Gene363
  • Gene363
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, May 28, 2007 3:33:00 AM
If you believe in hate crimes, why isn’t this a hate crime?

A white couple was carjacked, he was killed and his body burned, the woman was held for several days before she too was murdered and raped. All the suspects are all black.

There are more gory details in Google News here: http://tinyurl.com/ysma8t

Like any crime all sorts of rumors are spreading about what did or did not happen. The following is typical:

Murder victims lost in the furor

Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom's slayings have become the subject of racial tension, falsehoods

By JAMIE SATTERFIELD, [email protected] May 27, 2007

In the blogosphere, Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom are an indictment of mainstream media.

On the Internet, they are a Wikipedia entry. Among white separatists, they are a tool. Within a racially divided America, they are a cause.

That they are murder victims in a horrific Knoxville crime has gotten lost in all that noise.

"There are people out there that just want to make something even worse than what it already is," Christian's father, Gary Christian, said in a recent interview.

It has been nearly five months since Newsom, 23, and girlfriend, Channon Christian, 21, were slain. Four suspects were charged in the January slayings while a fifth faces federal charges of helping one of the suspects hide out.

The victims were white. The suspects are black.

Authorities said the case began as a carjacking but wound up a kidnapping, rape and murder. They have said little else, however, tightlipped on every aspect of the case, from where it occurred to how Christian died.

It didn't take long for details -- horrific ones -- to eke out. The problem is, many of them are wrong.

False information, bad information

The first major dose of misinformation in the killings came from a deputy U.S. marshal in Kentucky, where three of the five suspects were arrested.

He insisted Christian was held captive and repeatedly gang-raped for four days before her body was found inside a garbage can in one of the suspect's Chipman Street rental house.

Mainstream media reported the marshal's statements for at least two days. The stories and broadcasts were posted on the Internet and sent out over The Associated Press' news service.

As it turned out, Christian, though repeatedly raped, was dead within 24 hours of her abduction.

Some media corrected the earlier accounts in follow-up stories. But the claim kept surfacing -- and it remains out there today on the Internet and even among traditional outside media.

That was just the beginning of misstatements about the crimes, although the source or sources behind later falsehoods is largely unknown. Those misstatements included claims that Newsom and Christian were sexually mutilated.

They weren't, authorities say.

There also have been persistent claims that Christian was dismembered. As late as last week, a local television station on its Web site reported that Christian's body had been dismembered and found in "five trash bags." The fact is, Christian's intact body was wrapped in five trash bags.

But real details were slow in coming and largely remain cloaked in secrecy. Authorities insist they're trying to protect a case. Pundits and media experts contend they instead stoked the fires of conspiracy theorists.

Here's what is known from court records and relatives:

On the night of Jan. 6, Christian and Newsom were leaving a Washington Pike apartment complex when gunmen confronted them. The pair, inside Christian's Toyota 4Runner, were taken to a rental house on Chipman Street near Interstate 40 and Cherry Street.

Both repeatedly were raped, according to authorities. Within a few hours, Newsom was shot, his body wrapped in bedding, set afire and dumped alongside nearby railroad tracks.

Christian remained alive for several more hours. She was raped and strangled, and her body was discarded in a trashcan, according to investigators.

All five suspects, including the four accused in the slayings, have given statements about the killings, most implicating each other. Authorities have amassed a mound of evidence, from fingerprints to DNA.

They have unearthed nothing to suggest Christian and Newsom were targeted because of their race, according to law enforcers.

"There's nothing whatsoever that indicates any hate crime," said John Gill, special counsel to Knox County District Attorney General Randy Nichols. "There are things that really, coincidentally, would prove just the opposite."

As is typical in this case, he would not elaborate.

Race and volatility

The lack of evidence signaling a hate crime has not stopped white supremacists from using the case to advance their cause. Alex Linder, operator of the Vanguard News Network and an admitted supremacist who organized Saturday's rally in Knoxville to protest "black-on-white crime," said in an e-mail to the News Sentinel that the case is being "covered up" by mainstream media, "which intends white genocide."

Knoxville police arrested Linder at the rally's start, charging him with disorderly conduct, resisting arrest, assault on a police officer and vandalism.

Using the Internet and e-mail, the white-supremacist groups began a campaign of complaints to and about the mainstream media's coverage.

Suggestions of a racial bias by the media haven't been limited to fringe groups.

Conservative syndicated columnist Michelle Malkin is among those weighing in on the issue.

"This case -- an attractive white couple murdered by five black thugs -- doesn't fit any political agenda," she said. "It's not a useful crime. Reverse the races and just imagine how the national media would cover the story of a young black couple murdered by five white assailants."

The case has tapped into themes of racial tension and media liberalism, University of Tennessee law professor Glenn Reynolds noted.

Reynolds operates www.instapundit.com, one of the country's most popular blogs.

"You've got three things going on here," he said. "First, not that much information has come out, which always fuels speculation. Second, you've got plenty of public places for people to speculate. Third, you do have some people who are trying to milk it politically, and you have suspicion of the media."

Once the blogging furor began, often fueled by false information, Fox News took note, airing a couple of stories. CNN followed with coverage.

