MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 24, 2007 9:26:00 AM
Anybody have one of these?

The Bose Sound Dock is a bit pricey at $270 a pop... so I did a little on-line research and found the Klipsch iGroove Docking Station for $150.

Charges the iPod while it plays through some pretty good speakers. Plus, it has a remote control!

Many of the reviews said it was 'better than Bose' or 'sound quality equal to Bose'. Personally, I think Klipsch makes some pretty damn good speakers, though I do have Bose 601's in the house and I love them. Just wasn't willing to shell out an extra $120 when the quality is very likely to be just as good, possibly better, with the Klipsch.

MrsSledn
Thursday, May 24, 2007 9:32:00 AM
I don't have one, but I would like to get one. I have seen many around, but just don't know what's best.

So I will be sure to keep an extra eye out for one and on this thread.

I have one for my truck that plays and charges my Nano. And I like it. It was like $100 bucks at Best Buy.

SteveR@CigarBid
Thursday, May 24, 2007 9:34:00 AM
Don't let Bose fool you...you can do much better for the money. Looking at the big picture, Bose speakers are far from the best.

Unfortunately, I have nothing to really add to this thread. The only docking station I have for my Ipod is in my car. My Ipod doesn't really leave the car.

Buckwheat
Thursday, May 24, 2007 9:34:00 AM
Go listen to it. If it sounds good buy it. IMO most of these "all in one" solutions sound pretty lame.
MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 24, 2007 9:48:00 AM
Too late Julian. I already ordered it. Having heard Klipsch speakers, they rock. I'm sure I'll be pleased. If not, I'll send it back and get a refund.

Steve - many audiophiles do not like Bose speakers. While I think they are a bit pricey (I got mine on base, at the Navy Exchange, so they were discounted) I enjoy the sound quality. Are there better speakers out there? I'm sure there are. Am I happy with the 601's? Yes, I am. That's all that really matters.

I use my iPod a lot in the car and I also use it in the gym, in the house, in the back yard, etc... Having most of my music library with me at all times kicks ass. Julian and a HOST of other asshats from this very board (too numerous for me to list) got me this iPod, and a bunch of useful accessories to go with it, before I went to Iraq last year. It's something I probably never would have bought on my own and I freakin' LOVE it!

dtownmb
Thursday, May 24, 2007 10:18:00 AM
I have the Bose, and its the best quality docking station I have heard(although I have not heard the brand you bought) The docking stations are definatly nice, but I always wished that they would make a cord to connect the ipod to the speakers. If your not using shuffle or listening to a album, a cord would make it easier to cycle between songs.
teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 10:22:00 AM
No true audoholic will touch Bose merchandise. Bang for buck it is a no go.

Their name is worth more than their products.

andytv
Thursday, May 24, 2007 10:25:00 AM
My docking station is a cord that plugs from my iPod to my stereo.
MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 24, 2007 10:43:00 AM
TW - I guess there must be something wrong with my ears. I think the Bose speakers I have in my house sound outstanding. So what do the Audiophiles out there like better?? Klipsch? Polk Audio? Paradigm?

Newsflash. Their just as expensive (or close to it).

Andy - I have actually been using the Harmon Kardon speakers that came with my son's desktop a few years ago (we're both using laptops now). I just plug them into the jack and they sound pretty good. I'm looking for a better sound though. I could plug it into my home stereo, but that ain't real portable, ya know?

nine999
Thursday, May 24, 2007 10:56:00 AM
bose are excelent speakers, if you have the $$$. klipsh are just as good (and were on sale, so i got those)....

but like sean said... " Am I happy with the 601's? Yes, I am. That's all that really matters. "

nine

teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:06:00 AM
some of those are up there MACS... I prefer Energy, B&M, velodyne, RBH, McIntosh, Axiom, Aperion etc. As for price, thats my point. Dollar for Dollar Bose isn't usually in the ball park. Similarly priced speakers are usually much better.

that said I have a pair of 301s from 1982 that will not die. I use them as my middle speakers, energy as my front, center, and sub, and a couple Polks in the rear (pun intended).

Bose are middle of the road at best. They are surviveing on their name and their dream machines, headphones etc.

