victor808
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:26:00 AM
Okay guys... since this seems to be a hot topic, I'd like to point out a few items which seem to elude people regarding our planet. These are, what I consider to be the truly inconvenient truths.

1) We are a ways from being able to create a self sustaining environment off of our current planet.

2) We will eventually use up all the resources of this planet. It doesn't matter whether everyone turned into a sierra club tree-hugger tomorrow, or bought 10 Hummers tomorrow. That sort of stuff only affects the speed at which our consumption will occur.

3) In the event that we do consume all of a single necessary resource, we will likely die as a species.

4) Number 3 does not make a bit of difference to anyone other than us as a species. The earth will continue to spin, life will go on in some form or another, we just won't be around to enjoy it.

5) There appears to be some warming of our planet. This is documented and appears to coincide with population density, as well as carbon use.

6) Sufficient warming of the planet may result in the loss of one or more resources which we find necessary to continued survival.

Now, Lets put together a little analogy. You are ill. The doctor diagnoses you as having developed cancer, but is unsure as to precisely which form you have. He has narrowed it down however to two different forms. One possibility is an incurable form of cancer. There is nothing you can do about it, and you will die in 6 months. The other possibility is a curable form of cancer. The treatment isn't particularly fun, but you will survive if you undergo the treatment. There is no way of knowing which form you have. Do you take the treatment?

It's the same damn situation. So, we don't know whether current warming trends are man-made or natural global cycles? If we don't know, shouldn't we at least treat it like its the one we can do something about?

Hell, I don't personally care. I don't intend to have children, so I don't care whether the planet is in one piece after another 100 years or not. In fact, just for fun I may try to destroy it when I'm close to dying. But for those of you who have an intention of leaving any sort of legacy, I would think you would act in a more conservative manner towards these sorts of things.

pmn1
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:31:00 AM
Sorry Vic That dog don't hunt round here.
MACS
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:43:00 AM
While what you say makes a bit of sense... it is most inconvenient.

Sorry.

dkeage
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:50:00 AM
Wow.........the end of your post is a little scarey.......
DrMaddVibe
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:59:00 AM
Climate Panel Recommends Global Temperature Ceiling, Carbon Tax

By Peter Heinlein

United Nations

28 February 2007

A panel of scientists has presented the United Nations a detailed plan for combating climate change. VOA's correspondent at the U.N. Peter Heinlein reports the strategy involves reaching a global agreement on a temperature ceiling.

A group of 18 scientists from 11 countries is calling on the international community to act quickly to prevent catastrophic climate change.

In a report requested by the United Nations and partially paid for by the privately funded U.N. Foundation, the panel warns that any delay could lead to a dangerous rise in sea levels, increasingly turbulent weather, droughts and disease.

The report was issued three weeks after the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change concluded that global warming is real and caused in large part by human activity. But unlike the IPCC report, this latest document makes policy recommendations.

Panel member John Holdren of Harvard University says the world must be mobilized immediately to avoid catastrophe. "Climate change is real, it's already happening, it's already causing harm, it's accelerating and we need to do something about it, and we need to do something about it seriously, starting now. Our specific conclusions are that if the world were to go past the point of an increase above pre-industrial temperatures greater than 2 to 2.5 degrees Celsius, we would be in a regime where the danger of intolerable and unmanageable impacts on well-being would rise very rapidly," he said.

The panel's recommendations include a series of steps to cut the rate at which temperatures are rising. Chief among them are a global agreement on an acceptable ceiling for temperature rise and finding ways of adapting to cope with the damage already done.

Holdren, however, says even these measure will achieve very little unless they are accompanied by a global tax on greenhouse gas emissions. "We don't think ultimately society will get it right in terms of the full range and scope of activities needed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, until there is an additional incentive in the form of a price on greenhouse gas emissions, either through a carbon tax or a cap and trade approach," he said.

The United States is the biggest emitter of greenhouse gasses, but is not a party to the cap and trade system contained in the Kyoto Protocol on climate change.

Nevertheless, the Bush administration has set a target of cutting U.S. greenhouse gas emissions by 18 percent by 2012, and is spending $3 billion a year on climate change research.

Peter Raven, the head of the Sigma Xi Scientific society and co-author of the latest report, says success in limiting the effects of global warming will require private sector leadership, and a combined effort by the U.S. and the international community. "The private sector is doing a very good job, and kind of leadership we're calling for from the United Nations and international organizations and the kind of leadership the United States is moving towards will both be key ingredients in that," he said.

A U.N. spokesman says Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon is considering calling a summit meeting on climate change later this year. Environmental activists are calling on Mr. Ban to play a leading role in the process of negotiating a successor to the Kyoto agreement, which expires in 2012.

http://www.voanews.com/english/2007-02-28-voa2.cfm 

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 11:04:00 AM
"It's the same damn situation. So, we don't know whether current warming trends are man-made or natural global cycles? If we don't know, shouldn't we at least treat it like its the one we can do something about?"

