The rethoric is somewhat accurate.
DVD's store information in a digtal format.
The RCA cables that you would use for Component video (Cr, Cb, Y) are carring the video signal in an analog fasion.
For this to happen the signal needs to go through a set of digital to analog converters in the DVD player, then after transmission to the TV the signal is either displayed (older TV's) or converted back to digital (HDTV sets).
Each conversion stage incurrs a loss of signal quality.
The HDMI cable allows the signal to be transmitted in it's native digital form.
Now, here's the bonus - HDMI allows for this signal to be transmitted in High-Definition Digital, rather than standard NTSC.
If that's an HD-DVD disc, hook your HD-DVD player up with both component video RCA cables and with an HDMI cable. Play the DVD and then toggle back and forth between the inputs on the HDTV. This should allow you to see the difference quite clearly.