Neither focused on the slayings themselves but instead on plans for rallies and claims of media bias.

CNN correspondent Rusty Dornin came to the News Sentinel last week as part of her story coverage.

"We, like you, started getting all these e-mails," Dornin said.

Bob Steele, a media ethics expert at the Poynter Institute in St. Petersburg, Fla., isn't surprised.

"The issue of race is so tension-filled and so volatile in our society that when there is a crime involving different races (and) when individuals spray some gasoline around that case, new flames emerge, and that prompts the national media to cover it," he said.

Reynolds said those who complain that the national media would have reported on the case sooner had the victims been black and the assailants white could be right.

"I think it would have gotten a lot of national play faster if it had been a black couple kidnapped and killed by five white people," he said.

That's because the national media has a "template" for covering white-on-black crime but not the reverse, he said.

But Steele said he doesn't think it's that simple, citing a mix of factors that fuel media coverage.

"The uniqueness of the crime, the brutality of the crime, what the police and prosecutors say or don't say can significantly drive what's being published," he said.

"What you hear from family members or families of the accused. If there are individuals speaking out freely and significantly, there are interviews and sound bites to be had. Inevitably, the amount of coverage is dictated by what else is going on in the news."

At the center of the storm

Knox County Public Defender Mark Stephens finds himself a bit mystified at the notion that the slayings, though horrific, should have rated as national news.

"I refuse to believe these guys were laying in wait. It seems to me unlikely that the race of the victims had anything to do with this crime," he said. "It seems to me when we read about a black defendant shooting a black person in the projects, nobody gets upset about it.

"Why is this (case) worthy of national news coverage?" Stephens asked. "Unfortunately, this probably happens in major metropolitan areas every month."

The Rev. Ezra Maize, president of the local chapter of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, said the case has been hijacked by agenda-driven outsiders with no regard for the survivors of the slain couple.

"The NAACP wants equality and justice for everybody," he said. "If these families reached out (for help, support or advocacy), we would be just as eager, just as demanding to see that equality reigns. It's about equality and justice for everybody. We stand behind the Christian and Newsom families 100 percent."

Gill agreed.

"The DA's office is outraged they have tried to abuse the victims by using the death of loved ones for racist purposes," he said. "The things that are being seized on by these hate groups are things that never even happened."

Knoxville Police Chief Sterling P. Owen IV and Knox County Sheriff Jimmy "J.J." Jones have said they're worried that the storm surrounding race and media will cause a judge to move trials for the suspects out of Knox County.

"I haven't seen any evidence to indicate this is a hate crime, and I interviewed two of these suspects," Jones said. "I don't believe if they'd been Mexican, Chinese or Japanese it would have mattered. I believe these people were evil. I believe it was a plan.

"These two kids just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time," the sheriff said. "The only worry I have is to be able to secure a fair and capable jury in Knox County."

For veteran civil-rights leader and local minister Dr. Harold Middlebrook, the race-baiting dialogue is sad proof that although strides in race relations have been made, America remains a country divided.

"People have not yet learned to live together as fellow human beings," Middlebrook said. "I really hope in my lifetime to see the day when people will really look at trying to build a community where people can love and share in brotherhood."

Knoxville Mayor Bill Haslam said he believes Middlebrook might just get his wish -- locally at least.

"I think we have a lot of people here working to make relations better," Haslam said. "We're trying to solve problems while these outside groups are ... just trying to cause problems."

HockeyDad
Monday, May 28, 2007 4:07:00 AM
The previous post is sponsored by the Klu Klux Klan.

The Klu Klux Klan, for a brighter, whiter day!

[Email this to everyone you know in the world, quickly!]

The walrus
Monday, May 28, 2007 4:25:00 AM
The previous post was obviosly written without reading the first post.
HockeyDad
Monday, May 28, 2007 4:28:00 AM
^Do some research on the first "Copy n paste" post. It's been around for a while, been posted on this board a few times, and is actively spread by a few partisan groups.
burgess_b
Monday, May 28, 2007 6:35:00 AM
soooo, hockeydad, what i read you saying is that this article that shows it was NOT a racially motivated attack is being circulated by the KKK (who gets off on racial tensions)?

i gotta say that though i do not doubt that you looked into this and have more information than i do, i would wonder why they would put energy into this as opposed to say putting the focus on blacks attacking whites. i do not know...just does not seem like the best way to recruit...

Gene363
  • Gene363
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, May 28, 2007 7:15:00 AM
If this story was previously posted here, I could not find it, links?

The Google search results indicate it is not a false story, though it has been blown out of proportion.

For me, the idea of hate crimes is total BS, but I wanted to hear what other thought about this. It seems like hate crime proponents are not quite as color blind as their expectation for society.

donutboy2000
Monday, May 28, 2007 10:11:00 AM
The race card was played quickly. An election must be just around the corner.
donutboy2000
HockeyDad
Monday, May 28, 2007 12:21:00 PM
This one is totally unrelated to elections. Even if it was, we're still talking about American voters so you get what you get...

Google a few lines from the email or even the first line from the original post, "A white couple was carjacked, he was killed and his body burned, the woman was held for several days before she too was murdered and raped. All the suspects are all black."

