topper7788
Thursday, March 1, 2007 11:35:00 AM
Since went over a 100 on the 20K car thread, I thought you may find this of interest. This came out of a Trade publication from AIADA (American International Automobile Dealers) It's a little long, but I did not want to edit anything...

Topper (David)

What will be the fuel of the future?

By Les Jackson

AIADA Contributing Editor

By the middle part of the 21st Century engineers and scientists see a shift to fully electric vehicles. Internal combustion-powered vehicles will be relegated to museums, parades and shows, much like carriages and steam engines are displayed today. Reaching that point will take a number of steps that must, along the way, solve the many technical, economic and social issues facing such a dramatic change.

Today’s vehicles utilize state-of-the-art technologies to achieve the low levels of emissions demanded by government regulations and public health. Sophisticated computer software in vehicles keeps them running smoothly and reliably for tens of thousands of miles without maintenance, yet they are over 140 times cleaner than those of the pre-emissions era of the late 1960s.

How clean is that? Well, to equal the emissions accumulated in a one-way drive from Washington DC to Baltimore, MD in a typical V8-powered 1968 car, you would have to drive a modern car from DC to Los Angeles International Airport and back again, a trip of over 6,000 miles.

While the industry has every right to be proud of these impressive accomplishments in emission reduction, other pressures have conspired to make the industry seek alternative technologies to power vehicles in the future. These pressures include global warming issues, petroleum supplies and energy independence, international trade, world population and a number of others, all of which merge into a difficult-to-solve "equation."

The auto industry foresaw many of these pressures a number of years ago and most manufacturers responded by embarking on research programs to investigate alternative fuels and other technologies. The goal of these programs is to eventually remove conventional internal-combustion engines from the equation, but any alternative products that come into the marketplace must satisfy the public’s expectations in the areas of comfort, safety and economy. If not, they won’t sell.

New Directions

As far as the auto industry is concerned there are no restrictions on the range of technologies to be considered. Any and all ideas will be investigated until proven unfeasible, and it’s possible that the "magic bullet" has yet to be discovered. However, the consensus of the industry is that no one technology will prove to be the solution to alternative energy or large gains in fuel economy in existing drivetrains. The solution will almost certainly be a number of different approaches that will cumulatively effect the change.

Promising new and existing technologies are now coming into the marketplace. Each has its own advantages. Let’s take a look at some…

Diesel

By far the oldest technology – and still an internal combustion system – diesel has the potential of being one of several important "bridges" to the future. Diesel engines are at least 30% more thermally efficient than gasoline engines, which means a directly-translated mileage benefit to the user. If every passenger vehicle in the U.S. was powered by an equal-output diesel engine today we would be using roughly 30% less petroleum than we do now.

We don’t, however. Currently the diesel-powered U.S. passenger vehicle fleet is less than 1% of the total. This is a tiny fraction of comparable European and Asian fleets, where over half of all new vehicles are diesel-powered. The good news is that the major issues blocking acceptance of diesel engines here (noise, soot, odor, sluggishness) have all been solved.

Today’s diesel engines are designed for quiet operation and are equipped with turbochargers, direct injection (a high-tech fuel injection system) and various exhaust treatment systems to make them as clean-running as their gasoline-fueled counterparts. The recent phase-in of ultra low sulfur diesel fuel in the U.S. allows the use of BLUETEC technology to achieve the most stringent 50-state emissions standards.

BLUETEC is technology initiated jointly by Audi, Mercedes-Benz and Volkswagen and is a uniform label for clean and highly efficient engine/exhaust management systems. For instance, Volkswagen utilizes a nitrogen oxide storage catalyst and engine management system in the new Jetta TDI that changes operating modes periodically to treat the N0x stored in the catalytic converter, along with a particulate filter in the exhaust system. Mercedes-Benz utilizes urea injection into the exhaust, along with other particulate filtering, to achieve impressively low levels of N0x.

