America's #1 Online Cigar Auction
first, best, biggest!

Last post 10 hours ago by danmdevries. 323 replies replies.
7 Pages«<234567>
2024 Springtime Blind Reviews With a Twist
Tiver Offline
#251 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
jeebling wrote:
Nice job, T. Review really makes you slow down and concentrate on the moment, don’t you think?


Yes. I have spent time like this before, but this one had more nic kick than I was ready for, even though i had a sandwich just a little before. Had to get up and walk around. I was at a park and the weather was gorgeous. Out of butane and a wonky burn, but I just didn't find any break out moments. I don't think I missed out on anything. Jake will let me know once the reveal time comes Frying pan
ZRX1200 Offline
#252 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2007
Posts: 60,628
Blind cigar #2


It’s a well rolled 5x50 robusto with a light Corojo Ecuadorian Habano or a dark Connecticut wrapper….very slight veins, a double cap, very nice bunching and a noticeable barnyard nose. Pre-light draw tastes like cinnamon sticks smell (no pepper) or like fig Newton filling. Tight-ish draw.

1/3 first bit is BIG pepper, then it gone as fast as it got there. Then oak. Then the flavor diminishes noticeably, and oak comes on even stronger.

2/3 oak is turning into charcoal so I slowed the pace, then purged just hoping to improve it. Pepper came back again, then left and settled back into it.

3/3 rates more like a Connie now and flavors still haven’t changed but it did get hot. Put it down and total time was a hair over 85 mins.

Not a bad smoke but not one I’d reach for again, though if I was handed this at a gathering I wouldn’t say no. Origin? This isn’t as confusing as the first one but it doesn’t taste like a Puro I think it was a Habano wrapper and maybe a Connecticut binder? No idea the brand it’s not something I regularly smoke. Which, now that it’s a narrow band of go to’s these blinds are much harder for me than they used to.

Very confident it’s the yard cigar at this juncture. #1 is still in the lead but it’s off putting how good the bunch was on #2 too….🤷‍♂️
Telecaster52 Offline
#253 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 725
Z you wearing 2 too?
Sunoverbeach Offline
#254 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2017
Posts: 14,675
Sorry, been sidetracked again. Cheno, you were dead on with my intended tier rankings. Nicely done
deadeyedick Online
#255 Posted:
Joined: 03-13-2003
Posts: 17,124
Been waiting for the cigars from tele to get used to their new neighbors. Prolly get my reviews done this weekend.
jeebling Offline
#256 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
ZRX1200 wrote:
Blind cigar #2


It’s a well rolled 5x50 robusto with a light Corojo Ecuadorian Habano or a dark Connecticut wrapper….very slight veins, a double cap, very nice bunching and a noticeable barnyard nose. Pre-light draw tastes like cinnamon sticks smell (no pepper) or like fig Newton filling. Tight-ish draw.

1/3 first bit is BIG pepper, then it gone as fast as it got there. Then oak. Then the flavor diminishes noticeably, and oak comes on even stronger.

2/3 oak is turning into charcoal so I slowed the pace, then purged just hoping to improve it. Pepper came back again, then left and settled back into it.

3/3 rates more like a Connie now and flavors still haven’t changed but it did get hot. Put it down and total time was a hair over 85 mins.

Not a bad smoke but not one I’d reach for again, though if I was handed this at a gathering I wouldn’t say no. Origin? This isn’t as confusing as the first one but it doesn’t taste like a Puro I think it was a Habano wrapper and maybe a Connecticut binder? No idea the brand it’s not something I regularly smoke. Which, now that it’s a narrow band of go to’s these blinds are much harder for me than they used to.

Very confident it’s the yard cigar at this juncture. #1 is still in the lead but it’s off putting how good the bunch was on #2 too….🤷‍♂️


Great review. I should edit my reviews down a bit. I do word salad.
jeebling Offline
#257 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Sunoverbeach wrote:
Sorry, been sidetracked again. Cheno, you were dead on with my intended tier rankings. Nicely done


Spot on, Cheno! Happy 40th!

Applause Applause Applause
Huzza3045 Offline
#258 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 570
Smoke number 2 from Tiver:
Paired with Void Sake Company Opalescent Junmai Nigori (so I have an excuse for day-drinking)

Visual description: a thicc conny, double capped, even coloring, firm and consistent construction throughout, a couple of big ol’ veins on the wrapper. I started with blind smoke #2 because it was the largest, and I have some time to burn.

Unlit description: molasses, cedar, cashews and a little bit of spice. I feel like I will enjoy this.

