FWIW from CA:
As for which cigars are the best investment for collectors, the panel had many choices, including the Cuban Davidoff Chateau Haut Brion, which at $100 a stick is Bohrer's best seller, and any Cuban Dunhill. The panel also recommended several Cuban cigars being produced today, but stressed the importance of understanding box codes and which years are worth seeking out. Cigars produced between 1999 and 2001 can be inconsistent because the Cubans increased production during that time, while Havanas made since July 2002 are vastly improved. The panelists also recommended names such as Hoyo de Monterrey, Por Larrañaga and Ramon Allones, plus the limited-edition humidors released by Habanos S.A., Cuba's cigar exporting organization. In addition, Suckling also noted that some great non-Cuban cigars, such as Fuente Fuente OpusX, Padrón, Ashton VSG and La Flor Dominicana should age very well.
In the end, it's all about being a cigar lover and smoking the cigars you love most. However, no cigar enthusiast should go through life without smoking a rare or aged cigar, no matter how costly or difficult they are to find. "It's just a different experience," said Suckling. "As cigar lovers, it's something we should all be able to enjoy."