Biodiesel

Diesel engines can theoretically run on anything that will burn, including used cooking oils, but practical considerations (foreign substances, fluidity, temperature stability and others) dictate that standards must be met. Overall, biodiesel is a domestic, renewable fuel derived from natural oils like soybean or canola, and which meets the specifications of ASTM D 6751 (rules that cover issues pertaining to those above, along with clean air and other health effects and engine warranty concerns.) Biodiesel is generally a mixture of natural oils and petroleum-based diesel fuel, typically using 2-5% of the latter.

Benefits of biodiesel, aside from lowering dependence on foreign oil, include the reduction of carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, particulates and sulfur dioxide. Biodiesel fuel has higher lubricity, which translates to lower maintenance costs. Above all, the fuel is renewable.

Ethanol

Another renewable fuel that can be used in place of gasoline is ethanol, which is alcohol derived from plant sources. It is commonly made from corn, saw grasses and sugar cane, but can be made from a host of other crops. It has an inherently high octane number, making it a desirable fuel for high compression engines. Existing engines can be easily and inexpensively modified to run ethanol or blends of ethanol and gasoline – the most common is E85, a blend of 85% ethanol and 15% gasoline – and there are already nearly 2 million "flex-fuel" vehicles on the road in the U.S. that can run on ethanol.

A major benefit of ethanol is its extremely low emissions output, due to its high oxygen content. It dramatically reduces hydrocarbon and nitrogen oxide and carbon dioxide emissions. Ethanol greatly reduces VOC’s (volatile organic compounds) and particulate matter. It is produced through agriculture and therefore contributes to a major reduction in dependence on foreign oil.

Others

Hydrogen, compressed natural gas, propane and methanol are also fuels that can be run in gasoline engines, although significant modifications need to be made. These fuels are particularly suited to certain applications such as fleet usage, warehouse or closed-space operation. Compressed natural gas is being used extensively in urban buses as a way to reduce emissions.

Manufacturers are also using displacement-on-demand (electronically controlling how many cylinders should fire, depending upon power requirements) to make small increases in fuel mileage. Another approach is the use of 6, 7 and even 8-speed automatic transmissions to maximize the power transfer efficiencies in existing vehicles. Constant velocity transmissions are also being utilized by some manufacturers such as Nissan, which has CVT transmissions available in most of its vehicles. This technology allows the engine to run at its most efficient level during most driving situations.

Turbocharging is another well-known technology that increases thermal efficiency, thereby allowing greater power from less displacement, as smaller displacement engines use less fuel. Volkswagen has demonstrated impressive power output from a 1.4 liter engine by using both a turbocharger and supercharger. Fuel mileage is in the low 40s per gallon.

Hybrids

Hybrids are hot items these days. Toyota and Honda dominate the market at the moment and many other manufacturers either offer their own versions or will soon be doing so. Hybrids (a combination of a small gas engine, electric motor and battery storage) offer significant benefits, including lower overall emissions, high fuel mileage, quiet operation and a feeling that the owner is contributing in some small way toward solving the problems facing us. Tax incentives are available for hybrid owners.

On the drawing boards are future hybrids that promise to be even more stingy with fuel. Plug-in hybrids will have greater battery storage and the ability to be re-charged from an available outlet (at home or at work), thus increasing the operating range and decreasing the amount of time the gas engine needs to run. Fuel economies of up to 80 mpg are foreseen. Another approach is the replacement of the gas engine to a smaller displacement diesel engine. This yields the same amount of power but with a 30% increase in fuel mileage.

Fuel Cells

Fuel cell technology, used in the space program for over 40 years, is currently being developed by most major auto manufacturers or, at the least, is heavily researched. It currently shows the greatest amount of promise toward the goal of electric-powered vehicles, wherein electricity to run the motor is produced in an electro-chemical device (called a proton exchange membrane) that strips electrons from hydrogen, hydrocarbons or alcohols to produce the amount of current necessary.