First third: pleasant and light. The molasses from the pre light is not present, but the cedar and cashews are coming on strong. There’s a hint of citrus on the backend. I attempt a retrohale, I proceed to cough for the next minute or so. This is clearly what I deserve for pretending I know what I’m doing. The smoke production on this thing is immense. I feel like I’m making enough smoke that the Green Party is about to knock on my door and tax me. The burn line is even and consistent through the 1st third. Ash made it about an inch before gravity did the job for me. I attempt another retrohale. Clearly, I don’t learn from mistakes. As I approach the second third, I’m starting to notice a note of milk chocolate in my future.

Second third: The cedar is gone. Cashew is the predominant flavor. There’s a hint of milk chocolate on the aftertaste. I lose attention as I try to pin the next flavor, the ash falls into my lap again. Burn line remains straight. I’m now realizing that I probably smoke cigars too quick, I’m at 30 minutes and I’m halfway through.

Third third: The nut changed… kind of almond-y and vanilla-y? I approve of this change. I’ve been impressed that the burn line has stayed consistent throughout the stick and didn’t need to be relit, which is pretty rare when I’m smoking.

Total smoke time 1.25 hours

Final thoughts:
Overall a pleasant smoke, which had some mild changes throughout. Id buy a fiver of it. I’d reckon it’s a Mid range stick. However as I write in my psychiatric evals: I reserve the right to change my professional opinion when new information comes to light. At that point, I would be happy to revise the contents of this evaluation.
jeebling Offline
#259 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Huzza, LMAO at the internal dialogue there. Excellent observations in your review. Sounds like I might try a fiver of that myself.
Tiver Offline
#260 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
Seems like you enjoyed it pretty well Huzza. Nice review.
LeeBot Offline
#261 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,028
Huzza3045 wrote:
Nice review, which stick number was this?

It was #1. I'm smoking them in order.
deadeyedick Online
#262 Posted:
Joined: 03-13-2003
Posts: 17,124
OK here goes. Since I have been smoking more Cubans for many years my tastes have changed from stronger Nic bombs like Pepin and Tatuaje to enjoy the rich medium profiles much more often.

Cigar #1: A dark very mottled, splotchy, wrapper with almost black flecks, 5 1/2” X 50 with a crooked cap
1st impressions is this is a yard gar from it’s overall looks
Cold draw is of some molasses and earth but very light but only on the clipped head and nothing coming from the foot
Wrapper took a long time to get going but the filler started immediately with copious qty of smoke pouring out
The 1st retro showed light pepper but muted flavors
Almost immediately I get a taste of dirt maybe some earth so I’m thinking this is a habano but not any rich flavors are coming through
The draw was loose and burned a little hot with a crooked grey ash that was flaky
Wanted to tunnel and I had to correct the wrapper often which was not burning as fast as the filler - no cherry when tapped at 1 1/2” mark
No distinct flavors are coming through except dirt very mutted
Burn gets wonky at 2” I’m thinking this wrapper sucks
I quit this one with about 2” left. Iffn’ this was a car it would be a Yugo!
As Sara Peller would yell…”Where’s the beef?!”

Conclusion: I hope this is the yard gar!

Cigar #2: A dark box pressed 6X50 ‘ish with some glue on the wrapper, slightly toothy and a dull sheen. I’m thinking aged?
The wrapper had a small split about 1” up and needed to nurse it a little but never became a problem
Light barnyard on the cold draw with maybe some cedar notes
Slightly bitter on the 1st draw but seemed to settle down quickly with large volume of creamy smoke
The wrapper has a salty, sweet and roasted meat note that was very pleasant
Sharp notes of red pepper on the retro kinda bit the sinuses, only did that once
Grey ash that was firm and I tapped it at 2” more medium+ than strong profile at this point and I’m enjoying this one
Light spicyness continued with some wood and more roasted meaty goodness and creamy but stronger progression at the same time
Crooked burn towards the end needed touch up. A long aftertaste stays on the palate for hours after smoking this one.

Conclusion: Definitely a good cigar but I’m not sure iffn’ this is the 2nd tier or the premium until I try cigar #3

Cigar #3: A dark dusty looking 6X50 toro’ish parejo with a rounded triple seemed cap and some mottled tooth
Distinct sweet cocoa and dark bread note on the cold draw
1st impression is lots of velvety smoke so maybe aged or just medium strength?
Slight cinnamon on the retro but not too strong
Very straight burn line for the entire 90 minutes burn time and more medium than full
Smoke coats the palate and tongue. Pleasant aftertaste.
Notes of lemon, and some metallic taste along with slight astringency comes and goes
I’m thinking corojo wrapper or filler and I’m also think this looks like a Warped Nicotina due to the rounded head which I have smoked before

Conclusion: I liked #2 and #3 but that roasted meaty taste on #2 and some slightly weird metallic notes on #3 means I give this one second tier.

