victor808
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:38:00 PM
puritan.

You have simply described "bad science" and "politics". Not religion.

I think its funny, this desparate desire to classify a scientific concept (whether it is flawed or not) as a religious belief. It is a bald faced attempt to 1) lower the idea of science itself (something the religious right would love); and 2) allow the religious groups the opportunity to try to force their dogma into the public space. Its BS.

Call it bad science. Bring up studies showing why its bad science. Thats fine. Don't call science religion.

RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, November 3, 2007 11:50:00 PM
1. Author: GreenWolf70

once again your scientific superiority has swayed me.

i shall keep the lights on all night and keep the house at a comfortable 72 year round.

neopuritan
Sunday, November 4, 2007 2:11:00 AM
39. Author: manko

Hey, I've been called much worse; but thanks for insuring the understanding of generalization, and not needless personal attack.

Yes, I am a (surprise!) Christian, and no, there is nothing in my Faith that advocates any thought of being able to rape and pillage the earth. We are, on the other hand, called to be stewards of all the resources God has entrusted to mankind, a responsibility handed down since the Garden. We are also called to be our brother's keeper (cf. the parable of the Good Samaratin). Much of the Global Warming's religionists (see #4 in Webster above) would have imposed policy and regimens whose costs will be astronomical, and will have catastrophic consequences on the world's poor. It is exceedingly cheaper and cost effective to help people adapt to climate change, which is, at worst, inconveniently troublesome (consider our current lack of a "record" hurricane season [yawn]).

And also, being a Christian, allows us to enjoy all the fruits of God's Earth, including fermented combinations of barley, hops, wheat, etc., and rolled and ignited leaves commonly cultivated throughout the Carribbean and Central and South America and elsewhere.

Whistlebritches
Sunday, November 4, 2007 7:01:00 AM
#3

SteveR

You are the voice of wisdom on this subject.

It won't be long and we'll be trying to prevent global cooling as we were in the 70's.I wonder how much that will cost???

Ron

HockeyDad
Sunday, November 4, 2007 9:27:00 AM
^I dunno....How much you got? I'll make you a deal.
victor808
Sunday, November 4, 2007 7:54:00 PM
^43

Puritan... you certainly seem stuck on this "religion" terminology.

So, by point 4 on a definition, the following things are also religions:

1) AIDS walks

2) Gay Rights

3) NRA

4) The internal combustion engine

5) The neo-con's middle eastern foreign policy

6) welfare

Anything could be labeled a "religion" when you use the loosest definitions possible. Lets try using more accurate words, puritan. You know, so we can actually create an environment for discussion as opposed to screaming overly emotional catchphrases.

Lizardo
Sunday, November 4, 2007 8:23:00 PM
RE#3 SteveR is correct.

But don't tell anyone, global warming is paying my bills. Has been for about 17 years now.

We can't keep CO2 analyzers on our shelves, they continue to sell like hotcakes.

pabloescabar
Sunday, November 4, 2007 9:49:00 PM
...cool, thanks. I was having a hard time understanding this issue but your cartoons always clarify things.

neopuritan
Monday, November 5, 2007 2:36:00 AM
46. Author: victor808 Date: 11/05/2007 12:54 AM Reply

^43

Puritan... you certainly seem stuck on this "religion" terminology.

-----Not at all

So, by point 4 on a definition, the following things are also religions:

1) AIDS walks

2) Gay Rights

3) NRA

4) The internal combustion engine

5) The neo-con's middle eastern foreign policy

6) welfare

-----Well, now, don't be silly, but to the extent that something is beholden to with ardor and faith, yes; even you are religious. I'm not sure what you hold to entirely, but everyone on the face of the planet is religious. Even atheists... which is a misnomer, because even atheists believe something, which is why there can be no atheists!

Anything could be labeled a "religion" when you use the loosest definitions possible. Lets try using more accurate words, puritan.

-----Right out of the dictionary; that's why I posted it so there wouldn't be any equivocation.

You know, so we can actually create an environment for discussion as opposed to screaming overly emotional catchphrases.

-----Come now, who's screaming here. I think we've been somewhat gentlemanly, for the most part.

HockeyDad
Monday, November 5, 2007 3:01:00 AM
(Victor808 is a witch.)
neopuritan
Monday, November 5, 2007 3:04:00 AM
^ --- [chuckle]
HockeyDad
Monday, November 5, 2007 3:06:00 AM
cgarman
Monday, November 5, 2007 6:41:00 AM
HockeyDad, only if he weighs as much as a duck!!!
victor808
Monday, November 5, 2007 1:49:00 PM
Cgar - correct. I am approximately 40 witches.

puritan - I believe that your views are tainted by your religious faith. You see religion in everything, simply because you constitute religion as simply being ardor and faith.

