Well, judging by the response to the question, either a lot of cigar smokers don't go to movies or didn't like it enough to talk about it. Here's my take hopefully without giving too much away to those who haven't seen it yet. I'd score it a B+, I liked it better than 2 but not as good as 1. Villians were complex and interesting, there were interesting character twists and most of the acting was decent.
Some of the characters got a little overly melodramatic at times but Jonah Jameson was his usual hilarious self, always was my favorite character of the cartoons. Special effects were extremely good, although perhaps relied on too much at the expense of the plot but this is a common gripe of mine. Seeing it in the Imax was awesome for the most part, although for some of the wildly acrobatic flight scenes, a smaller screen might actually have been better. The Sandman scenes alone made it worth seeing in the Imax. All in all a pleasant experience and a decent movie but not quite deserving of the hype.