I got nothing...
1. Author: Dr Pepperhill Date: 01/08/2007 11:00 PM Reply
Dr. Pepperhill: "Yup, trivia games online are practically moot due to the internet age.
The scary part is that, with so much information at people's fingertips at the speed of light, so many are still woefully ignorant of the basic facts of law, government, history, etc."
J.Redleg: "Doc, I'd agree with you if there wasn't as much misinformation out there.
A little bit of wisdom and common sense is still needed to surf for information."
Not wanting to threadjack the 'name that tune' thread, I wholeheartedly agree J.R. Along with wisdom & common sense, there are also techniques for fact checking to help seperate the propaganda & sales garbage from possibly credible sources.
I was lucky in that I went back to college in my middle age years, and now days it's standard fare at universities to teach basic web fact checking skills. In one of my ethics class we had to research Roe v Wade and the Isreali-Palistinian crisis, highly charged subjects, using fact checking and credibility assessment techniques. A few things I picked up were:
A.) Trim the URL, example: trim this url to
http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/forum/forum.cfm?action=post&performpost=9
and you will get this:
http://www.cigarbid.com
Often this will take you to the home page. There you look for "about, about us, about the authors," link to see who publishes the site. Once you get their name, do a search on them and see what others are saying. For example, if professor of geology Joe Swindle at Fillmypockets University writes that global warming is a myth, see if he's ever been on record as working for or consulting for major coal or energy concerns. If so, he's probably lying.
B) Take with an extra grain of salt information presented on personal blogs or by political groups, often their url will end in '.com' or '.org', as in 'Moveon.org'
Give a litle more credibility to '.edu', '.gov', or bonified news sites, like 'New York Times' or 'Kansas City Star', as they are exposed to liability for publishing false information, whereas blogs or propaganda groups are generally not.
Most news comes from wire services, that others simply re-distribute. For example a train derails in India killing 182 people. All major news outlets will buy the same wire story and re-release it. The environment in which a factual story is presented does in fact affect it's content, or how the story is perceived; few news sources, if any, are objective. For example, if 52 people are killed in Iraqi explosion, Al Jazeera might report that "52 freedom fighters were killed", whereas Fox news might report that "52 terrorists were killed." In fact, it might just be the case that 52 people shopping at an outdoor market for vegetables were killed. Spin can be hard to spot through all the propaganda. Getting the story from API or other wire services can help cut back on the often purposeful editorializing that appears between the wire story quotes.
Information is a good thing, it can only make you stronger. It's well worth taking the care necessary, and using comon sense & wisdom, to be informed about your world.
Sometime the biggest obstacles to overcome are one's own preconceived biases. Truth is good not because it's right or moral, but because you can think better and accomplish more on accurate information than on falsehoods.
2. Author: J.Redleg Date: 01/08/2007 11:07 PM Reply
Well stated.
I'm afraid that there are many that refer to a link that they want to believe to be true.
Or worse yet, people believing everything they read in a forum - not to bash anyone, but I've looked for a simple real estate answer and found people giving very bad advise.
Education is and will always be the true key to start a person of any age down the information highway.
3. Author: HockeyDad Date: 01/08/2007 11:09 PM Reply
The internet is the greatest misinformation and propaganda tool ever invented.
4. Author: jpotts Date: 01/08/2007 11:10 PM Reply
Dr. Pepperhill:
Interesting you should post this. There was an incident on this very board where someone posted a lint to a story from ABC.com about Pakistan's Musharrif making a peace agreement with Al Qaeda. I came on it about four or five posts in, and checked out the link. Come to find out, ABC pulled the link - the story ended up being false.
I'm not sure, but I think it was Brian Ross that did the reporting on his page, but don't quote me on that.
So it only goes to show that even the "reputable" sites are not 100%.
5. Author: jpotts Date: 01/08/2007 11:11 PM Reply
"not to bash anyone, but I've looked for a simple real estate answer and found people giving very bad advise."
Buy high, sell low, and make out like a bandit in the real estate market!
6. Author: J.Redleg Date: 01/08/2007 11:13 PM Reply
jpotts, thanks for the advise. The guy I foreclosed my house from must have believed it. 🙂
7. Author: andytv Date: 01/08/2007 11:15 PM Reply
I love wikipedia.
Today, I read about a bunch of missionaries who had a boner for evangelizing some isolated tribe with a rep for violence..........and they all got killed.
