Andy,
Seems like an unfair comparison to me. The typical Party Short is much spicier and fuller-bodied than the PLPC. Smoking the Short 1st will always make the PLPC seem less appealing. Two very different cigars completely that deserve to be evaluated on their own merits.
I'll take the rich, smooth, medium, caramel flavors of the PLPC most times over the stronger flavor of the Party.
But thats just another opinion.
BTW the SCdH el Principe is right up there as well for it's spicy, rich kick.
DED