Victor, way to utilize (a variation of) 'Pascal's Wager.'

THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 1:35:00 PM
Isn't it true that nothing is actually consumed, that we just change it's state?

We may succeed in destroying ourselves but I doubt that we'll destroy the planet.

I'm weary of doomsayers whether they're right or not.

Nuclear holocaust

Population bomb

New ice age

DDT

Mercury poisoning

PCBs

Asian flu #1

Asian flu #2

San Andreas fault

Swine flu

Disco

Bird flu

Eggs are bad

Eggs are good

Butter bad

Margarine good

Butter good

Margarine bad

There are probably a few that I've forgotten.

The worst by far has been disco. Truly civilization teetered on the brink.

I've got no fear left for global warming.

That's my inconvenient truth.

jpotts
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 1:52:00 PM
victor808:

"It's the same damn situation. So, we don't know whether current warming trends are man-made or natural global cycles? If we don't know, shouldn't we at least treat it like its the one we can do something about?"

No. Because if you treat a curable cancer like an incurable cancer (meaning the method of treatment), you'll probably die anyways. If you cure a radiosensitive cancer with chemotherapy, you'll probably end up dead anyways.

The world has been far warmer and far cooler then it is at present. The current warming trend is evident because the world has just come off a mini-ice age, that ended sometime early in the 20th century. The fact is that the environment is dynamic, and our most accurate temperature / weather records only go back some 200 years (at the very, very best). All else is little better then circumstanial evidence (such as ice core samples and tree ring densities).

If you look hard enough, you'll see people in the past have made predictions that when the world's population got to a certain level (a number we've already exceeded by now) that the world's population would become unsustainable. If you also look back at articles in Newsweek and Time, you'll see how scientists were predicting a new ice age (and that was only about 30 years ago). Now, some of the VERY SAME scientists are predicting global warming and environmental collapse. If these people were that wrong then, what's to say they're right now?

Remember the alarm of "Acid Rain"? Notice how no one seems to be talking about it any more? Wanna bet that the dire predictions about this,made way back when, never came true?

Remember the holes in the ozone layer? Notice how no one is talking about that either?

Does anyone remember how the "scientific community" scoffed when Ronald Reagan said that there were trees that actually produce pollution / smog? He was right about that, but the way.

All of this alarmist stuff has the same scientific credibility as the outrageous claims that conservationists made about the Spotted Owl. It's a bunch of bogus pap that can't be proven, at least at this point in the human experience. And if you don't believe me, pick out 10 dates in the future, and ask one of these experts to predict what the weather will be like - specifically, meaning exact temperature at the exact time of day, and the excat amount of rainfall - at your house on any of these dates. If you get more then 6 correct answers, then we'll talk.

Let's face it, doom and gloom brings in the grants and funding. No one wants to fund research that'll tell them they have nothing to worry about. For example, who wants to fund a program that will stop asteroids from destroying the Earth when the chance of the Earth being destroyed by an asterioid is virtually nil? Answer: no one.

jpotts
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 1:54:00 PM
THL:

"There are probably a few that I've forgotten."

You forgot:

* Saccarine causes cancer

* Oat bran prevents cancer

* Alar causes cancer

8trackdisco
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 3:40:00 PM
'..Swine flu

Disco

Bird flu..'

------------------------------------------

Wash your mouth out, THL.

Sincerely,

8trackdisco.

teedubbya
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 3:51:00 PM
I don't intend to have children either. Unless they improve the surgery.
rugrunner
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 4:16:00 PM
LOL I guess your idea of truth and incontinent are equally correct. #5 is tragically flawed logic at its most Victor.

THL you forgot:

Running out of fresh water by 1982

Radon gas

teedubbya
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 4:41:00 PM
Weiner
THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic
Thursday, March 1, 2007 5:24:00 AM
Yep, you're right rugs. That and acid rain, acid reflux, ozone layer holes, now an asteroid.....

It can be tough to separate the wheat from the chaff sometimes. All sides trot out eminent experts who like politicians and zealots say that if you don't see it their way you're an idiot responsible for the destruction of mankind.

Gimme a break.....I'm panic-ed out.

I think probably the 1st headline in the 1st newspaper warned us of the imminent destruction of all that we hold dear.

bloody spaniard
Thursday, March 1, 2007 5:36:00 AM
The mercury poisoning "panic" has affected my family TWICE due to ignorance & GREED.
pmn1
Thursday, March 1, 2007 6:12:00 AM
Level RED
THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic
Thursday, March 1, 2007 6:42:00 AM
Bloody,

On who's part? Have they been drinking from the thermometer again?

teedubbya
Thursday, March 1, 2007 6:45:00 AM
mercury and similar have been used as preservatives
THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic
Thursday, March 1, 2007 6:56:00 AM
Hey, I forgot about the plight of the rainforests! When I was in high school,(I graduated in 1972) we were told that there would be no more rainforests by 1985.

If the icecaps shrink then the tundras will move further north and south respectively, right?

This will leave room for more trees!