I have one of those cheap $6 ones from WallyWorld. Don't trust it at all. I did the salt test with it and had some pretty strange results. After 8 hours was off by -2, 16 hours off by -2, 24 hours off by -2, 48+ hours it was off by +15.
Until I can get me a quality digital I'm using the junk one and my analog and kinda taking the average of the two. As long as my sticks smoke well I'm not in too much hurry to spend more on a new hydrometer.