00camper
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 10:12:00 AM
I just wish they'd leave the poor guy alone. Mistakes were made and (over)exposed. Let's move on already.
johnfs
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 10:30:00 AM
"Mistakes were made and (over)exposed."

Not according to his family, after all it was his brother asking congress to investigate the matter surounding his death and the release of misinformation. It appears his family does not agree with you. It is the Army and administration that have disrespected the courage of a fine american and his family, by telling lies to his family and the american public.

00camper
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 11:08:00 AM
I didn't mean "overexposed". I meant to say that the matter has been dissected and discussed extensively and yet the media still keeps bringing it up.

I say let the poor man stay dead.

herfsnipe
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 11:11:00 AM
I agree this should play out for as long as it takes. Heads should roll. Cover-ups are always worse than the actual incident. They knew 2 days after PT was killed that it was "fratricide".

Friendly fire. Never good, but it does happen. All the family ever wanted was for someone in the chain of command to tell them "Yes, it was us. It was an accident. We own it, we're sorry."

They were too busy with Operation Camouflage. The armed services have operated far too long with the attitude that they are untouchable as long as there is a war going on.

BULLS#I7!

You can't just kill innocent civilians BECAUSE YOU CAN'T FIND THE BOMBER, you can't parade "detainees" or whatever the F#@& they call them this week around in their birthday suits and stack them like cordwood on top of each other, taking their pictures while pointing to their pec#er, and you sure as F#@& can't shoot your fellow soldiers, call them heroes, and JUST CARRY ON LIKE NOTHING HAPPENED and expect the American people JUST ACCEPT IT.

Someone needs to answer for Pat Tillman.

teedubbya
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 11:16:00 AM
I'd agree with you camper if thats what his family wanted as well. Afterall, they are the ones left behind.
delarob
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 11:42:00 AM
I think what's disrespecting is what is going now. Granted an accident happened. Tell the family he died like a soldier. He is a hero. He died in service that he volunteered for. All of this heartache is not nescessary and heads should roll, but not in the spotlight like this. It cheapens his service. Of the rolling heads should be the one that leaked the info.
ixlr8
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 12:01:00 PM
What about those who con-cocted the KIA story line?

Too bad there isn't a cartoon about this or

greensheep would have it posted on the pic-post..(note: Somebody get that boy some sharp color crayons...)

SteveS
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 12:05:00 PM
=======================================

Author: herfsnipe Date: 04/24/2007 03:11 PM

Someone needs to answer for Pat Tillman.

=======================================

The assignment of guilt and blame is not and should not be an issue ... and the fact that there are those who persist in trying to make it so, whether in this case or any other, is a huge problem in today's society ...

Pat Tillman is a hero ... period ... end of story.

He gave up a high-profile, high-paying career in the NFL to join the military and try to make a difference. He went to war on behalf of the United States and it's citizens including you, me and a lot of others.

War is a dangerous thing ... people get hurt and some of them get killed ... some of those who get killed in war die as a result of an attempt of others on their side to inflict casualties on the other side ... dating back to the first war in history, it has ALWAYS been this way ...

It makes NO difference where the bullet came from that killed him ... he is no less a hero because he died as the result of friendly fire ... it is particularly sad that such is the case, but make no mistake about it ...

Pat Tillman is a hero ... period ... end of story.

ixlr8
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 12:10:00 PM
Read a story yesterday from his BROTHER

seems he and the family are upset and the media

chose to publish that fact! Spin is for faux news!

teedubbya
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 12:15:00 PM
He is a hero. Period. SteveS is correct.

That should be seperated from dolts who tried to use his unfortunate death for gain by flat out lying. They should have said nothing or told the truth.

You can not have it both ways. You can not try to use his death then get upset for people calling your stench a stench.

ixlr8
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 12:17:00 PM
tee...word!
Charlie
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:03:00 PM
lxr8 or whatever you are...it is Fox News, you need to learn to watch Fox once in a while and quit listening to NPR.

