ssutton219
Tuesday, April 17, 2007 8:51:00 PM
I have tried to search and I have read as much as I can but I havent came across where you guys list your opinions on "premium" smokes? I know its a taste factor but what are your opinions. I want to be sending the right stuff in these trades I want to get in to!!

Thanks!!

Shawn

heynow5151
Tuesday, April 17, 2007 8:53:00 PM
anything on the list is good. Best bet is to send what you like and chances are they will like the too. But don't listen to me I know nothing about trades.........
ScottHar
Tuesday, April 17, 2007 9:59:00 PM
Patience, Grasshopper. Stick around and you'll see that opinions are all over the map. One person will think Rocky Patel is the Cigar Messiah; another will swear that RP and his sticks are way overrated.

Obviously, the second person in my example is an utter moron and you'll want to ridicule him mercilessly, attack his ancestors, question his manhood, and sneer at his politics. But really you shouldn't do this...

...on the "Cigars & Related" board. That's more "Miscellaneous" fodder.

Hope this helps.

ScottHar

blackdog2000
Wednesday, April 18, 2007 4:52:00 AM
Personally I am still puzzled by the whole "trading for noobies" thing.

I understand that many brothers are generous and go the extra mile, but to be fair, most noobs don't have boxes of interesting stuff to exchange for the bonus bombs.

I remember a whole bunch of trades where the noob had to send a bunch of cigars to service personnel in Iraq. Which is cool I suppose, but it was farily big stakes.

Over the past coule of years, I've read opinions and bought five packs of items that looked interesting. Some were, some were not. Worst case I had 3 or 4 sticks left that were not going to get smoked.

Eventually I've settled on a few standbys that I like.

There are hundreds of sticks that could be listed as "premium" handrolled. No way you're going to cover all of them. Everyone's going to have differing opinions.

Thunder.Gerbil
Wednesday, April 18, 2007 6:09:00 AM
Technically any hand made cigar is a "premium cigar".

We have since colloquialized the term to refer to a perceived level of quality of the cigar. Just as we created the descriptor "super-premium cigar" to refer to a cigar of a aupposedly even higher quality level.

Negotiate your trade in advance, that way no one feels shortchanged.

engletl
Wednesday, April 18, 2007 6:13:00 AM
blackdog...

the whole noob trade thread is more about mentoring than getting some "quality" smokes.

I went through the noob trades and my mentor was drnos...he opened my eyes to a wider range of smokes, some I liked some I didn't.

The most important idea we vets try to convey is generosity and not having the attitude of "what's in it for me"

I for one have made many great new friends thru the noob trades now that I am a "vet"

I hope this sheds a little more understanding as to why we vets do those trades

Todd

JTokash
Thursday, April 19, 2007 8:20:00 PM
As a noob, I can say that the noob trade was an eye-opener for me! Todd ^^^ sent me an amazing package (which has yet to be utilized due to crappy northern weather, though all the cigars are resting in my humidor) and I am sure that my return fire looked like a firecracker next to a 16 inch deck gun. But what I think I gained more than anything else is a friend and a mentor. I will always be in debt for the kindness that I was shown.

Regards,

-JT