ffbking
Thursday, June 21, 2007 12:25:00 PM
I have been a BOTL for a few months. A couple months back I purchased a box of Victor Sinclair '55' (sampler) and I enjoyed them all. Put the remaining 20 in my humi and pulled one out to have today at lunch.

While smoking the camaroon, the flavor was much less intense than I remembered from the last one. Then, about half way through, the wrapper started coming loose. It still smoked ok, but the entire wrapper ended up falling off. Is this a result of a humi being too humid? Too dry? I have a couple ISOM sticks in there as well and I am afraid they are going to ruin if I don't fix it.....just don't know if it was the humidor or the stick....

ffbking

JTokash
Thursday, June 21, 2007 12:30:00 PM
I'm a noob, so that this for what it's worth.

There are a ton of arguments about too dry or too moist, but from my limited experience, it all seems to depend on what type of wrapper you have.

For example, I have some with Conn. natural wrappers that are way too dry if I have them at the same humidity as say a maduro type of wrapper. What I'm discovering is that if it's crunchy, it's too dry... if it's squishy, it's too wet. So just keep them firm, but not crunchy, somewhere in the middle.

Hope this helps,

-JT

JTokash
Thursday, June 21, 2007 12:31:00 PM
^

should read, "so take this for what it's worth."

-JT

jojoc
Thursday, June 21, 2007 12:42:00 PM
are you using distilled water, 50/50, beads?

wrapper falling apart usually is the result of too low humidity.

until i started using beads I had a heck of a time controling my Rh, even with 50/50.

my advice, if you are using the green foam, replace with beads and get a second container of some sort for additional beads (extra credo, bead tubes, nylons, etc.) let the gars sit for a couple weeks and see how they are.

jpotts
Friday, June 22, 2007 7:03:00 AM
Unravelling wrappers isn't generally indicitive of humidity problems. It's more likely the result of just plain bad construction. The wrapper may also be too thin, and if it is too easily damaged will tear, and then unravel.

However, if the stick is overhumidified, when you light it up, it'll eventually swell which may cause the wrapper to split. A lot of people who have been smoking the Gurkha X-Fuertes have been complaining about this very same problem as of late. The way to tell that your cigars are overhumidified (from my experience) are as follows:

1) Does not easily slide out of the cello, but has to be pushed out from the end.

2) Splitting during smoking (see above).

3) Generally bad burn on sticks known to be solid performers, and/or the need to relight periodically.

4) Bitter taste (unless it's a Maxim de Paris).

5) Swelling near the area where the ash meets the leaf.

If you're keeping them a little too dry, the following will happen:

1) Fast burn when smoking.

2) A generally "flat" taste (not always indicative).

3) A "crunchy" sound when gently squeezing the cigar.

4) Cigar tends to smoke "hot" early on, inducing what some refer to as a "metallic" taste.

5) The wrapper tends to be very fragile, and tears easily.

Mind you, these are general symptoms, and not hard-and-fast rules. Some maduros, because they're quite oily, will burn bad unless they're rested for a while (they tend to absorb mositure rapidly, but will not release it at the same rate). Some cigars just have thin, fragile wrappers, and humidity has nothing to do with it.

I typically have problems with overhumidifaction.

sw48362
Friday, June 22, 2007 8:19:00 AM
Can be the result of over humidified conditions, then the humi becomes too dry, under humidified. The expansion and then contraction lifts wrapper away from binder, thus causing easy wrapper tearing, or splitting of the wrapper from the heat of the cigar.

pacman357
Friday, June 22, 2007 9:56:00 AM
Personally, I think it was them guttdimmed liberals.
La10870
Friday, June 22, 2007 10:05:00 AM
Most cammys tend to be thin and delicate and require a little extra care (but they're worth it IMHO).
La10870
Friday, June 22, 2007 10:05:00 AM
make that cammy wrappers...........