Quantum physics is not religion. Yet quantum physics requires a certain amount of faith, and certainly has scientists who study it with a great deal of ardor.

This goes back to definitions. Some people like to use a very "loose" definition for religion. However, if you use this loose definition (and yes, a 4th ranked definition in a dictionary is VERY loose) you have to apply it uniformly. This is why, if you are to hold yourself to that definition... well, everyone on the planet isn't just religious, everyone has at least 10 or 20 different religions that they follow at any one time.

I prefer to use more accurate words. Call a religion a religion, and a scientific theory a scientific theory. This also allows you the opportunity to call a cause a cause, a social policy a social policy, an international policy an international policy, a law of physics a law of physices (etc etc etc). you get the point.

As far as the "Screaming catchphrases" i was being more general. You have no idea how many times I've seen the "BUT secular intellectuals get to have their religion of evolution taught in the public schools!" BS... it cheapens the argument.

neopuritan
Monday, November 5, 2007 5:57:00 PM
54. Author: victor808 Date: 11/05/2007 06:49 PM Reply

puritan - I believe that your views are tainted by your religious faith.

-----As are yours...

You see religion in everything, simply because you constitute religion as simply being ardor and faith.

-----You are learning. Good.

Quantum physics is not religion. Yet quantum physics requires a certain amount of faith, and certainly has scientists who study it with a great deal of ardor.

-----A rose by any other name...

This goes back to definitions. Some people like to use a very "loose" definition for religion. However, if you use this loose definition (and yes, a 4th ranked definition in a dictionary is VERY loose) you have to apply it uniformly. This is why, if you are to hold yourself to that definition... well, everyone on the planet isn't just religious, everyone has at least 10 or 20 different religions that they follow at any one time.

-----Being ranked 4th is not an indicator of "looseness." It is simply a list of application dependent upon context. The contextual application is quite tight.

-----No, no one has 20 + - religions; everyone has just one. God, or, themself-as god.

I prefer to use more accurate words. Call a religion a religion, and a scientific theory a scientific theory. This also allows you the opportunity to call a cause a cause, a social policy a social policy, an international policy an international policy, a law of physics a law of physices (etc etc etc). you get the point.

-----Irrelevant.

As far as the "Screaming catchphrases" i was being more general. You have no idea how many times I've seen the "BUT secular intellectuals get to have their religion of evolution taught in the public schools!" BS... it cheapens the argument.

-----Noooo. It enforces the argument. Evolution is just as much religion as any. To ignore that is to impose rank unfairness, compel intellectual dishonesty, and disingenuously compel moral relativity.

victor808
Monday, November 5, 2007 6:24:00 PM
Geez puritan... you're pulling me away from all the drama over on the misc board for this???

Okay, we have established that YOU consider religion to constitute simply anything which one believes in with ardor and/or faith. This is a bad definition. It is too broad.

Lets look at it this way:

"No, no one has 20 + - religions; everyone has just one. God, or, themself-as god. "

"Being ranked 4th is not an indicator of "looseness." It is simply a list of application dependent upon context. The contextual application is quite tight. "

Okay. So what about a christian who believes in Bush's foreign policy? That's two religions right there. Both require faith. And the individual could believe strongly in both.

Let me make it more simple for you. You already established that you believe quantum physics to be a religious belief. What about a christian quantum physicist? There. Two religions. And yes, they do exist. I even know catholic biochemists. One can even believe in christianity, AND believe that evolution is an accurate scientific theory.

I've had this argument before. As I've said before, it all boils down to data. Actual, real, by golly facts. A scientific theory ultimately is based on data. A faulty theory can be based on bad or incomplete data. BUT IT IS STILL BASED ON DATA.

A religion is based on faith.

If you can find actual data to base the existence of a god (any god) on, then we can talk about putting science on the same level as religion. Until then, you are "compelling intellectual dishonesty" by putting a baseless faith on the same level as even bad science. And yes, THERE IS RANK in ideas. Some theories rank higher than others, based on how much consistent data there is to back it up.

"moral relativity"? morals don't come into this. We are not talking about morals. Morals have nothing to do with science.

neopuritan
Wednesday, November 7, 2007 4:17:00 AM
Geez puritan... you're pulling me away from all the drama over on the misc board for this???

