teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 6:00:00 AM
Anyone watch his show last night? It was fascinating. According to him the "left wing" press handed Bush his war without quesitons.

I do not know much about Moyers (don't know why, guess I never paid attention to him). Are the attack dogs going to paint him as

leftie commie

rightie nazi

independent

stupid or

benign

I'm really just curious what folk's take on him and the show are if you watched it. I do not have an opinion on him.

The show was very interesting and made the press look very bad.

Just curious.

HockeyDad
Thursday, April 26, 2007 6:06:00 AM
I was watching CSI: Miami and CSI: Las Vegas instead.
DrafterX
Thursday, April 26, 2007 6:09:00 AM
I love Emily Procter...
HockeyDad
Thursday, April 26, 2007 6:24:00 AM
^Absolutely!
jpotts
Thursday, April 26, 2007 7:27:00 AM
I've watched a lot og Moyers stuff before. Usually, I can't get past about 15 minutes before turning it off.

The guy was, is, and probably always will be a big-time left-winger. In fact, he passes Walter Cronkite in this distinction. Most of his stuff is agenda driven from the outset, and is riddled with errors of omission. It's one of the reasons why when the name Bill Moyers has anything to do with it, I don't bother watching.

He did some "reports" on Biblical stuff that were just plain stupid and awful. So, his ineptitude and bias isn't limited to political subjects.

Face it: he's Michael Moore with a journalistic pedigree.

People seem to often forget that the "left-wing" press "handed" the Iraq war to the administration (which, in itself, is a crock) because:

1) The previous administration (which a majority of the press was sympathetic to) advocated military action against Iraq.

2) The previous administration touted there very same facts concerning Saddam's WMD program.

3) Democrats in office in 2002 - 2003 were all for going into Iraq. The had access to same intelligence as the White House, and some of them (namely Carl Levin) urged Clintion to take military action against Saddam Hussien.

4) Nothing gets better ratings than war and scandal.

HockeyDad
Thursday, April 26, 2007 7:57:00 AM
Excuse me....

"American Idol" gets better ratings than war and scandal.

HockeyDad
Thursday, April 26, 2007 7:59:00 AM
"CSI: Miami" took the #8 slot last week.

News sucks.

Charlie
Thursday, April 26, 2007 8:32:00 AM
Bill Moyers is usually pretty much leaning to the left; however, once in a while he will shock you with something on the more conservative nature....very rarely!

Charlie

SteveS
Thursday, April 26, 2007 8:42:00 AM
Bill Moyers first came on the scene as an aide to LBJ in the 1960 presidential primaries and served as an aide in the Kennedy administration, then became a “special assistant” to LBJ after Johnson ascended to the presidency … in that capacity, he was the guy behind LBJs “Great Society” initiatives and he later served as press secretary and interim chief of staff to Johnson …

He is clearly very much in the liberal camp and anything he says must be viewed with that in mind ...

SteveS
Thursday, April 26, 2007 8:49:00 AM
============================================

Author: jpotts Date: 04/26/2007 11:27 AM

People seem to often forget that the "left-wing"

press "handed" the Iraq war to the administration

(which, in itself, is a crock) because:

1) The previous administration (which a majority

of the press was sympathetic to) advocated military

action against Iraq.

2) The previous administration touted there very

same facts concerning Saddam's WMD program.

3) Democrats in office in 2002 - 2003 were all for

going into Iraq. The had access to same intelligence

as the White House, and some of them (namely Carl

Levin) urged Clintion to take military action

against Saddam Hussien.

============================================

I think most people would be highly surprised to learn that on more than one occasion, the US came within hours of a unilateral attack on Iraq during the Clinton years ...

mingkou
Thursday, April 26, 2007 9:06:00 AM
I haven't seen this special, but Bill Moyers is pretty much correct on this. Much of the left-wing press (really, most of the media that is) didn't really look hard enough at the evidence that the administration presented for its case. From my memory of the papers I read, the NYT and TNR basically had to come out and say "sorry" to its readers for trusting the government's word that it was "a slam dunk." WaPo was pretty much down the middle and not a cheerleader, but they still believed the evidence. I'm still waiting for the National Review to apologize to the 4 conservatives that were right about Iraq but that they had basically called traitors on the cover. This whole sentiment really occured once the minority of people who were against the war turned into the majority and had to ask where the critical voices were in the press to help counteract the administration's spin.
jpotts
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:04:00 AM
"'American Idol' gets better ratings than war and scandal."

I think that speaks volumes...one way or the other...

teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:09:00 AM
Folks should watch it, even if you go into it not wanting to beleive.

I'm not sure what to make of it, and recognize I am biased (as is everyone else) but it does make some good points.