You'll come up with some really interesting web sites but not necessarily ones you'll want to be hitting from a work computer.

This murder made it to the CigarBid forum but many other since have not.

victor808
Monday, May 28, 2007 12:35:00 PM
Do people not really understand the definition of a hate crime?

A hate crime is (in my understanding) a crime committed specifically because of the victim's race. (ie, "we'll beat/kill that homo, because he's gay"; or "we'll string up that black guy because he's black and dating a white woman").

There doesn't seem to be any evidence in this crime to indicate that the victims were selected specifically to demonstrate any dominance over their race. Some of the criminals may have some latent race issues, and that aided in the selection of their victims, but without any specific evidence (ie, sticking a "fist of black power" up their ass, or crucifying them upside down with "kill whitey" carved in their bodies) there is no way any hate crime charges would stick.

Why don't people ever use their brain and simply think about these things?

Gene363
  • Gene363
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, May 28, 2007 3:05:00 PM
Victor808, unfortunately the authors of hate crime legislation didn’t use their brains to think things out before passing some feel good legislation.

If hate is a crime:

Is victim A any less dead because criminal X killed them during a robbery or in a fight over something versus killing them because of who/what they were?

Conversely, if criminal X kills victim A, is it any less of a crime because Criminal X liked person A?

You can not make a crime out of what some one thinks, only the actions they take. In effect, hate crime laws reduce the legal consequences for killing/attacking a member of a non protected group. That exception makes hate crime laws discriminatory based on race and sexual orientation, etc.

donutboy2000
Monday, May 28, 2007 3:09:00 PM
The Supreme Court does not appear to agree with you.
HockeyDad
Monday, May 28, 2007 4:01:00 PM
Hate crime legislation doesn't really serve a purpose except to tack on a few years to a criminal sentencing. In this particular crime, the four defendants each face 46 counts including murder, rape, and kidnapping. Tacking on "hate crime" is meaningless because you aren't going to convict for it without convicting for other far more serious crimes first.

It is important to note that under hate crime laws, there is no such thing as a non-protected group. Every group is protected equally with the exact same burden of proof to convict. Whites are not getting less protection under the law although this particular case is being heavily used to try to make that claim. Of course this case is also being used to make a lot more wild claims regarding the black on white crime menace and even the Jews controlling the media and keeping the story from being properly covered.

ScottHar
Monday, May 28, 2007 4:17:00 PM
I find the entire notion of "hate crimes" ridiculous. It's not wrong to kill a person because they're gay/black/Jewish/whatever.

It's wrong to kill a person. Period.

When you start trying to punish criminals for "bad thoughts" -- instead of bad behavior -- you're getting into some scary Orwellian territory.

(And in answer to the original subject line, "Hate Crime?" My answer: "Yep. I sure do.")

ScottHar

burgess_b
Monday, May 28, 2007 5:21:00 PM
i hate everyone...but i commit no crimes.
pabloescabar
Monday, May 28, 2007 5:23:00 PM
don't ask don't tell
wtjvj
Monday, May 28, 2007 5:33:00 PM
If it was`nt a hate crime why did`nt they just take them for a ride and toss them out on the street and keep on going?

It appears they raped and murdered both of them, if you don`t see the hate is this crime your missing the point of the law.

WT.

Oddboggle
Monday, May 28, 2007 5:56:00 PM
It's wrong to kill a person, of course, but when it comes to bringing the perps to justice, then it can be added as proof of a motive. But there's gotta be something there -- in the perps' background, or witness reports -- that suggests "hate crime."

Last night, two black guys were attacked by a group of white guys. In the ruckus, one of the black guys was stabbed. They'll call this a "hate crime" (and they are) because the white guys started the fight, used the N-word, and pursued the black guys who left the fast food joint in a failed attempt to avoid the fight. What else could this be, but a hate crime?

I don't think it's impossible to prove that race was a motivating factor in some crimes, esp. when they're witnesses; I do think that the victim makes the call, too. I wonder who would be charged with a hate crime had the two black guys whupped the five white guys.

Oddboggle

victor808
Tuesday, May 29, 2007 7:44:00 AM
Gene,

I'm not debating the validity of hate crime legislation, to be honest I don't know whether it's a good idea in the end.

But, within the confines of the current legislation there is a very specific definition of "hate crime" and that definition demands proof that the attack is specifically motivated by the victims status as a member of a race/gender/sexual orientation.

A random white guy killing a random black guy is not a hate crime, neither is the reverse. I don't believe that hate crime legislation reduces sentencing anywhere else (it is a specific "add-on" to existing sentencing).

Now, interestingly the sentence "you cannot make a crime out of what some one thinks" is a good point against legislating hate crimes. As an aside, there was a case a number of years ago where a convicted pedophile on probation was arrested for keeping a journal in which he wrote the fictionalized molestation of a neighbor boy. Would you defend him, he was arrested based solely on his thoughts.

penzt8
Tuesday, May 29, 2007 7:51:00 AM
Double homicide, rape should get the death penalty. Do they give you an extra injection to kill you faster if it's a hate crime?