-----There's drama over there? Oh, sorry. LOL

Okay, we have established that YOU consider religion to constitute simply anything which one believes in with ardor and/or faith. This is a bad definition. It is too broad.

-----Religion has always been about a man's attempt to reason with his deity, supplicate, satisfy, atone to. Even if that is himself. A man will construct his own 10 +- commandments, of which even he will fail to keep. He will always utterly fail. And the consequences are too profound to ignore. Christianity, on the other hand, has always been about God reaching out to men, His pursuit of him, His desire to have relationship with men, to even sacrificially give of Himself to demonstrate His love and grace towards men. "God demonstrates His love toward us in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us." Romans 5:8.

One can even believe in christianity, AND believe that evolution is an accurate scientific theory.

-----Nope; competing world views. The latter statement is a denial of the veracity of Scripture. No true, orthodox, evangelical Christian can embrace evolution.

I've had this argument before. As I've said before, it all boils down to data. Actual, real, by golly facts. A scientific theory ultimately is based on data. A faulty theory can be based on bad or incomplete data. BUT IT IS STILL BASED ON DATA.

-----A scientific theory remains a theory until proven. The scientific method requires repeatability. Bad or incomplete data, furthermore, prove nothing. It only proves the desperation of those trying to prove that which cannot be proven in reality, through deception and untruth.

A religion is based on faith.

-----Yes.

If you can find actual data to base the existence of a god (any god) on, then we can talk about putting science on the same level as religion.

-----Disprove the existence of God. (If you wish, we can start another thread on this, or EM. [my handle at gmail dot com])

"moral relativity"? morals don't come into this. We are not talking about morals. Morals have nothing to do with science.

-----Science is very moral. It requires a strict code to operate with any validity. This is the maintenance and check of truth. Remember, "You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor." (I.e., You shall not lie.) Exodus 20:16. Otherwise, what can be believed? The fact remains, because of the Man's depravity, we have only limited access to Truth. For Truth to have any propositional validity, the Source must be infallible and inerrant. There is only one such source of propositional truth, The Scriptures of the Old and New Testament, whose veracity, infallibility, and inerrancy, is readily verified.

-----Vic, I have appreciated our exchanges, and some may have been interested, amused, or maybe miffed. Whatever the case, I be glad to dialog via email, since it has largely devolved into a two-member conversation; unless you or others express otherwise.

-----Otherwise, may God bless you.

-----Neo

manko
Wednesday, November 7, 2007 5:55:00 AM
I like you Neopuritan. I disagree with some of what you say. I agree with some of what you say. You believe in what you believe in deep in the soul. That's the cats pajamas in my eyes.
neopuritan
Wednesday, November 7, 2007 9:23:00 PM
58. Author: manko Date: 11/07/2007 10:55 AM

"That's the cats pajamas in my eyes."

-----Why, thank you. I've just been one to have received much grace, and believe me, I need it, being the hard-boiled sinner that I am!

-----Just trying to picture a cat in pajamas... lol.

victor808
Thursday, November 8, 2007 10:03:00 AM
Puritan,

You unfortunately contradict yourself. On one hand you say everyone is religious. This suggests that religion is a relatively open-ended definition. But THEN you have the audacity to say this:

"-----Nope; competing world views. The latter statement is a denial of the veracity of Scripture. No true, orthodox, evangelical Christian can embrace evolution"

Thats interesting. I did not know that you were god. Now, I'm about as atheistic as you can get. And yes, I do occasionally have a god complex. But I'm sure than a lot of christians would be a bit offended by the idea that YOU and YOU ALONE get to dictate what constitutes being a christian. (note, I didn't say orthodox, I really don't care which of the multiple sects we are talking about).

So, assuming for the moment that you are not god (because I am, dammit); we have to assume that when a person defines themselves as "christian" there is no real reason to believe that they do not actually believe in the existence of the christian god. (I'm not making a value judgement about whether they are good or bad christians, that's not my place).

With this in mind, it is VERY possible for a person to identify themselves as christian, AND believe in evolution.

I've noticed that you refused to address the "christian and believe's bush's foreign policy" example. By your definition earlier, believing that the general neocon strategy of placing bases in the middle east, and essentially meddling with the islamic countries is a good idea, IS A RELIGIOUS BELIEF. this is your definition, not mine. But, using that definition, anyone who is both christian, and believes this policy is good, has two religions right there! Hell, if they believe general theories of quantum physics hold true, then there's a third!

