haven't had the 10th Anniversary...
I liked the Punch Rare Corojo during the beginning of my cigar journey, nearly 10 years ago. Then I discovered the Camacho Corojo, which I thought was much better, so I didn't go back to the Punch....now I find that I don't like the latest Camacho Corojos as well as the previous ones...
seems cigars vary from production year to production year...very difficult to replicate a blend, year after year because the leaves, even if grown from the same batch of seeds, will exhibit some variances depending on a variety of factors...
I was a big fan of the DC Maximus 5-6 years ago...the ones I bought 2-3 years ago didn't meet that mark...same for the Crowned Head Las Calaveras...2014 was an outstanding year...others weren't as good...some outstanding cigars don't age welll, others do....
part of the mystical road that you travel chasing cigars...