Mattie B
Thursday, February 8, 2007 6:36:00 AM
I know this was a topic that was brought up before, but I have to share.

Last night I'm watching the outdoor channel and a self defense program in on. They are discussing the best long gun for home security. The shotgun was the weapon of choice.

Here is the interesting point. The PROS suggested using 7 or 8 bird shot. They said that buckshot can cause to much secondary damage. Bird shot is more than ample to down an intruder.

I would have to agree with what they are saying. If you have ever shot a pine sappling within 5 yrds, you have seen the potential damage.

Just my opinion.

rkrhymes
Thursday, February 8, 2007 6:52:00 AM
Remington 870 - 18 inch barrel - 9 round extended magazine - 2 3/4 (easier for ME to recover from and be ready to launch the next one - as opposed to 3") inch 000 buck - 12 ga.
ixlr8
Thursday, February 8, 2007 7:14:00 AM
OObuck followed w/slug

repeat as needed...

Gunflintwoodshop
Thursday, February 8, 2007 7:24:00 AM
Repost of my story and how I feel about Home Defense loads:

I think a couple of things have to be cleared up. I go thru sometimes 1000 rounds a week at the range I have what you call a expensive hobby to say the least. I have a Mossberg 590 special purpose that I keep handy and I had to use it once while living in Virginia while I was in the service. Long story short I was lucky enough to hear the crackhead coming up the stairs thanks to my now 15 year old black lab and I was able to get my wife, dog and myself in the masterbath. Once he got in the bedroom he was looking for something that we must not have had because he kept screaming about how Tyrone must have sold it. I still to this day have no damn clue what he was talking about. Then it happened he was at the bathroom door pounding and my wife was crying and the was dog barking. I started yelling at him telling him "I have a gun and if you enter this room I will shoot". This went on for what might have been 30 seconds but it seemed like an hour. Then all of a sudden the door flew up and I squeezed the trigger - and what was chaos just a second before was over in a split second. As he lay dieing on my bedroom floor I grabbed my wife and dog and got them out of the house. I ran back upstairs and he was dead by the time I got to him which was only a minute or two after I shot him. All in all everything feel into our corner that night so to speak. I was at a range of 6 feet and the 00 buck had zero spread once it hit his chest in fact it went thru him and penetrated 1/2 drywall over 12 feet away. So if you ask me about what brand to buy I'd tell you who cares as long as when you pull the trigger you feel confident it will go bang. As far as which one holds the most rounds who really cares you need one maybe two shots at the most. The ranges for home defense are between 5-12 feet and it's at night most of the time. If you shoot someone at 10 yards you better pray he has a gun and it's pointed at you. It's going to be hard to explain why you shot a unarmed man at 30 feet when the cops get there. As far as the load goes I think #7, #8 or 00 Buck will all work just fine. What you have to remember is it's not only the load size but it's the amount of foot pounds behind the load size. The most important thing to remember is this isn't a combat zone or a riot zone this is your house and your family, and the winner on that night if that night ever comes will be the person who wants your family the most. All I can say is prepare, prepare, prepare I had a plan and we executed it without any flaws and criminal came to us and that is what you want. You want to have the control in a situation like I had - you want to make him have to come thru a 28" door to get you. While all the while you are waiting to meet his advancing attack on the other side. I never hesitated that night and I looked directly into his eyes as he stood in that door way and I squeezed that trigger. I have never had nightmares nor even felt bad about what happened that night, and I think it's because I know what would have happened to my wife if I hadn't been there. Just my two cents -- Gunflint

Cycleman
Thursday, February 8, 2007 8:49:00 AM
did anyone read all of that....

damn I am one lazy asshat....

I use 45 acp .....

But the sound of a shotgun chambering a slug.... will make most any intruder .... jet..... I MEAN Leave...

rkrhymes
Thursday, February 8, 2007 8:51:00 AM
Cycleman - I too am fond of the venerable .45 ACP - - - on the property - especially inside the house - I am hoping that the sound of the slide slamming shut on the 870 will deter - if not - then the NEXT sound is going to be a really loud one.
Gunflintwoodshop
Thursday, February 8, 2007 9:11:00 AM
I can't tell the deference between a slug or a 00 Buck shell being loaded. In my honest opinion a 45 used on the guy that broke into my house would have resulted in me wresting with him on the bedroom floor until he bleed out. I stick by the shotgun for home defense.
StogeeBoy
Thursday, February 8, 2007 9:19:00 AM
2 words- Deer Slugs... no fragmentation....
nine999
Thursday, February 8, 2007 9:45:00 AM

NINE!!!

Thunder.Gerbil
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:00:00 AM
Back when I was working ambulances in Jamaca Queens I got to scrape up what was left of some poor **** that got hit by a 12ga shell that had been re-packed with dimes. Guy looked like he got hit with a box of flying razor blades.