"-----Religion has always been about a man's attempt to reason with his deity, supplicate, satisfy, atone to. Even if that is himself... ...His love and grace towards men. "God demonstrates His love toward us in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us." Romans 5:8. "

Not really relevant. I don't personally care why religion was created. I don't even care if man without religion with fall into chaos and self destruct. Its the whole "die on your feet vs live on your knees" concept.

"-----A scientific theory remains a theory until proven. The scientific method requires repeatability. Bad or incomplete data, furthermore, prove nothing. It only proves the desperation of those trying to prove that which cannot be proven in reality, through deception and untruth. "

You are correct that a scientific theory is a theory until proven. I don't dispute that. But there HAS to be a reason to even create a theory. If I were to postulate the theory that my **** can cure breast cancer... well, Even if I were willing to thoroughly test that theory with any young woman suffering from the horrible affliction, odds are that the scientific community wouldn't give it the time of day. (well, it is mostly guys, so they probably would.. but that's a whole other problem).

You seem to think that bad data proves something. What you really fail to understand (and this is something that people who are stronly attached to religion really do miss) is that science is a PROCESS for vetting information. Science is not automatically at odds with religion. If there were any indication that god existed, the scientific community would jump immediately to develop a theory and a process for experimentally testing the idea.

This is the fundamental difference. In religion, no one designs an experiment to test the existence of god. (Okay, I have a bag of 50 kittens. I will drop this bag off the top of a 50 story building. Obviously, if god exists, he must love kittens. Therefore, something will interfere with my experiment and save the kittens...... oh. Okay. I have a bag of 51! kittens. ... (I call this my "kitten test"! of religion. Each god can be assigned a "kitten value" corresponding to the number of kittens they feel is worth saving.)...:) Anyway, I digress. Religion generally promotes blind faith to the scriptures. Questioning them is not encouraged. In the scientific method, faith is DISCOURAGED, and questioning everything is ENCOURAGED. Now, you'll talk about how no one is questioning global warming or evolution etc etc. But you're actually wrong. A good experiment will give the researcher a yes or no answer. So any experiment involved in these fields does have the opportunity to disprove the theory. (I am simplifying for space here, but these large theories are actually comprised of hundreds of smaller definable experiments/theories. As long as all the smaller experiments continue to provide consistent results, this supports the veracity of the larger theory.) Instances where negative information is squashed, or in which false information is provided is CLEARLY WRONG, and does hurt the larger theory and the scientific community as a whole. but this does not make it a religion, just a bad theory.

"-----Disprove the existence of God. (If you wish, we can start another thread on this, or EM. [my handle at gmail dot com]) "

I don't need to. Until his/her/it's existence is proven, there is no rationale to require disproving it. That's akin to me saying "Disprove the existence of that invisible, ten foot tall, purple monster standing in the corner!" Oh, you can't disprove it? Well then it must exist!

"Science is very moral. It requires a strict code to operate with any validity. This is the maintenance and check of truth. Remember, ...."

Yes and no. Science does require adherence to a investigational code, I agree. And when scientists violate that, the community as a whole is harmed, and scientific progess is set back. BUT (there's always a but), science is not ABOUT morals. Science is about truth. Something is or it isn't.Whether the answer achieved is good or bad is irrelevant, achieving the answer itself is the important part. Do you understand the difference? Let me give you an example (I like to give outrageous examples, since I think it is the extremes which help explain things): Lets say a geneticist investigating the human genome discovered that all blacks contained a gene encoding a protein which slowed synaptic firing, and ruduced overall cognitive capabilities. (This is not too different than scientists attempts 150 years ago to prove that blacks were well suited to slavery because of the shape of their cranium and length of various bones). Now, the moral thing to do, would be to lie about this finding or bury it; this sort of information would likely cause an entire second class citizenry, destroy all the civil freedoms which this country has worked for etc etc. But the fact of the matter is, if this were true and discovered, the scientist would report it. Why? Because the answer, and only the answer is what is important in science. I would like to state again, before I go on, that the above is a complete dramatization and no such protein has been discovered, nor is it being investigated.

"Vic, I have appreciated our exchanges, and some may have been interested, amused, or maybe miffed. Whatever the case, I be glad to dialog via email, since it has largely devolved into a two-member conversation; unless you or others express otherwise. "

I enjoy this stuff as well, when I have time to properly address it.

"-----Otherwise, may God bless you. "

I appreciate your well wishes, but I do try to avoid being "blessed", thanks!