THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, December 7, 2006 6:39:00 AM
Given the current political climate is it possible for the U.S. to fight a war of "total commitment"? A war which presses an enemy to complete destruction a la WW2?
andytv
Thursday, December 7, 2006 6:45:00 AM
I don't think so.
teedubbya
Thursday, December 7, 2006 6:47:00 AM
we could have in Afghan and will be able to again someday.

Bush took his eye off the ball and effed up the focus and resolve we and the world had.

it must be the right war for the right reasons. Iraq is not that.

bloody spaniard
Thursday, December 7, 2006 6:56:00 AM
Our leaders don't have the moral resolve or authority anymore.

Public relations (AND political correctness) rules & our media dictates policy.

In the next 5- 10 years, alliances involving Iran, Korea, Russia, China, and other left wing, Third World governments will test our resolve and we are toast.

Hope I'm wrong, but I genuinely fear for our children.

HockeyDad
Thursday, December 7, 2006 7:03:00 AM
BRIC: Brazil, Russia, China, India.

That is the future. Plan accordingly.

Politically, is is possible to fight a war of total commitment right now. Militarily, we are overcommitted worldwide already. The United States should be far more afraid of an economic war where we are most vulnerable and that we will have to convert into a military war to win.

herfsnipe
Thursday, December 7, 2006 7:05:00 AM
The answer to your question depends on whether or not the "enemy" is identifiable, fights by the "rules of war", is willing to die for the sake of it's cause / religion and may or may not have been doing so for thousands of years.

The Germans, when faced with insurmountable odds caved like a California sinkhole and either dropped their weapons and ran or committed suicide. Not many Germans sent their firstborn into the streets of Berlin or the Champs-Elysées with explosives strapped to their arschbackes.

Today's enemy seems "just a bit" more committed. It seems we have neither the right strategic approach and nor manpower to be able claim a complete victory. The current situation could go on for many years to come with little or no progress being made. Seems senseless. Even more so now when you think about the the fact that the country we're assisting is making little or no organized effort to protect it's sovereignty and f***ing help us.

usahog
Thursday, December 7, 2006 7:16:00 AM
I'm tellin Ya... Establish our bases.. set up a perimiter around these bases and let those who want to die for Ala come on out and meet their destiny...

We can train the Iraqi Forces in remote area's and then turn them lose to police their own people...

We're going to be occupying this area for many years/decades to come...

It's time the Iraqi Government is handed a bit more responsibility... If the quarterback can't handle the ball.. bench his ass and pick another star player..

Hog

jpotts
Thursday, December 7, 2006 7:52:00 AM
The answer is "yes."

First, the American people are not a bunch of wimps, as most people seem to think. We suffered far worse during WWII, and had less to start with, then what we've got now. The problem is that things are not perceived as dire as they should be, and therefore not worthy the attention of some.

Come another 9/11-style attack, and that might change.

As far as political climate goes, that can be changed once every 2 years. It just requires the will of the electorate to change it.

Third, history has shown that Americans have done, and can do more with far less then virtually any other nation in the world. When you've got former slaves creating 500 different uses for a peanut (some of which you still use to this very day), then there's very little that cannot be accomplished through resiliant resolve.

Economically, over the years I've heard the same reactionary alarm when it was the Soviets, or the Saudis, or the Japanese that were the next great economic conqurers. And while the US has been "invaded" by some of these forces, it still stands strong. In fact, the economies of Saudi Arabia and Japan rely heavily on a strong US economy. Whereas, when Japan went into a long recession in the ninties, the US economy was barely affected.

bloody spaniard
Thursday, December 7, 2006 7:58:00 AM
In addition to the ever- increasing economic interdependency, Jpotts, the America that you remember is vanishing quickly. We are a Yugoslavia (just prior to Tito's demise) waiting to happen.
jpotts
Thursday, December 7, 2006 8:00:00 AM
Well, I guess time will tell.

The best I can do ie work as hard as I can...

...when I'm not screwing around on this frickin' board.

MACS
Thursday, December 7, 2006 8:32:00 AM
WWII... Germany and Japan were focused on World domination.

If that were to happen again, we'd have the backing of most of the world, like we did then, and we would most certainly have the same outcome.

THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, December 7, 2006 8:39:00 AM
I agree with you for the most part, jpotts.

I think for us to do it though we need a continuous over-arching threat.

The current batch of Islam-o-terrorists hasn't been able to provoke a sustained response from us. Probably because we subconciously realize that they lack the wherewithal to muster a viable, national border changing, military effort. We've become bored with them as an opponent.

When they acquire nukes, one day they will, and are stupid enough to use them, the sleeping giant may re-awaken.

Hog, you're right. But this is my point. Our leaders lack the resolve to make those calls. They've fallen into same trap that Viet Nam should have taught them to avoid. They're letting politics dictate the pace and tactics.

I was never for this war, but I believed that if it was going to be fought half measures wouldn't cut it.

If your going to jump over a ditch you gotta mean it or you end up muddy with everybody laughing at you.

jpotts
Thursday, December 7, 2006 9:01:00 AM
THL:

"I agree with you for the most part, jpotts.'

Don't let that get around. Next thing you know they'll be calling you an anti-semite, liar, bigot, sexist, radical.