The fuel cell has tremendous appeal because it can not only be used to power a vehicle but also stationary powerplants for rural, military and countless other applications. Fuel cells are environmentally clean, producing nothing more than water vapor. The fuel consumed is widely available (hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe) and, eventually, should be inexpensively produced.

Presently Honda, DaimlerChrysler, Toyota, Hyundai, Nissan, Audi, BMW, Daihatsu, Fiat, Kia, Mitsubishi, Peugeot, Suzuki, Volkswagen, Ford, GM and Shell Oil have active fuel cell programs and test vehicles.

Les Jackson is a syndicated automotive writer whose columns appear in a number of publications.

DrMaddVibe
Thursday, March 1, 2007 12:16:00 PM
Biodiesel???

With all of the obese kids running around and the transfats kicks...we can take that one off of the table. They'll be closing up fast food restaurants before they shutter up peep show palaces. Bank that one! That will reduce the "supply", thus reducing the demand.

Fuel cell

Most people don't know this, but the main reason why DiamlerBenz went after Dodge was for their advancements in fuel cell technology. The Charger was supposed to be the first car mass produced with this power plant. Oddly enough, since the merger...the research labs have been moved to Germany, no car has been produced and not a peep except for Popular Mechanics type magazines even carry stories about it.

Personally, I'd like to see a more intelligent type car that uses computers to maximize and sheild the driving experience for us the consumer. I want them to be able to go on autopilot and I want them safe enough with redundancy.

What I really want is the flying car. Oh, its out there. The price tag is high. I remember going to auto shows as a kid and seeing the Star Wars type concept vehicles and we're no closer to seeing those on the road than we are seeing France become a superpower again.

http://www.moller.com/ 

You open up a dealership for these at the same price point as say a Lincoln Navigator and the factory won't be able to keep up with the demand!

http://money.cnn.com/2006/05/04/technology/business2_wrightspeed/ 

or this...http://www.teslamotors.com/index.php?js_enabled=1

But these are secondary choices to the Moller car.

jpotts
Thursday, March 1, 2007 12:30:00 PM
Ford is rolling out its new Diesel engine this year, called the "Clean Diesel". I'm not sure of the details as to the difference, but it's a big deal around here.

There are a number of Ford vehicles that can switch between Ethanol and Gasoline, and even burn a blend of these fuels. Right now, there are about 6 on the Flex-fuel program, and have been out there since before 2000.

A number of ethanol and bio-diesel factories are beginning to pop-up in and around Michigan. There have been some new advancements in getting greater yields in ethanol by moving to stuff like sugar beets and cellulose ethanol (corn stalks). While ethanol only produces about 60% the power of gasoline, this is easily fixed with putting in bigger gas tanks.

I actually see biodiesel being the both a long and short-term solution to the nation's fuel "problem" (which wouldn't exist if we didn't drive oil companies to go overseas to get their product). It's cheap to produce, you can make it out of virtually anything (I red somewhere that Canada has been turning waste from slaughterhouses into biodiesel fuel), and with the proper additives, it is virtually indistinguishable from normal diesel.

Ethanol is a good alternative, but I don't think it'll catch on. Frankly speaking, I just don't see electric cars catching on anytime soon, or even in 2050. Too many disadvantages to them, they'll be too much of a draw on our current power grid (as it stands now, we have blackouts in the summer when everyone turns on their air conditioners), and they're too expensive to maintain.

But we'll see what the future holds.

teedubbya
Thursday, March 1, 2007 12:47:00 PM
I thought about a VW deisel awhile back but couldn't justify it.
edsbar60
Thursday, March 1, 2007 1:15:00 PM
If this becomes cost-effective for vehicles then this will keep hybrids around for awhile.

There's new developments in Li-ion batteries that are safer and can be fully recharged in 5 minutes.

http://www.a123systems.com/html/tech/overview.html 

topper7788
Thursday, March 1, 2007 1:22:00 PM
Guys,

The skinny is Hybrids are the "bridge" and our grand kids WILL be driving fuel cell "Hydrogen powered" cars. We are 20 to 40 years away from a "Hydrogen" based fuel economy.