Its worthwhile

jpotts
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:29:00 AM
Actually, a better show to watch was with Thomas Friedman (sp:?) about "Green Energy". I assumed it was a bunch of the same liberal "use one sheet of toilet paper" baloney, but with what few moments I did see, it was quite to the contrary.

This is the same guy that wrote the book "The World is Flat", which I thought was nearly a complete load a horsesh*t. I'm hoping that they replay it so I can see the whole thing.

teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:41:00 AM
BOB SIMON: From overseas we had a clearer view. I mean we knew things or suspected things that-- perhaps the Washington press corps could not suspect. For example, the absurdity of putting up a connection between Saddam Hussein and Al Qaeda.

BILL MOYERS: Absurdity. The Washington press corps cannot question an absurdity?

BOB SIMON: Well maybe the Washington press corps based inside the belt-- wasn't as aware as those of us who are based in the Middle East and who spend a lot of time in Iraq. I mean when the Washington press corps travels, it travels with the president or with the secretary of state. And--

BILL MOYERS: In a bubble.

BOB SIMON: Yeah in a bubble. Where as we who've spent weeks just walking the streets of Baghdad and in other situations in Baghdad-- just were scratching our heads. In ways that perhaps that the Washington press corps could not.

BILL MOYERS: Simon was under no illusions about Saddam Hussein. During the first Gulf War he and his camera crew were arrested by Iraqi forces, and brutalized for 40 days before being released.

BOB SIMON: We're going home, which is the, the place you go to after a war when, if you've been as lucky as we've been.

BILL MOYERS: It didn't make sense to Simon that the dictator would trust islamic terrorists.

BOB SIMON: Saddam as most tyrants, was a total control freak. He wanted total control of his regime. Total control of the country. And to introduce a wild card like Al Qaeda in any sense was just something he would not do. So I just didn't believe it for an instant.

teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:43:00 AM
BILL MOYERS: Strobel learned that within two weeks after 9/11, senior intelligence officers were growing concerned that the bush administration was stretching 'little bits and pieces of informationÂ….' to Connect Saddam Hussein to Al qaeda — with no hard evidence.

WARREN STROBEL: There was a lot of skepticism among our editors because what we were writing was so at odds with what most of the rest of the Washington press corps was reporting and some of our papers frankly, just didn't run the stories. They had access to the NEW YORK TIMES wire and the WASHINGTON POST wire and they chose those stories instead.

BILL MOYERS: Within the month Strobel found out the Pentagon had already dispatched James Woolsey to Europe looking for any shred of evidence to incriminate hussein....

WARREN STROBEL: He did this even knowing that the CIA had already analyzed this carefully and found no such links. So, the more I thought about that, the more it just didn't seem to make sense.

teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:46:00 AM
JAMES BAMFORD: So, Al-Haideri was in Bangkok. Judy Miller flew there to interview him.

JAMES BAMFORD: The NEW YORK TIMES ran a front page-- story-- basically confirming everything the administration had been saying about Iraq -

BILL MOYERS: Al-Haideri said he was a Kurd from northern Iraq. He told Miller the Iraqis had hidden chemical and biological weaponsÂ….Some.... miller reported...... Right under Saddam's "presidential sites."

BILL MOYERS: The story spread far and wide.

MICHAEL MASSING: THE NEW YORK TIMES is just-- remains immensely influential. People in the TV world read it every morning, and it's amazing how often you'll see a story go from the front page of the day's paper in the morning to the evening news cast at night. People in government-- of course read it, think tanks, and so on.

JONATHAN LANDAY: There were some red flags that the NEW YORK TIMES story threw out immediately, which caught our eye-- immediately. The first was the idea that a Kurd-- the enemy of Saddam had been allowed into his most top secret military facilities. I don't think so. That was, for me, the biggest red flag. And there were others, like the idea that Saddam Hussein would put a biological weapons facility under his residence. I mean, would you put a biological weapons lab under your living room? I don't think so.

WARREN STROBEL: The first rule of being an intelligence agent, or a journalist, and they're really not that different, is you're skeptical of defectors, because they have a reason to exaggerate. They want to increase their value to you. They probably want something from you. Doesn't mean they're lying, but you should be -- journalists are supposed to be skeptical, right? And I'm-afraid the NEW YORK TIMES reporter in that case and a lot of other reporters were just not skeptical of what these defectors were saying. Nor was the administrationÂ…

teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:48:00 AM
BILL MOYERS: Leslie Stahl and CBS Retracted their story a year after the invasion when nearly all the evidence presented by defectors proved to be false.

VANITY FAIR's Rose later said high government officials had confirmed his stories. But these were the very officials who had bet on Chalabi as their favorite man o'war. To the Knight Ridder team it all smelled of a con game.

