America's #1 Online Cigar Auction
first, best, biggest!

Last post 11 years ago by frankj1. 54 replies replies.
2 Pages<12
Gestapo
DrafterX Offline
#51 Posted:
Joined: 10-18-2005
Posts: 98,559
Good to hear.... let's hope that part of history remains just that... although there are similarities iin many so called armies or organizations out there....
tailgater Offline
#52 Posted:
Joined: 06-01-2000
Posts: 26,185
frankj1 wrote:
you aren't wrong. perhaps it is a bit more sensitive to some than others. I, for one, am not hurt by this, just like to point out how easy it is to lessen original meaning of words from said English Language and therefore lessen their historical meaning/importance...creating a population of shoulder shruggers just 70 years later.

I'm not offended, not by this at least, but I get why some are. Again, I think your assessment is correct though.
Lets start calling bad political moments Potato Famines for a while, just to get a break from , you know. j/k


Potato Famine?
Was that an insult to my Irish heritage?
Angel

And you forgot the "e" on potato...
signed,
D.Q.


Frank, what we need is context and perspective and intent.
If someone says "so-and-so is just as bad as Hitler" then that would be an ignorant statement.

If they say "he's like a mini Hitler, for crying out loud" that would be a reasonable insult.

I hear you when you say "Just" 70 years. But if 70 years makes the wounds too fresh, then how many is OK?
100?
500?

Dwelling on the past is how we get into pseudo-serious discussions about reparations for slavery.
Hell, if we're going to hate on the Germans, then why the love affair with Japan? They are, after all, the last nation to attack us on our own soil.

Politicians need to know better when to use such terms as Gestapo because too many people DO get offended. It's too bad, but it's reality.


DrafterX Offline
#53 Posted:
Joined: 10-18-2005
Posts: 98,559
Hitler had a lotta balls.... Mellow
frankj1 Offline
#54 Posted:
Joined: 02-08-2007
Posts: 44,223
tailgater wrote:
Potato Famine?
Was that an insult to my Irish heritage?
Angel

And you forgot the "e" on potato...
signed,
D.Q.


Frank, what we need is context and perspective and intent.
If someone says "so-and-so is just as bad as Hitler" then that would be an ignorant statement.

If they say "he's like a mini Hitler, for crying out loud" that would be a reasonable insult.

I hear you when you say "Just" 70 years. But if 70 years makes the wounds too fresh, then how many is OK?
100?
500?

Dwelling on the past is how we get into pseudo-serious discussions about reparations for slavery.
Hell, if we're going to hate on the Germans, then why the love affair with Japan? They are, after all, the last nation to attack us on our own soil.

Politicians need to know better when to use such terms as Gestapo because too many people DO get offended. It's too bad, but it's reality.



I do not disagree with anything you are saying, Mr. Vice-President Dan, especially the context part. Again, I was not insulted by the ignorance of the politician nor by this thread. I also did not know you are Irish, just picked it as a random alternative ethnic related fiasco to use instead of , well you know what, trying to be funny. Fail.

One nit-pick item. It isn't that the wounds are too fresh to poke at that keeps it from being fair game for trivializing with humor, it's that it is an event of such monumentally hideous proportion that it should never be allowed to forget...if only to avoid repetition on ANY group of people. My opinion, you are all free to disagree, I will not cry, I even hear some yawning.

I just fear certain type usage of language, over time, changes the accuracy of recalled history. Like Blacks de-stygmatizing the N-word, using it so as to neutralize its power of hatred, I fear the same can happen accidentally with the horrors perpetrated by the Nazis through funny use of key words, or too much Hogans Heroes

Besides, I thought the Soup Nazi was a great episode.

Enough seriousness, OK?
Users browsing this topic
Guest
2 Pages<12