GM should have a plug in Hybrid on the road hopefully around 2010 with real world fuel economy of about 80MPG. This is not a pipe-dream, there are still some battery issue's to work out but according to the engineers its doable and being worked on RIGHT NOW! AKA Chevy Volt that has been on the auto show circuit this year. Toyota is also working on similar technology. This I know first hand. But make no misstake your not buying one of these at $20,000 or less. Toyota will be coming out with a 400+HP Hybrid sports car that gets over 25MPG.

LOTS of reason why fuel cells are not in use yet. Infrastructure, technology, COST... But that is what's coming. At least as far as the talk is with GM and several other makers.

DrMaddVibe
Thursday, March 1, 2007 2:41:00 PM
GM already had an EV car. They chose to scrap it and demolished the remains.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM_EV1 

I'd like to know why it's taking until 2010 for them to get to the marketplace. It's not like they had to re-engineer too much.

jackconrad
Thursday, March 1, 2007 2:47:00 PM
I'd tie the Old Lady up to the reins but she's gettin to damned slow in her old age !!!
topper7788
Thursday, March 1, 2007 4:26:00 PM
Maddvibe,

"GM already had an EV car. They chose to scrap it and demolished the remains.

I'd like to know why it's taking until 2010 for them to get to the marketplace. It's not like they had to re-engineer too much. "

(Sarcasm on)

Because it is a conspiracy between George Bush and GM and BIG OIL, to soak the public...

(Sarcasm off)

Are you just trying to bait me? or are you just talking out your butt? but anyway this is the answer.

This is ENTIRELY NEW TECHNOLOGY, which basically runs the vehicle on batteries almost exclusively and uses the gas engine to recharge the batteries, and it can also be plugged in to wall for charging.

Unfortunately there is currently NO batteries available to put out the power GM wants that are light enough yet. From what we (the dealers) have been told they are currently engineering the vehicles now on the come that the batteries will be available in volume and at a price point to make the vehicle viable in the market.

Also, up to a year or so ago it was deemed by all but Toyota that Hybrid's in volume were just not viable in the market with gas under $2.00 a gallon, a view by the way shared by the US three, Mercedes, BMW, VW, Nissan, and about everyone else. Even Toyota really just wanted the Prius to be a display of Technology for Toyota... But there luck or timing was just right..

A 80MPG Hybrid will not sell real well if it costs $80,000 !

The first GM electric died because

a. it really was not a very good car and

b. the PUBLIC did not want it.

jpotts
Thursday, March 1, 2007 6:17:00 PM
"I'd like to know why it's taking until 2010 for them to get to the marketplace. It's not like they had to re-engineer too much."

Actually, you have to reengineer quite a bit. Pure-electric cars run on a static charge, whith some recharge capability. Hybrid cars switch back and forth between technologies, and the battery management is a little more difficult.

Secondly, while Ford is moving to standards (yours truely trying to drive that home) both GM and Chrysler tend to do things their own way, developing their own internal network protocols, communications systems and so on. Would you believe that GM had a "bare wire" network system that purposely used a single, uninsulated wire that communicated with all of the vehicle modules (computers) in the car? They did, and it saved them something like 20 lbs worth of weight in the vehicle.

Most people, however, call that penny-wise and pound foolish. But I digress...

I agree that hybrids are simply a short-term solution to a long term problem. It takes a LOT of energy to move a car, and something like a fuel cell would be kinda like having a mini nuclear reactor on board your car in order to power it efficiently, and over a long period of time, making it cost-effective to own one of these types of vehicles.

I seriously don't think the internal combustion engine is going anywhere, anytime soon. It is a very efficient machine for locomotion that can be adapted to a multitude of fuels and purposes.

DrMaddVibe
Friday, March 2, 2007 4:51:00 AM
"Are you just trying to bait me? or are you just talking out your butt? but anyway this is the answer."