JOHN WALCOTT: What he did was reasonably clever but fairly obvious, which is he gave the same stuff to some reporters that, for one reason or another, he felt would simply report it. And then he gave the same stuff to people in the Vice President's office and in the Secretary of Defense's office. And so, if the reporter called the Department of Defense or the Vice President's office to check, they would've said, "Oh, I think that's-- you can go with that. We have that, too." So, you create the appearance, or Chalabi created the appearance, that there were two sources, and that the information had been independently confirmed, when, in fact, there was only one source. And it hadn't been confirmed by anybody.

JONATHAN LANDAY: And let's not forget how close these people were to this administration, which raises the question, was there coordination? I can't tell you that there was, but it sure looked like it.

teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:51:00 AM
BILL MOYERS: Landay found plenty of evidence to contradict the official propaganda, and the facts quickly changed his mind.

JONATHAN LANDAY: I -- simply spent basically a month familiarizing myself, with what Saddam's weapons of mass destruction programs had been and what had happened to them. And, there was tons of material available on that from the UN weapons inspectors. I mean, they got into virtually everything, and their reports were online.

JONATHAN LANDAY: If you go down here the Iraq Nuclear Verification Office, they put up regular-here you go-key findings, what they found out about Iraq's nuclear weapons programs. It's all here in the open for anybody who wants to read it.

BILL MOYERS: International inspectors had gone into Iraq after the first Gulf War to search for and to destroy Saddam Hussein's weapons systemsÂ….Late in 1998, the inspections came to an abrupt halt after the iraqi government refused to cooperateÂ…but that hardly meant no one was watching.

JONATHAN LANDAY: During the period of time between when the inspectors left Iraq, which was in 1998-- the end of 1998 and then, the United States had covered the place with spy satellites and-- U2 over flights, and-- you know, the-- other intelligence services had their eyeballs on this place.

****** CHENEY: (Speech to the VFW 8/26/02) There is a great danger thatÂ…

BILL MOYERS: That's why Landay was surprised by what Vice President Cheney told a group of veterans in late august 2002.

****** CHENEY: (Speech to the VFW 8/26/02) Many of us are convinced that Saddam Hussein will acquire nuclear weapons fairly soon.

JONATHAN LANDAY: Â…And I looked at that and I said, "What is he talking about?" Because, to develop a nuclear weapon you need specific infrastructure and in particular the way the Iraqi's were trying to produce a nuclear weapon was through enrichment of uranium.

Now, you need tens of thousands of machines called "centrifuges" to produce highly enriched uranium for a nuclear weapon. You've gotta house those in a fairly big place, and you've gotta provide a huge amount of power to this facility. Could he really have done it with all of these eyes on his country?

****** CHENEY: (Speech to the VFW 8/26/02) But we now know that Saddam has resumed his efforts to acquire nuclear weapons.

JONATHAN LANDAY: So, when Cheney said that, I got on the phone to people, and one person said to me-- somebody who watched proliferation as their job-said, "The Vice President is lying."

teedubbya
Thursday, April 26, 2007 10:57:00 AM
ERIC BOEHLERT: So in October of 2002, 100,000 people in Washington, the-- one of the largest, you know, peace demonstrations in-- in-- in years in the United States. And the press just-- you know, the WASHINGTON POST put a photo on its Metro page.

BILL MOYERS: The photographs ran with an article but the paper's ombudsman later criticized the post for not giving the story more prominence.

BILL MOYERS: Meanwhile, in the six months leading up to the invasion THE WASHINGTON POST Would editorialze in favor of the war at least 27 times.

BILL MOYERS: What got even less ink than the protestors, was the release of something called the national intelligence estimate. Before voting to give the President war powers, Congress asked the administration to detail all the top secret evidence it was using to justify an invasion.

The press got a declassified version. Most of the media gave it a cursory reading, but jonathan landay examined the text closelyÂ…

JONATHAN LANDAY: I got my copy, and I opened it upÂ…

JONATHAN LANDAY: This is the white paper thatÂ…

JONATHAN LANDAY: And I came to the part that talked about the aluminum tubes. Now, it said that the majority of analysts believed that those tubes were for the nuclear weapons program. It turns out, though, that that majority of intelligence analysts were-- had no background in nuclear weapons.

BILL MOYERS: Knight Ridder was on top of the most important story of the runup to the invasion....The manipulation of intelligence to make the case for war.

JONATHAN LANDAY: So, here was yet another building block in this chain of building blocks that we had collected over these months about what they were saying to the public, and what the intelligence was actually telling them. And, there were differences. Some of them were-- were nuanced. Some of them were quite large. But, it became quite apparent that they were grabbing just about anything they could to make the case for going to war in Iraq.

BILL MOYERS: Over a dozen sources told Knight Ridder that the pentagon was pressuring analysts to "cook the intelligence books" -- deep throats were talkingÂ…. But few in the press were listening.