Here's my take on it.
I don't see any of the current frontrunners standing a chance. Rudy is too liberal on social issues to capture the hearts of true conservatives. He's got the hutzpa and the credentials on the war issue and he's a true fiscal conservative, but in the long run, he won't make it. McCain is a no go. He's abandoned the party on too many key issues in the past, perhaps in an effort to etablish himself as a 'maverick' but the party liners don't want a maverick, they want someone who will stand up to the liberals when it counts and McCain has a history of letting them down. Romney is an interesting candidate and may have a legitimate shot at the top spot, but more likey he'll get a V.P. nod to bring in the votes from the liberal Northeast. Personally, I like Fred Thompson, although he'll have to answer for his support of the McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Reform Bill. He seems like a true conservative with the charisma and electibility we need. Although most people are familiar with him because of his acting career, most of those polled recently say they have a favorable opinion of him, even the democrats.
As for the Dems, I don't see Hilary winning the nomination. There are just too many people in her own party that can't stand her. Obama's camp is well organized and will do a great job of tearing her down in the next 8 months before the primaries begin. There are a lot of skeletons in her closet and there are a lot of people working around the clock in an effort to dig them out. As for the Senator from Illinois, well, quid pro quo. . . Hilary's side will do a fine job of destroying him, although his short history in the public's eye will work to his advantage as there's less dirt to dig up. I don't think Edwards can pull it off. He's not the type people get passionate over,(sort of like Al Gore) sorry. I wouldn't rule out Joe Biden from Pennsyvania, though. He's tough, experienced and Pennsylvania carries a boat load of electoral votes.
All in all it looks like a wide open field, but as I said, I don't think any of the current frontrunners are electible. I think there's a dark horse to watch for in both races.