And the envelope please:

#1 La Palina Classic Rosado
#2 Opus X Forbidden Lost City (from 2016)
#3 Warped Futuro (from 2019)

Much thanks to telecaster for the chance to smoke these blind. Always a great way to challenge your taste buds without the marketing getting in the way.
Tiver Offline
#263 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
Great write up DED.

it's reassuring to know that AF OX has a lot to offer, while at the same time lesser priced cigars can be time well spent.

From your conclusion it would appear that the come and go metallic flavor in the Warped wasn't nearly enough of a knock to toss it in the compost bin.
Huzza3045 Offline
#264 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 570
Blind review #2:
Smoke #1 from Tiver

Once again, paired with Void Sake Company Opalescent Junmai Nigori

Visual description: a romusto conny, single capped, some discoloration, firm and consistent construction throughout, a few veins. Also has an indent on the wrapper that says “risto”. I’m going to try to ignore that for the sake of a blind review.

Unlit description: not much of a taste unlit. There’s a hint of sweetness and wood, but I can’t identify anything else.

First third: the first third is kind of grassy/barnyard-y. I’m also thinking there’s a bit of walnut in there somewhere. All the flavors are very light and a bit hard to distinguish at this point.

Second third: the walnut flavor is coming on stronger and is now the primary flavor.

Third third: walnut flavor is still the predominant one, but has gotten strong than before.

Final thoughts: It’s a good stick, but doesn’t really give off much flavors to think about and doesn’t change much. Feels like a good smoke to have with a cup of coffee or while reading a book. I’m guessing it’s a good ol’ yard gar (or that’s what I’d guess if I didn’t know it was a montecristo)
Tiver Offline
#265 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
The "risto" evidence was insufficient and ambiguous.

It won't hold up in court or at least a conviction would be overturned on appeal. "Your Honor, we submit the warrant should not have been issued as the evidence lacked specificity "


Montecristo

Kristoff

ristorante - a list of possible house branded cigars from any number of eateries bearing the indented letters might have sent the review on an entirely different tack Eh?















Flapper jester
Huzza3045 Offline
#266 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 570
Your honor, Huzza3045 would like to motion to stike the "risto" assumption for the record. He was not aware of other brands with those letters.
jeebling Offline
#267 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Palama has a ruling to make.

DED, very nice work my brother. You have a refined palate my friend.
Tiver Offline
#268 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
Jake's Blind number - Fred the Bull

Beeyootiful construction. Very firm, but not too heavy in the hand 5x52ish robusto

Mottled medium to slightly darker brown with several long, thin, smooth veins and a tightly seamed wrapper. Might have a slight red tone in there.

Smells of barnyard. Stronger at the foot

The straight cut cap revealed a sweeter barnyard smell. Cold draw offered a hint of dried sweet fruit flavor like a chocolate covered cherry and the wrapper had a very light spice on the lips and tongue

Toasted and light up immediately produced ample (copious) smoke with an initial dose of white pepper. A strong medium right out of the gate with a razor sharp burn. Very light gray to white tight ash. Perfect draw.

White pepper falls quickly to an oakey/woody smoke with full flavor. Retro is a little warm. Reminiscent of a quick slug of strong whisky in both flavor and heat. A quick drink of water to keep my tasters in check

Sweet wrapper taste on lips and the smokey sweet flavor lingers in the mouth well after a sip of water

Into the second third and the cigar is still as firm as when I started and the draw remains perfect. The cherry is staying right where it ought and the burn remains sharp. This cigar burns like a champ and suggests to me to smoke it slowly. It's not going to go out.

A note of some tree nuts enters and the pepper comes and goes, but there is always a background of full tobacco with that lingering sweetness. Regular sips of water keeps it in check but doesn't wash it away

Strength builds as the 2nd enters the 3rd. The pepper turns earthy and perhaps there is some seared meatiness to the flavor. I notice the nicotine has been polite, but rather obvious as I toss the nub

Final thoughts. This was a very good cigar. The flavor would easily stand up to any strong beverage that one might choose to accompany it.

Jake wasn't messing around. Both Big Grey and Fred were at least medium plus strength (for this noob anyway), but Fred was easily the superior cigar with regards to construction and balance of strength and flavor. Lord only knows what that donky deek big fella, Earl the Horse has in store.


danmdevries Offline
#269 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,451
Tiver wrote:

From your conclusion it would appear that the come and go metallic flavor in the Warped wasn't nearly enough of a knock to toss it in the compost bin.


