Calavera: Godfather and me swear by the 8-5-8 Sungrown, which are really spicy and full-bodied, more so than most Fuentes...but if you don't like Fuente's other stuff, you might not like these either.
Cigars I hate that others love...I haven't had many good experiences with the Torano Exodus 1959, which others seem to enjoy. Each time I've had one its been bitter and had a bad burn...but then again, seems each time I try one, its outdoors on a windy day, so maybe that's it.
Cigars I love that others hate...actually, I have a soft spot for Black & Mild machine-mades. Really, I don't know if you can consider it a cigar, since it's made with pipe tobacco, but for some reason I like these little things for their kinda sweet, nutty taste every once in a while. Hav-A-Tampa Jewels are also another low-grade machine-made I like.
As far as handmades, I've really liked most of Perdomo's stuff, from the Perdomo2 to the La Tradicion (which is awesome, I think), which seems to get bashed, and I'm a Fuente fanatic.