8. Author: jpotts Date: 01/08/2007 11:45 PM Reply
^ That wasn't unusual. Read about Father Marquette.
9. Author: HockeyDad Date: 01/08/2007 11:47 PM Reply
...Just take a look at how many people said Michigan and Ohio State were great teams.
Internet fiction!
10. Author: RICKAMAVEN Date: 01/08/2007 11:51 PM Reply
my first year in college, one of my professors said i will not teach you anything, but i will teach you how to find out everyrhing for yourself.
today all he had to say was google, links, and judgment.
11. Author: Dr Pepperhill Date: 01/09/2007 12:04 AM Reply
Speaking of T-rexes, I don't know if I would have made back in those days Rick. Grueling hours pouring over scholarly journals in the library, notebooks spilling over with references & citatations.
Quite a few of the classes I took were going bookless by the time I graduated. The good old days suck!
12. Author: RICKAMAVEN Date: 01/09/2007 05:16 AM Reply
i learned why boats float even if they are very heavy and what a catalyst is.
i think i am catalyst.
13. Author: allbidness Date: 01/09/2007 06:29 AM Reply
Ah, but how do you teach someone not to see what they want to see and believe what they want to believe because it's more comfortable that way.
14. Author: teedubbya Date: 01/09/2007 08:43 AM Reply
I liked going to the library and actually looking at papers and journals from the 1920s etc. You got a better feel for the time based on the information non specific to the topic at hand. You don't get that with an internet search.
Word would have been better than the damn typewritter however.
15. Author: RICKAMAVEN Date: 01/09/2007 09:41 AM Reply
allbidness
HOPEFULLY IF YOU KEEP REPEATING IT, SOME EYES AND EARS WILL OPEN.
I HAVE BEEN POUNDING BUSH FOR MANY YEARS ON THE BOARDS. I GET LESS NEGATIVE RESPONSE THEN I USED TO., AND SOMETIMES I EVEN GET POSITIVE RESPONSE.
THAT IS A SMALL VICTORY.
16. Author: pgje51 Date: 01/09/2007 11:41 AM Reply
Is this a tribute thread to Al Gore?
17. Author: HockeyDad Date: 01/09/2007 12:34 PM Reply
People are way too obsessed with "truth".
The general public doesn't need to know what the truth is. They need to be trained as to how to react and respond under all circumstances based on how they have been taught to feel.
18. Author: jpotts Date: 01/09/2007 01:02 PM Reply
"HOPEFULLY IF YOU KEEP REPEATING IT, SOME EYES AND EARS WILL OPEN."
Who was it that said, "repeat a lie loud enough, and often enough, and people will believe it"?
By the way, anybody remember what John Wilkes Booth said after he jumped from Lincoln's theater box?
19. Author: Dr Pepperhill Date: 01/10/2007 01:44 AM Reply
HD, your statement has support down at the nuts & bolts biological level.
The human mind is designed as a grand delusion machine, capable of creating monumental fantasy structures of sub-reality , which often bear little resemblance to dull objective reality; which may or may not serve to fulfill the goals of a person or group. If objective reality were important for humans to be aware of, we would have adapted to be more aware of it than we are of our very useful and subjective ideations and fantasies.
Efficacious behavior is what is important to survival and success, not necessarily objective reality, which is really a fringe point of view for very palpable reason.
It's analogous to color & sweetness. There is no red on ripe strawberries, or sweetness in their sugar. Redness is an attribute our minds create for light we perceive of a certain wavelength, and sweetness is created by the mind to alert us to nutrition opportunities in the environment. Redness & sweetness do not exist objectively outside of the human mind, but exist solely in the mind and serve very valuable functions nonetheless. By projecting color and sweetness on things important to us, thus are we benefited, regardless of the fact that color and sweetness have no objective existence outside of our minds.
Our brains are evolved to function, that is, to lie, project, convince, deceive, and create fantastic realities, and to great adaptive success one might add.
Truth is a curiosity attractive only for geeks and esoteric connosseiurs. Even scientists, who are trained to toil professionally to gather and analyze the objective data of nature, go on after work to lie and manipulate for sex, money, social power, and entertainment.
Truth is only useful insofar as it can attain the necessities and pleasaures of life. Where it fails to do so, it's importance diminishes respectively.
Return To Top