That is a note that can be overwhelming or complimentary. I hate it in several cigars, most notably Ligma privata 9. Tastes like the sensation of licking a 9v battery. But I love it in several lines from Warped and Aganorsa and others as a complimentary addition.
jeebling Offline
#270 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Tiver wrote:
Jake's Blind number - Fred the Bull

Beeyootiful construction. Very firm, but not too heavy in the hand 5x52ish robusto

Mottled medium to slightly darker brown with several long, thin, smooth veins and a tightly seamed wrapper. Might have a slight red tone in there.

Smells of barnyard. Stronger at the foot

The straight cut cap revealed a sweeter barnyard smell. Cold draw offered a hint of dried sweet fruit flavor like a chocolate covered cherry and the wrapper had a very light spice on the lips and tongue

Toasted and light up immediately produced ample (copious) smoke with an initial dose of white pepper. A strong medium right out of the gate with a razor sharp burn. Very light gray to white tight ash. Perfect draw.

White pepper falls quickly to an oakey/woody smoke with full flavor. Retro is a little warm. Reminiscent of a quick slug of strong whisky in both flavor and heat. A quick drink of water to keep my tasters in check

Sweet wrapper taste on lips and the smokey sweet flavor lingers in the mouth well after a sip of water

Into the second third and the cigar is still as firm as when I started and the draw remains perfect. The cherry is staying right where it ought and the burn remains sharp. This cigar burns like a champ and suggests to me to smoke it slowly. It's not going to go out.

A note of some tree nuts enters and the pepper comes and goes, but there is always a background of full tobacco with that lingering sweetness. Regular sips of water keeps it in check but doesn't wash it away

Strength builds as the 2nd enters the 3rd. The pepper turns earthy and perhaps there is some seared meatiness to the flavor. I notice the nicotine has been polite, but rather obvious as I toss the nub

Final thoughts. This was a very good cigar. The flavor would easily stand up to any strong beverage that one might choose to accompany it.

Jake wasn't messing around. Both Big Grey and Fred were at least medium plus strength (for this noob anyway), but Fred was easily the superior cigar with regards to construction and balance of strength and flavor. Lord only knows what that donky deek big fella, Earl the Horse has in store.





Well done, Tiver. It’s always nice to have a very good cigar 😎
jeebling Offline
#271 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298

BLIND REVIEW CIGAR FROM LEEBOT APR ‘24
6 x 55/56ish Belicoso beautiful dark mahogany, invisible seam, small veins well distributed, cap looks very well done to this noob. Nose is fruity, foot smells have rum ball type fragrance. Chocolate covered dried fruit smells…excellent. Touch of cocoa, green apple, Levi Garrett plug cold draw. DBL guillotine flat. Kickoff burned BBQ sauce from the grill and green sour apple, savory. Grilling spices lined with a pleasant sweetness. Man, that retro is really very interesting in the best way. Green apple yielding to a strong cedar taste. Moderately astringent w/dark cocoa. Woody, earthy on the edges. Easy retro no burn, no pepper in nose. Touch of black pepper w/the other flavors. For me this falls into full bodied and I’m guessing it’s a Penn BL wrapper over ligeros. Because it’s strong I’ll just make a guess that it’s Nicaraguan and I’m still in first third. The flavor profile is so broad and has a zing, could be Sumatra inside there too. Well behaved burn line, copious amounts of smoke on draw, not a lot of smoke at rest. 35 minutes in I’m at 1” mark (!) still holding ash. 40 minutes ash drop approx 1 1/4”. Transition, milder flavors now. Toasty note. Milder. About 1 hour transition to final third. Twangy strong molasses, mild black pepper, very slight sour cherry. Cool smoker. Occasional smoked meat on retro. Installing patented Tele-nubber. Retro now burns sinuses. Very strong molasses and getting unpleasant bitter at the nub. Smoke time 1hr 35min.
The flavors on kickoff were complex, then flattened, noticeable transition in 2nd third. It was however a bit monotonous by the time i got to the nub. This has AJ Fernandez’ fingerprints on it.

Cigar 1 - yard
Cigar 2 - primo
Cigar 3 - mid
LeeBot Offline
#272 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,028
Cigar #2 from Huzza.
From the files of Jack Diamond.

It was a dark night in the city when she swayed out of my office, leaving an envelope full of cash, the smell of sex in the room, and a cigar on the table. I sat down to smoke it, thinking about the case.