Charlie

HockeyDad
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:07:00 PM
The important thing is that we don't lose sight of the Global War on Terror.
GreenWolf70
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:21:00 PM
I'm of two minds on this.

On one hand, being shot while on point is indicative of one piss poor unit. Its infantry basic 101. And the comments about the guy who shot PT being anxious to kill someone is also amatuerish and this was a Ranger unit, supposedly an elite unit. Just sounds like there was a lack of leadership here to begin. So I'm wondering if they were really covering up criminally poor leadership that led to this fratracide situation.

Then being that PT had a high hero profile, I can understand the Army wanting to "protect" the family and the country by presenting PT as dying a hero's death. Understand, but definately do not agree with the lying. So, yes, heads should roll for being stupid. But these are individuals and not some systematic Army problem.

jpotts
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:33:00 PM
Lots of people died in WWII due to friendly fire. It happens all the time in war. It's a little thing known as The Fog of War. People mistake friend for foe, people shoot wildly, sometimes allies get killed. War is not like an episode of the A-Team where Mr. T. fires in all directions, and no one gets hurt.

While I've never seen an incident where families during WWII received notifications that their husbands / sons were killed in friendly fire incidents, I'm sure there were several letters sent that portrayed the soldiers death in a heoric light, and did not tell the entire truth. You can call it an outright lie if you want, but I think the intention was for the family to think that their loved one was heroic, and did a noble thing.

And that's probably what happened here.

But hey, there are some out there who just gotta make sure that the heroic contribution of a fine individual is p*ssed all over, just so Bush, or Rumsfeld, or the Pentagon, or someone can be desparaged in order to score some political points here or there. In my opinion, this is all about politics, and nothing more.

From everything I've read, I've yet to find a reason for a cover-up, other than a football star dies in a friendly-fire incident, which (to my knowledge) has already been admitted by the military.

It could also very well be that much of this "cover-up" has gone on to protect the people who actually killed Pat Tillman by accident. Given the media scrutiny, and the complete lack of understanding by a lot of people these days as to what goes on in a war zone, if the names of these soldiers got out, they'd be crucified by the press. Or they'd be somehow connected to Chaney and Haliburton, or the Swift Boat people.

In my opinion, people need to leave this alone, and let the poor guy rest in peace with some semblence of honor.

mingkou
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:53:00 PM
The coverup is because so much of the rightwing media emphasized how great Pat Dillman was. Here is a guy that was willing to ditch a lucrative NFL career to go fight for his country only to be killed by the very side he was fighting for. But Hannity, Rush, etc. all talked so much about Pat Dillman when they talked about patriotism and respect for the armed forces. If they had not repeatedly brought Mr. Dillman up, then they probably wouldn't have bothered with the coverup. It just makes his sacrifice look like a complete sham when the killing was done by U.S. soldiers and then lied about to protect the image of the armed forces.

So, if I were in the Dillman family I would be pissed. You use him as a posterboy for patriotism and the military and then ultimately dishonor him by not telling the truth as to how he died? Kevin Dillman put it best when he said "The deception surrounding this case was an insult to the family: but more importantly, its primary purpose was to deceive a whole nation. We say these things with disappointment and sadness for our country. Once again, we have been used as props in a Pentagon public relations exercise."

HockeyDad
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:56:00 PM
Let's not start maligning the fine people at Halliburton again.
jpotts
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:56:00 PM
^ Thanks for illustrating my point.

Politics. Pure and simple.

jpotts
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 1:56:00 PM
Sorry HockeyDad...last comment not directed your way.
mingkou
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 2:17:00 PM
Actually, Jessica Lynch said some very sensible here:

"The bottom line is the American people are capable of determining their own ideals of heroes and they don't need to be told elaborate lies," Lynch said.

I think those who are defending the pentagon on this one seem to think the opposite. Not very patriotic if you ask me.