I've heard from good sources and from what I've been able to cull is that you're a master baiter. Nobody else can touch you.

As far as talking out of my butt, I'm not a ventriliquist or a car salseman.

Do you even bother to cut and paste links and READ what people put up?

topper7788
Friday, March 2, 2007 5:17:00 AM
Maddvibe,

"I've heard from good sources and from what I've been able to cull is that you're a master baiter. Nobody

else can touch you."

Uuhhh, that's like 6th grade, how old are you?

"As far as talking out of my butt, I'm not a ventriliquist or a car salseman."

Did you put a lot of time into that comeback?

Obviously you have never sold cars, your lack of knowledge of your DAD's business shows that.

"Do you even bother to cut and paste links and READ what people put up?"

Am I missing something? Isn't this cut and paste? Gee I thought I did that all the time... And I generally read what interests me, you?

Hey, you might want to use a spell checker, your spelling sucks worse than mine!!!!

DrMaddVibe
Friday, March 2, 2007 5:26:00 AM
Here...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM_EV1 

from there you can get to...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevrolet_Volt_Concept 

What part of this sentence did you NOT get when you were in these discussions for this car?

"At the time of the Volt concept's unveiling, GM's estimates for the battery pack's cost using existing technology ranged as high as $20,000. GM stated they likely wouldn't consider producing the vehicle until the cost was reduced to $4,000 or $5,000"

You're not too bright.

topper7788
Friday, March 2, 2007 5:48:00 AM
Maddvibe,

OMG, you quoting wikipedia! I'm impressed you can read.

I do not need to look this stuff up. ITS WHAT I DO FOR A LIVING GENIOUS!!! I have sat in session with GM engineers explaining were we stand on this technology,

If you bothered to read my post I already said COST was one factor, THE BIG ON IS THESE BATTERIES CANNOT be produced today in volume PERIOD the teck is not their yet for the type of battery GM intends to use.

GM is working on the rest of the car WITHOUT actually having a battery package for the car.. Plus genius it takes quite a lot to engineer and deliver to market a TOTALLY new automobile! Several years in fact even if it was not a Hybrid.

As dealers sometimes we see vehicles 2 or 3 years prior to them coming to market, and the manufactures were designing, engineering those same vehicles 2 or 3 years prior to that !!

This is what I said, AND it is correct...

"Unfortunately there is currently NO batteries available to put out the power GM wants that are light enough yet. From what we (the dealers) have been told they are currently engineering the vehicles now on the come that the batteries will be available in volume and at a price point to make the vehicle viable in the market. "

DrMaddVibe
Friday, March 2, 2007 6:12:00 AM
In my line of work...we support engineers in the labs...proving grounds and plant floors. The things I've seen in North and South America with regards to especially GM pale to some sales force diatribe you want to cheer about.

I've been privvy to cars that you'll never see, failures that didn't make it out of the labs and been underground in rooms that even Rick Wagoner couldn't get into. You're spoonfed the very same info that's on wikipedia and you can't come up with any other info to refute wikipedia! You want to call me a genius? Ok, I'll post up a link where people can see and digest information with their own brain. What's your source again?

As far as the batteries go...that's their way out. Just like they folded up their tents in the 90's with the EV "project", they'll do the same thing again. "People didn't want it", "It costs too much to produce" or "It's not profitable".

If it wasn't about making a buck and solving a global problem, you'd think there would be a consortium of auto companies creating an automotive "Manhattan Project"(you can google that one up)to solve the issue. It really is just a business though. Seeing as how GM is desperate to recapture buyers they'll say anything to get you on the lot, and getting you to "party talk" to the masses on your lot is the 1st step in creating a buzz that most likely their kids won't even see!

teedubbya
Friday, March 2, 2007 6:15:00 AM
hey topper -

admittedly I've only been skimming this thread. And this is possibly a softball question.

how does GM fare in relation to the rest of the big manufacturers (stick with the big three and the big three jap.) in alternative development and tech?