This cigar looks nice. It’s well made, cold draw is good. I light it and enjoy some slight sweetness.
Sweet like that dame. She came in a couple of weeks ago boo hoo-ing about how somebody whacked her old man. He was some suit bigshot. She thought it was a hit. Wanted me to find the killer. Man, this broad was a looker– fancy looking blonde with the most amazing gray eyes I’ve ever seen. She told me she would give me a wad of cash for solving the case. She let me know she would give me something else too.

I’m getting a little chocolate from the cigar and some really nice cream. Maybe there’s criollo in the blend, some chocolate flavors lingering in the shadows ...

My first stop on the case was Muggsy’s place. Muggsy’s is the type of bar nice people don’t go in. At least once a week more people go into the place than come out. He has a special trashman on the take, see, who doesn’t open any of the bags and doesn’t ask questions. If there was a hit on the guy, Muggsy might know. He’s called “Muggsy” because of his face. Mug like a catcher’s mit that got left out in the rain after the game was called. Ugly just for the sake of being ugly.

The cream is still around. I'm really digging this cigar.

Muggsy told me that he didn't know anything. He knows I don't care about his business, so I couldn't figure out why he would lie to me. (I've known Muggsy since we was kids. He used to stutter. To this day, he has to slow down when he's lying or he'll start stuttering. Muggsy was talking real slow that night.)

I went to the suit’s office asking around, trying to find out if he had enemies. They all hated him, glad he was gone. Said he was a real heel.

Second third of this cigar is continuing like the first. The sweetness and cream take the stage, stealing the spotlight. Bread notes creeping in, like footsteps in a dark alley. A little chocolate in the background like a distant echo of trouble. Hard not to puff too fast. Like smoking a roasted marshmallow. Burn and draw? Perfect.

I was stuck on the case for a while, so I decided to go back to Muggsy's and find out why he was lying to me, squeeze somebody around there hard-like. That type of thing can go south though, fella can find himself getting taken out with the trash doin' something like that, so I was packing heat this time, carrying the .38.

After hanging out for a while, I saw my mark. Larry Fingers. Smilin' scumbag would dime on his own mother to save his hide. I waited for him to leave and leaned on him hard in the alleyway. Once I saw the sweat on his forehead, I knew I had him. I showed him the picture of the suit, and he tells me that the guy came in a couple weeks ago, had some hot dame on his arm. I asked if she had gray eyes, and he said “yes.” I asked Fingers what night of the week they came in, and he said it was a Tuesday. He remembered cause it was a slow night, and they stood out.

Then the sweat started beading on my forehead, and I started regretting the lifetime of bad decisions that led me to taking the case.

The third act of this cigar is solid as a rock. Construction, burn, draw, smoke production, all top-notch. I feel like I should know what this is, like chasing a lead in a labyrinth of deception. A little more leather, adding to the mystery. Didn't want it to end, and neither did the cigar.

I am wrapping up this final bit of the cigar thinking about the report I gave the dame. I said that somebody from his job probably had him whacked, but I couldn’t figure out who.

This was a real primo cigar. Dame had good taste. I’ll give her that.






Epilogue: So why’d I do it? Why’d I throw the case? Cause Fingers said they came in on a Tuesday.

Trash man comes on Wednesdays.

Crazy broad had her husband wacked and paid me to find the killer knowing I’d figure out she done it. She knew she could take my report to the coppers. They would ask around at his office a little, then give up. Lazy bums aren’t going to try to solve a case I can’t crack. She walks.

Why not turn her in? Cause a broad like that is a whole lot of sexy and even more crazy. If she got let off, pleading insanity or somethin’, I’m looking over my shoulder the rest of my life for the guy she hires to whack me. I’m not doin’ that for some suit I never met.

Nah … you want to know the real reason I done it? Those eyes. And cause broads like that, see, they don’t pay attention to guys like me. Not that kind of attention.


And cause she gave me a good cigar.
Sunoverbeach Offline
#273 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2017
Posts: 14,675
Cigar #3 - I'm counting down this year
from Jgraz

Appearance:
Romustoish in size
Milk chocolate in color. Cap was several shades lighter. Understandable, but struck me as odd
Seams were tight. Slightly veiny with one larger one running the length of the cigar
Had a firm feel throughout the length

The Burn:
Tight draw. Couple of swipes cleared the airway
Even burn for the first inch, then hit a small void just under the wrapper and went a little crooked. Prolly beetle burrows (I keed)
Kept the same line through the rest of the smoke. No more burrows discovered and no touchups required
Ash held firm through about two inches

The Flavah:
Notes of chocolate, coffee and very light pepper to start
Had kind of a smooth creamy feel to it.
Pepper started picking up about an inch or so in
Hints of cinnamon came in to play
Halfway point to the end, pepper seesawed in and out
At low pepper points, had a caramel sweetness to it
Strength seemed to sit in the mild/med range

The WAG:
Enjoyablle smoke and rain held off just lopng enough to finish it. Preliminary tentative guess is maybe the mid tier smoke.
jeebling Offline
#274 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Lee, that was a stellar short story and review. I truly enjoyed it and I hope to hear more outta Diamond. I’m buying that cigar when the great reveal happens.