You will find as you brouse higher end shops and review sites that Bose will rarely be offered or ranked very high. There are too many good reference speaker out there.

A recent review of seven (I think) "budget tower speakers" put BOSE in last. (Audioholics.com)

Bose 701

The Bose 701 speaker system is much different from the other speakers in this review. They stand 32 1/2" X 10 1/4" X 12 1/2" and have a retail price of $838 for a pair and have little or no discount thanks to Bose's price fixing policy. These speakers are unique in that they:

Have the worst overall build quality

The only speakers in this review that utilize paper drivers for the tweeters and midrange.

Have the highest retail price which is not proportional to their performance.

The Bose 701 has dual 8" woofers, (1) 6.5" side firing midrange and (2) 2" paper tweeters. The 2" paper tweeters are too large for the task of high frequencies. The treble coming out of the 701's is very unrefined, raspy, and undetailed . The midrange sounded muddy, bloated, and 2 dimensional. It was extremely difficult to get these speakers to image properly as the sound just seemed to blare out in all directions with no uniformity or tonal consistency.

The bass extension was impressive for this speaker system and was the only minor strong point I found about this system. However, switching back and forth between the Bose 701's and the Pinnacle Reference was like night and day. Picture how your voice sounds when you try to speak 5 feet underwater. Now imagine how much clearer your voice sounds once you have lifted your head above sea level. The 701's represent your head 5' under water while the Reference puts you on a nice beach chair far above sea level, sipping Pina Coladas with a slightly cool breeze coming from the NE. In other words the Pinnacle Reference, and even all of the other speaker systems reviewed here crushed the Bose 701's with respect to overall fidelity, build quality, and value. After my listening session with these speakers, it is my opinion that Bose should change their slogan to "Better Sales Thru Marketing..."

This is common. BOSE is pedestrian....but like anything else if you are happy with it who cares.

teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:09:00 AM
These are the speakers (only 5)

And for the money I'd spend a little more and get away from bose entirely.

Speakers Tested

Pinnacle Classic Gold Tower

Pinnacle Classic Gold Reference

Polk RT600

Infinity RS5

Bose 701

Buckwheat
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:20:00 AM
Bottom line is if you think it sounds good (for the money) then it is good. Period

You quickly start to get into huge diminished returns when you get into the "audiophile" stuff.

teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:21:00 AM
Just foud this..... top ten things to avoid when buying new speakers.....#7=Bose

7) Speaker companies that sell little "Cubed" systems and expensive clock radios endorsed by musicians on infomercials that claim "Better Sound Through Research".While size constraints can play a big role in one's purchasing decisions, the buyer should at least know there are better sounding alternatives at lower cost, better build quality, and in similar footprints. In addition, the alternatives are non-proprietary and offer a greater amount of features and future upgrade options. The notion that a successful marketing campaign makes for the "world's greatest" speaker is ridiculous - it simply means that the company spends more on marketing than any other aspect of their products - including parts and build quality. Now with that said, are we trying to change the world or defeat some "evil" empire from taking over home audio? Nope. Everyone is free to make their own decisions and everyone will have their own opinions and experiences with respect to what makes a good audio system, but know that alternatives exist - and a little research may go a long way to getting you better performance, and better compatibility at far less cost.

teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:22:00 AM
Except when you pay the same price for something better.

OK I've been jacking and will now jack off

nine999
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:24:00 AM

man... but who wouldn't want a set of 901's in theyr living room.....

nine

teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:26:00 AM
I always wanted 901s. Back in highschool..... Much better speakers exist in that price range. MUCH BETTER.
teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:27:00 AM
Many many MUCH BETTER at the same price of less.

Cooler looking ones too..... you can get great speakers custom to your room for that.

nine999
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:28:00 AM

teedub....don't ruin it for me man...

like my wife says, i'm a still stuck in the '80's....

nine

teedubbya
Thursday, May 24, 2007 11:29:00 AM
I must hafe to hit the mens room... I said B@M when I meant B&W

I had a set of those but liked my Energys better. Most would disagree with me but they sounded better in my room.

Try a pair of these...

B & W Nautilus 802's

I'd say they are over priced as well and you can do better for less $$. But they are funky.