Most vicious store-bought 12ga shell wounds I've seen were those left by #4-buck magnum rounds out of a riot gun (18-1/2", no choke). Those 41 pelets did a hell of a lot more damage than any 00 wounds I ever saw.

Oh, and .45ACP's hits aint too pretty either. 'specially when someone loads Hydra-Shocks...

buzkirk
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:05:00 AM
I go with the .45 cal in my Colt and Sig 220, loaded with Hydra shock and Black talons
ScottHar
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:19:00 AM
.45 ACP shotgun chambering a slug or a 00 Buck shell #4-buck magnum..."

This is like another language to me -- but fascinating. I've been curious about guns and whatnot for a little while now.

Anyone recommend a book or website that would be a good place to start? I definitely want to arm myself with the best information before I arm myself, you know?

ScottHar

rkrhymes
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:21:00 AM
Gunflint - I agree with you - I didn't make that clear in my post above. Around the house - on the property the 870 is the tool of choice - off property- CCW - my choice is the .45ACP - hydrashoks. Hope I never have to squeeze the trigger on someone - but if they push it - - -
rkrhymes
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:25:00 AM
Scott - locate a local gunshop or pistol range and go talk to them face to face. If you live in a state that allows Concealed Carry - go talk to someone that teaches the class - go ahead - sign up and take the class!
Cycleman
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:34:00 AM
I use Mag-Safe....

but I stagger them with regular ball ammo.

First round is ball ammo, because statistics say that more deaths are self-inflected accidents.

So I PERSONNALLY would rather be shot with ball ammo than Mag Safe. Anyone hit with Mag Safe in the torso... is dead.

So I stagger them .... because the mag safe.... tough deadly.... does NOT shoot through walls .... and what if the **** IS on the other side of the wall.....

gotta have some ball ammo and then just double tap.

And no... I have no plans of shooting myself....

fishinguitarman
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:48:00 AM
Mattie B .........Just confront \'em naked....That\'ll scare \'em to death.
rkrhymes
Thursday, February 8, 2007 10:49:00 AM
FGM - depends on the "bend" of the intruder . . .
Thunder.Gerbil
Thursday, February 8, 2007 11:27:00 AM
Cycleman, I really hope that you never get hit with anything comming out of the businuess end of what was your .45 ACP before the perp. took it from you, because frankly, even a .45 ACP ball round is probably going to kill you - if it doesn't, it'll incapacitate you and the next round will.

(actually, I hope that you, and everyone else here, is never hit by anything more powerfull than a wet noodle)

When you say "Mag-Safe" rounds, is this just another name for what used to be known as the "Glazer Safety Slug"? Sounds like it might be.

I didn't really feel like getting into this before because of all the bull**** macho posturing going on in this thread (not referring to you Michael), but...

The glazer safety slug is probably the best round you could choose for a pistol. Sure, a hollow-point is going to have better range and if you miss the center of mass, which is highly likely under the circumstances for most people, you'll probably still take someone down. Now what happens to that bullet when you miss entirely?

It doesn't vanish into never-never land like the movies show. It goes through walls. It goes through doors. Eventually, it will stop. Hopefully that won't be in your neighbors chest.

A glazer safety slug won't go through two layers of drywall.

Shotgun loads are **** vicious. Period. End of story, doesn't matter if it's high-brass, low-brass, or magnums. At point blank range you can kill someone with a dammed rock-salt load.

#7 low-brass xtra-light rounds, as un-macho as they sound, are going to do a great job of killing anything that they hits at point-blank range. But after hitting a traget or after 15 feet or so it's going to have a hard time going through an interior sheetrock wall. If it does, it will probably only cause minor injuries to whomever is on the other side of the wall.

As Gunflint pointed out: High powered shotgun loads don't stop when they hit someone like they do on TV and in the movies.

How far do you think a deer slug is going to travel after it hits someone? Long way. Exit wounds are far worse than entry wounds. Pull up vfrtwice's post about the deer he shot with a .50 cal muzzle-loader if you want a second opinion. Not quite the same I know, but "bits of lung and flesh everywhere" is a pretty good description of what you're going to be looking at after you pull the trigger. Oh, and remember, the reason it looks like that is because the round exited the body. But where did it go?

One last thing, remember the 4-buck magnum victim I mentioned a few posts back? The left side of his torso was mostly disentegrated by a single round. Unfortunately, so was the better part of the head of the shooter's 8-year old son who happened to be standing on the other side of the wall at the moment the trigger was pulled.

Think about that if you have spouses, kids & neighbors.

fishinguitarman
Thursday, February 8, 2007 11:31:00 AM
#17...LMAO!
fishinguitarman
Thursday, February 8, 2007 11:34:00 AM
#5 Remington Hevi-Shot (3 1/2\" Magnum) will Penetrate 28 gauge Corragated Tin at FORTY YARDS. Turkeys don\'t stand a chance, but overkill for an intruder at 10.