SOB - romustoish lol I’m adding that to my vocabulary
Tiver Offline
#275 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
Nice write up Lee. If only......I mean aside from the murder and mayhem.


SOB - great description. No hotties were involved?


Jeebs - Man that's a lot of nuance there. Nice choices of descriptors.
JGRAZ Online
#276 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 763
Sunoverbeach wrote:
Cigar #3 - I'm counting down this year
from Jgraz

Appearance:
Romustoish in size
Milk chocolate in color. Cap was several shades lighter. Understandable, but struck me as odd
Seams were tight. Slightly veiny with one larger one running the length of the cigar
Had a firm feel throughout the length

The Burn:
Tight draw. Couple of swipes cleared the airway
Even burn for the first inch, then hit a small void just under the wrapper and went a little crooked. Prolly beetle burrows (I keed)
Kept the same line through the rest of the smoke. No more burrows discovered and no touchups required
Ash held firm through about two inches

The Flavah:
Notes of chocolate, coffee and very light pepper to start
Had kind of a smooth creamy feel to it.
Pepper started picking up about an inch or so in
Hints of cinnamon came in to play
Halfway point to the end, pepper seesawed in and out
At low pepper points, had a caramel sweetness to it
Strength seemed to sit in the mild/med range

The WAG:
Enjoyablle smoke and rain held off just lopng enough to finish it. Preliminary tentative guess is maybe the mid tier smoke.



Great review SOB. I've enjoyed these for quite sometime and have to get another box at some point, sans beetles of course
LeeBot Offline
#277 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,028
jeebling wrote:
BLIND REVIEW CIGAR FROM LEEBOT APR ‘24

Cigar 1 - yard
Cigar 2 - primo
Cigar 3 - mid

Great job jeebs! You switched the yard and the primo, but that's understandable. In retrospect, I should have separated them more.

The Reveal:

#1 - Perdomo Lot 23 (meant to be the mid)
#2 Viaje Private Keep Lemon*
#3 - Diesel Unholy Cocktail. Nice job picking up that it's an AJF blend! (meant to be the yard)



* I am soooo sorry about that Viaje. I picked it out wanting to give you a brand it seemed that you hadn't tried. I pulled one for myself and smoked it after I had mailed yours. Then, I had burn problems and remembered that I had burn problems the last time I smoked one of those. Counting yours, that's 3 cigars in a row, which is just bad.

I did not want to send you a dud. I owe you a primo cigar and will make good. No need to send Knuckles after me.
jeebling Offline
#278 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Hey, not too bad. Next year I hope I can get a little better. You don’t owe me anything, brother. That’s just how it goes with cigars. I’ve never had any of those cigars before so it was truly a fun experience. I would love to know what a good Viaje is like but if that’s 3 bad ones in a row maybe I’ll put that on the no fly list.
Thanks for the smokes, Lee!
danmdevries Offline
#279 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,451
Viaje is like Ezra Zion jeebling. Manufactured exclusivity. They do a lot of short run limited releases. No need for QC if 2/3 bundles you release are good, they still got your money.

Their good stuff is great. Problem is you don't know if the batch you're buying is gonna be good. And if it is good, you can't get another one. So then you hope the next one is as good. But then it's not. Or sometimes it is.
ZRX1200 Offline
#280 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2007
Posts: 60,628
^ ain’t that the truth….

They’ve switched production facilities I believe 3-4 times as well. The PDR rolled ones were the most problematic ones I’ve smoked.
ZRX1200 Offline
#281 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2007
Posts: 60,628
Just got an email about the “Birthday Blend” release “hinting” that it’s a SA wrapper and it’s a mystery blend….another reason Viaje irritates me.
Palama Offline
#282 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,735
ZRX1200 wrote:
Just got an email about the “Birthday Blend” release “hinting” that it’s a SA wrapper and it’s a mystery blend….another reason Viaje irritates me.


Nine or 10 years ago I attended a Viaje smoker with Andre Farkas in attendance. While I did buy a few LE and even a Hawaii exclusive, when Farkas got up to speak, there was something about hm that didn’t make me feel that confident about his cigar blending abilities. I can’t remember what it was but I’ve never found a Viaje that made me go “WHOA! I gotta get me a box of these!”
jeebling Offline
#283 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
danmdevries wrote:
Viaje is like Ezra Zion jeebling. Manufactured exclusivity. They do a lot of short run limited releases. No need for QC if 2/3 bundles you release are good, they still got your money.

