ever heard of lawsuits due to 2nd hand smoke or bad health resulting from "addiction" to fast food, etc.???

We HAVE to pass tort reform, as well as, throw the bums out, but I wouldn't bet on either.

Laws have already been passed to prohibit smoking at HOME in some jurisdictions.

Better get used to it. It'll only get worse.

vfrtwice
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 6:16:00 AM
pac...your post was not wated. It was very informative. I was making a joke as we all know "money talks" EVERYWHERE!!!

thanks for the input. I was attempting to put it in laymans terms!! haaa

v

jackconrad
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 6:33:00 AM
As an Elected Official i can tell you that idefininatley have stepped into many Bars !
emmajaye
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 6:37:00 AM
One thing you all need to be aware of is when all the big tobacco companies got sued and settled up with different states a lot of money went to anti-tobacco coaltions. There is a lot money being spent on getting the message out that smoking is bad. They do not diffentiate between cigarettes or cigars. They get local city council people on those coalitions and start the drum beat for passing the bans. I have been invited to our local coalition meetings. I don't think anyone realizes that I am a cigar smoker. These meetings seem like a waste of time to me, but I sure as hell am going to stay involved to see where this goes. Our rights are being chipped away constantly and the majority doesn't seem to notice or care. I heard recently that Las Vegas passed the smoking ban. I never thought I would live long enough to see that city pass such a ban. It is truly scary to think that some day some do gooder is going to pass a law that says I can't go out on my deck to smoke a cigar. But it has already happened in California in certain areas. As a cigar smoker and lover, I urge all of you to find out what movements are going on in your localities. Get involved. Raise your voice. If a business wants to ban smoking to get more patrons that is a business decision, but if the government wants to tell me I can't smoke on my own deck then there is a constitutional right of privacy which is infringed. Don't sit by idly and think this won't happen to you/me. I have used this quote on here before "When they came for the jews I didn't speak up because I wasn't jewish. When they came for the Poles, I didn't speak up because I wasn't Polish. When they came for the Czechs, I said nothing because I wasn't one of them. When they came for me, no one else was left to speak up." Speak up.
vfrtwice
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 6:57:00 AM
great post!!!

like I said, this was a huge wake up call for me, an avid outdoorsman and firearms lover. A HUGE WAKE UP CALL!!!!

I need to get educated and more involved!!!

prementioned "do gooders" are nipping at the heals of our right to hunt and bear arms!!

v