I was reading the other day how the whole mercedes chrisler debauchle was Mercedes way of grabbing alternative tech. and basically that stalled things.

Just thinking out loud. Admittedly I don't know much about the subject.

topper7788
Friday, March 2, 2007 8:20:00 AM
Maddvibe,

First of all, I handle 6 brands, 3 domestic Cadillac-Pontiac, and Jeep as well as Nissan, Mitsubishi and Kia.

I have been here just under a year. Previous to this I ran a Toyota and Acura dealer for another large group. I CERTAILNLY don't and won't shill for GM...

On the thread were advise was asked on what to buy my responses were primarily Toyota's and Honda's.

You can claim whatever you want, you still don't have a clue... And yes GM, HONDA both folded their electric programs BECOUSE it did not make sense at the time. PERIOD and even now Hybrids are still NOT the best value if you look at ownership costs.. When my mother in law asked me about a Prius I recommended a Corolla it was simply a better value. Plus GM is not what it once was and product development dollars HAVE to go were they get the best return on investment.

My fellow dealers and manufactures are not interested in saving the planet.. We'll leave that to Al Gore. My job is to make profit for my owner, and GM's job is to preform for it's stockholder's. NOBODY has ever claimed less.

So you can make all the stupid comments you want, but my posts and actions speak for themselves.

topper7788
Friday, March 2, 2007 8:39:00 AM
TW,

"hey topper -

how does GM fare in relation to the rest of the big manufacturers (stick with the big three and the big three jap.) in alternative development and tech?

I was reading the other day how the whole mercedes chrisler debauchle was Mercedes way of grabbing alternative tech. and basically that stalled things."

Remember I am a car dealer and I don't work for the manufactures, but this is what I know:

DaimlerChrysler wanted nothing to do with Hybrids as of 3 years ago when I was affiliated with A Chrysler store, they are heavily invested in Diesel Technology. And were starting at that time to look seriously at Fuel Cell tech.

Ford, buys its Hybrid Technology from Toyota and their for is always a generation back, they do however offer lots of vehicles that are "Flex Fuel" ready E-85 Ethanol.

GM, Easily spends the most of the big three on Hybrids, with several models now available and MANY more coming shortly. They are also working hard on "plug in" hybrid technology, what I was talking about earlier in the thread.

Remember that GM has much more limited resources than it used to, so the first thing is getting the company profitable not saving the planet. The "Plug in" technology is as Michael Jackson the head of AutoNation calls it is "Game Changing". That's were the bulk of GM short term alternative program is. Long term Fuel Cell's.

Now Ford is really in trouble and is not to my knowledge spending much on development at all. Almost all of their money is going to conventional product to try and get them back as a viable company again.

Toyota by far leads all manufactures in "alternative fuel" development and is committed to having a full line of Hybrids for sale over the next several years and bringing down the cost difference from conventional by 50%. At their National Dealer meeting 2 years ago Jim Press said (The guy who runs US Toyota) that Toyota's long term goal is to build a car that will cross the country on ONE tank of gas.. He may be stretching the point but that was what he said...Heck they made over 10 BILLON dollars last year.

Honda has a Hybrid program, but as of a couple of years ago it was not that big of a priority. I can't speak for them today because I have been out of the Acura business for almost 2 years. Their resources are limited as compared to Toyota. They are nowhere near the size of Toyota and have a much smaller worldwide product line.

Hope that helps.. And remember, the above is my observations, I do not work for those companies but I have represented the product lines and most manufacturers are VERY forthcoming to their dealer body.

teedubbya
Friday, March 2, 2007 8:46:00 AM
^ I gottcha. Interesting non the less
topper7788
Friday, March 2, 2007 9:01:00 AM
TW,

Remember if gas had stayed at under $2 a gallon, the thread would have said, "why is Toyota trying so sell this ugly little car"