Their good stuff is great. Problem is you don't know if the batch you're buying is gonna be good. And if it is good, you can't get another one. So then you hope the next one is as good. But then it's not. Or sometimes it is.


I’ve got several different EZ blends in storage. I’m holding off buying anymore. I hope some of the blends are to my liking. I’ll keep that in mind with Viaje though. Thanks.
danmdevries Offline
#284 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,451
Palama wrote:
Nine or 10 years ago I attended a Viaje smoker with Andre Farkas in attendance. While I did buy a few LE and even a Hawaii exclusive, when Farkas got up to speak, there was something about hm that didn’t make me feel that confident about his cigar blending abilities. I can’t remember what it was but I’ve never found a Viaje that made me go “WHOA! I gotta get me a box of these!”


Satori is the only one that I even remember smoking. I've had several over the years from trades and stuff, but the Satori is the only one that I really can recall as being special. But that was probably back 2014-15ish and I have zero confidence if I bought some today they would wow me. Especially at $12per.
ZRX1200 Offline
#285 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2007
Posts: 60,628
The first Super Shots were unreal, the first Platinos were amazing, the 50/50’s were really good….then it went way hit and miss about the time he started the 250 box/bundle pre order crap.
PapaWhiskey Offline
#286 Posted:
Joined: 01-01-2023
Posts: 769
DeadEyeDick, Here’s my guess.

A was the boxed pressed yard gar.
B was the delicious Maduro torpedo or belicoso just under 5 inches and about 48rg premium cigar.
C was the 5 inch about 52rg habano parejo mid range cigar.

B and C were both good and I’d consider buying boxes of but to me B was the premium cigar.

Thanks brother, the cigars and goodies were all great! Still haven’t found anyone to try the scorpion lollipop yet. Do you actually eat the scorpion inside? I might give it a go if it’s here much longer.
jeebling Offline
#287 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Good luck PW, and now ladies and gentlemen, the big reveal…

(Oh…yeah, eat that scorpion, it, uh, should be ok. Yeah)
danmdevries Offline
#288 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,451
PapaWhiskey wrote:
DeadEyeDick, Here’s my guess.

A was the boxed pressed yard gar.
B was the delicious Maduro torpedo or belicoso just under 5 inches and about 48rg premium cigar.
C was the 5 inch about 52rg habano parejo mid range cigar.

B and C were both good and I’d consider buying boxes of but to me B was the premium cigar.

Thanks brother, the cigars and goodies were all great! Still haven’t found anyone to try the scorpion lollipop yet. Do you actually eat the scorpion inside? I might give it a go if it’s here much longer.


You only posted one review. Shame on you
PapaWhiskey Offline
#289 Posted:
Joined: 01-01-2023
Posts: 769
danmdevries wrote:
You only posted one review. Shame on you


B burned great, nice sharp, slow burn yet easy draw. No touchups. I have a hard time identifying flavor nuances but it was good, delicious actually.

C cracked and required a few touchups, nice draw, the flavor was good, maybe nutty.

I'll have to work on my flavor identification.
jeebling Offline
#290 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Flag on da play! 🚩
Tiver Offline
#291 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
Oh Yeah. You definitely eat the scorpion









Think






Whistle











'cause everyone knows scorpions pair well with bananas

or wait, was it you gotta be bananas to consider eating a scorpion

apparently they are edible so it's up to you Pdubbs
deadeyedick Online
#292 Posted:
Joined: 03-13-2003
Posts: 17,124
PapaWhiskey wrote:
DeadEyeDick, Here’s my guess.

A was the boxed pressed yard gar.
B was the delicious Maduro torpedo or belicoso just under 5 inches and about 48rg premium cigar.
C was the 5 inch about 52rg habano parejo mid range cigar.

B and C were both good and I’d consider buying boxes of but to me B was the premium cigar.

Thanks brother, the cigars and goodies were all great! Still haven’t found anyone to try the scorpion lollipop yet. Do you actually eat the scorpion inside? I might give it a go if it’s here much longer.


A = Beaunaventura BV560 ( I like these for around $5)
B = Warped Black Honey (premium)
C = LFD Colorado Oscuro (mid)

Now chomp down on that scorpion! And we need a review of that bugger.
jeebling Offline
#293 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Excellent, PW. You got 3 for 3
LeeBot Offline
#294 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,028
deadeyedick wrote:
A = Beaunaventura BV560 ( I like these for around $5)
B = Warped Black Honey (premium)
C = LFD Colorado Oscuro (mid)

Now chomp down on that scorpion! And we need a review of that bugger.

