Dak,The only thing I can offer is this. How many cigars do U intend have in your collection? Whatever that amount is,Double the capacity of anything U intend 2 buy. If U buy just singles and 5packs on CB. Buy an El Grande humidor,that will hold about 300 gars. If U intend 2 buy boxes also,Still buy the humidor but include a Coleman type cooler to store cigars in their boxes. Be sure 2 include a humidifier and hygrometer 2 keep track of the humidity. As far as the antique humidors go,I believe they should be used as conversation piece and not 2 store cigars. X