forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 3:36:00 AM
Just a little scenario to see if anyone agrees with me on this or not...

Wife and I will have been married for 8 years in 3 weeks. She has a brother who is 39 and will be getting married this fall. When we got married, he was an usher and part of the arrangement was that all of the tux's were paid for and we contributed half of the cost of the bridesmaid dresses, which maybe amounted to a $50-75 cost for the girls to buy and keep obviously.

Fast forward to today, we are both considerably much better off financially, although he's now pulling in around $150k and the fiance to be is probably making $60k+ at least. They've only been together 6 months and she's asked my wife to be in the wedding. She originally said something about not being picky and wanting to allow the girls to wear whatever style dress she wants as long as it was a certain color. Now, by B-I-L has decided that he wants a specific dress for everyone to buy, which would probably be $150.

While I make a pretty decent income myself, we are living on solely my income while my wife stays home with our 3 kids(4,2, and 3 weeks old). Am I crazy to think someone with more than twice our household income should help pay for the dress if she's going to be in it in this case? I'm literally of the opinion that I'll stay home if they expect us to foot the whole bill.

What would you do in this situation?

DrMaddVibe
Thursday, May 3, 2007 3:44:00 AM
Remind him what you did.

If not, skip it if you can't afford it. You sure as hell don't want to have any grudge at a wedding.

Trust me.

wheelrite
Thursday, May 3, 2007 3:51:00 AM
BOO HOO,

My daughter is getting married next month.I'll compare receipts with ya.My wife and she have gone NUTTS...

lol,

wheel...

forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 3:53:00 AM
I don't have to worry about that as my 2 daughters are 4 & 2. I wonder if I can open up a 529 account for them specifically for their wedding.
forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 3:54:00 AM
^^I'm just of the opinion almost that if he doesn't want to contribute, my wife should tell them she can't be in it.

Overall, it's not necessarily about the money, but the principle behind it.

wheelrite
Thursday, May 3, 2007 4:01:00 AM
^^^

They invited the PRINCIPLE ???

engletl
Thursday, May 3, 2007 4:20:00 AM
Is he gay??? The Bride is supposed to decide what SHE wants HER Bridesmaids and the rest of the attendants to wear.

Todd

forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 4:30:00 AM
He's just completely anal. As far as I'm concerened, if he wants to be anal about it, he can foot the bill for it as well.

hombre
Thursday, May 3, 2007 4:33:00 AM
Go ahead and get the dress but then "accidently" knock over the cake before they get a chance to cut it. Just to make you feel good!
diverbelow72
Thursday, May 3, 2007 4:35:00 AM
That's a tough one, but try looking at both sides. I see your point and agree with you. On the other hand, people tend to remember their personal fiance issues more than others. Maybe they don't recall the whole financial arrangements for your wedding and are so caught up in theirs that is a mere oversight. I would talk to them. Or there is always the possiblity that they are just cheap. My wife was in a wedding a couple of years back and was eight months pregnant and the marrying couple paid for all the dresses.

Good luck,

Diver

forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 4:58:00 AM
Agreed diver. And if nothing else, a combined income of 200k+ who isn't going to be throwing a very extravagent wedding should be a little thoughtful when asking someone to shoulder the cost of the dress. It's not like I didn't just pick up $2,500 of doctor/hospital bills left over from my deductible/co-pays/etc that will put quite a strain on us financially in the short term.
JonR
Thursday, May 3, 2007 5:11:00 AM
Yo Forgop:

Okay, Okay, here's what you do, pay the $150 for the dress and for a wedding gift give them a matching pair of plastic spatulas.

JonR

forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 5:26:00 AM
Is there anything significant behind the spatulas gift other than cost? Just curious if there was another "hidden message" in the gift itself. 😉
rbmbb
Thursday, May 3, 2007 5:44:00 AM
The best way to handle this situation is to have the same conversation you had with your groomsmen 8 years ago, but now with you B-I-L.

Figure out what you want to accomplish and remind him of your past arrangement.

If he balks....oh well, pay the $150 bucks and move on with your life.

I can't imagine that this small dollar amount would destroy your future relationship with you B-I-L.

R

Charlie
Thursday, May 3, 2007 5:51:00 AM
The best way to handle this situation is to have the same conversation you had with your groomsmen 8 years ago, but now with you B-I-L.

And if he balks about this, he is most likely a cheap smack, face it and move on!

Charlie

forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 6:15:00 AM
The odd thing to me is that she's been around my wife maybe 10 times total now and is already asking her to stand up in her wedding.
Kingfisher
Thursday, May 3, 2007 6:18:00 AM
My wife and I were just recently married..second one for each of us. We decided to pay for all dresses and tuxes ourselves. I personally think that the bride and groom should do so, particularly in the case of a second marriage, or a marriage where the bride and groom are over 30 and gainfully employed.

Just my $.02

Thunder.Gerbil
Thursday, May 3, 2007 6:49:00 AM
RE #7:

DING! DING! DING! DING! DING! DING!

WE HAVE A WINNER!

teedubbya
Thursday, May 3, 2007 6:57:00 AM
I have a differing opinion here.

Its his special day. Join it if you like, but don't if you don't.

Eveyone has an opinion and unfortunatly during times like this (when he and his future wife are the central focus and make the decisions) its stressful and hard enough to have a good time on such an important day without everyone having a way you should be doing it better.

I learned really quick that every one knew how I should do things and often did not agree with each other. Then sacked up and said love it or leave it. Things went much better then.

I'm just saying be a part of the wedding party or not. Totally your choice, but don't dicker over a buck fity. Its not worth being right, even if you are.

forgop
  • forgop
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, May 3, 2007 7:03:00 AM
Let me put it this way-

I won't be putting up the buck fifty for her to buy the dress, so if she sneaks around to get the money, then I'll be on my wife's rear about it.