1. Must do: Buy a digital hygrometer that can be calibrated. it shouldn't cost you more that about $15-20. You can also by a calibration kit. Boveda makes both and I have them both. I am quite satisfied, although there certainly are other brands.
2. Get a larger humidor. The larger your humidor is, no mater how few cigars you may store in it, the more stable it will be. Also a large humidor, say with a lift out tray, can have different humidity levels in different locations. If your humidification device is mounted on the inside of the lid, then you can keep your cigars that need higher humidity on top. Those that benefit from lower humidity can be stored on the bottom.
3. Use a humidification solution or system such as beads or gel in a jar, along with a propylene glycol solution to keep your desired humidity constant. Alternatives include Boveda humidification packs, Humid-Eze or the little pillows that CI/Cbid sells.
4. Sign up in the TRADE section as a noob and a veteran will be assigned to you . He or she will help you out with all of this, trade some cigars with you and teach you the way...