I have been smoking some of these in the car commuting in the past few months. The box has aged a year and a half (in perfect conditions, of course--including the mandatory two days plus dry boxing before smoking. :-)).
After that care the burn was even. The volume of smoke was a little lower than average.
As was noted above the Sungrown is the best of the group. It was a smooth smoke that reminded me of some decent low cost Sungrowns available at other sites.
The corojo is very mild for a corojo. If you smoke it very slowly you get a little bit of that corojo taste. If you want the real thing try the Camacho Corojo Churchill. 🙂
The maduro many here believe to be painted. Aging solved that problem for me and it started out like a very good maduro. However when I put it down and ate dinner and came back to the smoke I purged and purged and it still was terrible.
(So, if you smoke these make sure you finish them and don't come back to them if you put them down.)
I had a Cameroon last night. A Hemingway or Perdomo La Tradicion Reserve it is not, but it was an OK mild cameroon. I like the Petersons better for that taste profile and (around here) price range.
So I will not be bidding on another box--but with proper care and feeding they are not _that_ bad.
For the same bucks I would recommend you go with anything in the 5 Vegas line.