Nice job, PW!


EAT IT! EAT IT! EAT IT!
JGRAZ Online
#295 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 763
Good work Papa.
And I agree with others, eat the 🦂
Tiver Offline
#296 Posted:
Joined: 08-22-2019
Posts: 346
Nice job PW. Nailed it
Huzza3045 Offline
#297 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 570
I’ve eaten one before, it’s better than you think.
LeeBot Offline
#298 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,028
First 1/3
It’s a toro with a smooth maduro wrapper, barnyard smell. It has a heavy bite at first. This is definitely a heavy metal start. It kinda has this Slipknot thing going on, maybe some Otep / Mushroomhead on the edges, sort a of nu metal vibe but definitely the harder type. Very in your face.

I’m getting some Earth, but subtly, not an Earth, Wind, and Fire vibe at. There’s still a lot of ligero and bite on the retrohale, so I would say that the heavy metal is still the main driver. Call it DevilDriver with some nuance. There’s a hint of dry hay on the retrohale that reminds me of Patsy Cline and Hank Williams. A little caramel. It’s smoother now, but not smooth jazz / Steve Winwood smooth, just not mosh pit hard anymore. I am digging it. There’s a small amount of cream. Leather on the finish, but only a little – so, more of a Village People kinda leather, not Judas Priest.

2/3
It's good. Excellent construction so far. Burn, smoke production, draw are all excellent. Has a medium/full body. Adele? Estelí? Some smokey barbecue that reminds me of Texas Hippie Coalition. Dry wood and cream on the retrohale. I’m not going to make an Eric Clapton reference. It’s not that much cream. Smokey BBQ is standing out, so I’m thinking more Muddy Waters.

3/3
It settles into dry wood and generic tobacco flavor. Kinda muted out in the final third. Reminds me of elevator music. It’s there, but nothing is standing out, maybe it’s not meant to stand out. It picked up a little at the end, but not much.

I want to say it is an AJF blend.

So, in summary, I enjoyed these cigars, Huzza. All three had excellent construction that rivals any top-notch cigar (or exceeds some of them like that crappy Viaje I sent jeebs).

To summarize all three:

#1 – yardgar / daily smoke. If I had to pick something, I would call it a Diesel.
#2 – premium. I should know what this is. The only thing I can think of is a Southern Draw Firethorn, but I don’t think that’s correct because I think there was criollo in the blend, and I don’t think Firethorns have that. But it’s all I can think of.
#3 – medium. Some AJF blend.
jeebling Offline
#299 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,298
Awesome reviews, Lee. Good luck with the reveal!
Huzza3045 Offline
#300 Posted:
Joined: 11-07-2022
Posts: 570

Smoke number 3:
Once again, paired with Void Sake Company Opalescent Junmai Nigori

Visual description: a torpedo conny, some discoloration, firm and consistent construction throughout, a few veins. Looks like the label took a piece of the wrapper.

Unlit description: mostly cedar and a pretty solid amount of spice.

First third: actually pretty spicy. Never had a spicy conny before. I’d say its red peppery? The other flavors are washed out by the spice. I usually dislike spicy smoked, but I’m not hating this one. I do hope the spicy mellows a little in the future to allow for more other flavors to be noticed.

After about an inch, the spice calmed down. Now the spices are on the backend and some sort of barnyard-y wood is starting to take the forefront.

Second third: while the first third was outside of my preferred taste, the second third is very nice. It’s like the cigar slapped me in the face, and then gave my a cold beer after a long work day. It’s mostly cedar on the front, but with some warm cooking spices on the backend. Honestly, if this stick stayed in this flavor range for the whole stick, I’d be pretty thrilled with it.

Third third: this stick stayed the same, and I’m pretty happy about it. Smooth, flavorful, and a little bit of cooking spices on the back end makes for a great stick.

Final thoughts: compared to all the other sticks I smoked, this paired, by far, the best with my sake. Better than the first stick (stick number 2)? Not sure. Honestly, they both were pretty great. Although I liked them both pretty equally, id say this is the mid tier stick.

So here is my estimations

-stick 1: yard gar
-stick 2: premium
-stick 3: mid tier.

Although it’s important to note, I loved them all. However my deciding factor between stick 2 and 3 was this: which would I have rather been a mid tier stick that I could afford. Definitely stick 2.

I got a little bit left of this smoke, so I’ll open up the envelope when I finish up.
Users browsing this topic
Guest
7 Pages«<234567>