mrtelcom
Friday, October 17, 2003 2:01:00 PM
OK, I am cutting and pasting from another board, but this is just tooo dang good! :

Since I hold a Ph.D. in analytical chemistry, I think I'm qualified to contribute to this discussion.

In a closed system, such as a cooler or humidor, water in a container or water from a saturated sponge will evaporate until an equilibrium condition exists. That equilibrium condition, represented by the "relative humidity", is governed by the partial pressure of water vapor at a given temperature.

As we all know from experience, the partial pressure of water vapor (the relative humidity of the system) is way too high for storing cigars. When we add propylene glycol to the mix, we "interfere" with the ability of the water to evaporate from the sponge. In essence, the partial pressure of the water vapor is REDUCED by adding a material which inhibits the ability of the water vapor to evaporate.

The identity of the interfering material is really not important - it can be ethylene glycol, glycerin, or even common table salt - but the amount in the mix certainly IS important. At a 50-50 mix of propylene glycol to water, the equilibrium vapor pressure of water at 70 deg. F will yield a relative humidity of some 72% RH.

As more water tries to evaporate from the sponge, to take care of dry cigars, for example, or because the humidor is not really a truly closed system, it becomes increasingly difficult for the water to evaporate because the relative concentration of propylene glycol increases in the remaining mix. The propylene glycol is a non-volatile material and will not evaporate from the sponge. Once charged, the sponge should be replenished only with distilled water to restore the original 50-50 mix, if that is what is desired.

I prefer to keep my cigars at 67% relative humidity. To achieve this, I charge a sponge with a mixture of 58% propylene glycol and 42% water. As water evaporates from this system and the sponge struggles to raise the RH above about 64%, I add water at this time. The sponge will still feel "heavy", because it is then only loaded with PG.

Think of the amount of proylene glycol in your initial charge as a "humidistat" for your system. Here are the values to use for a given desired relative humidity, assuming a 70 deg. F storage temperature:

Desired RH %PG %H20

65 60 40

66 59 41

67 58 42

68 57 43

69 56 44

70 54 46

71 52 48

72 50 50

The astute observer will notice that the relationship between relative humidity and %PG in the system is not linear, but begins increasing sharply below about 55% PG in the system. This is why so many people struggle to get the %RH in their coolerdor down below 70%, even though they are using 50-50 mixes.

I hope this clears up some of the myths circulating about cigar storage.

mrtelcom
Friday, October 17, 2003 2:05:00 PM
Here is a follow up that I found interesting :

by replenishing the foam with your 50-50 mix, you are gradually increasing the concentration of propylene glycol in the foam. Assuming the water has completely vaporized from the foam after each addition, the amount of PG in the foam increases by this progression:

50% - 75% - 87.5% - 93.75% - and so on.

After 4 replenishments, the foam is virtually all PG, and the RH of the system will become essentially that of the surrounding environment.

This is why, once charged, you only need to replenish the humidity elements/ foam/ sponge/ whatever with distilled water.

RICKAMAVEN
Friday, October 17, 2003 6:42:00 PM
having once driven by a community college, i would agree with your analysis.

i would offer the following bit of down home information to the new to cigar group. set it and forget it.

unless you live in a tent in the gobi desert, it is not necessary to check your cigars hourly, daily and i guess you could even skip a week if you are not constantly opening the humidor.

SwimNaked
Friday, October 17, 2003 6:48:00 PM
Hey.. while I am a Biologist by trade, I'm a Chemist by profession. And not that that guy needs any confirmation, but I'd say that he's spot on.
cigman627
Friday, October 17, 2003 10:14:00 PM
Ok, I get the first part, but it gets a little fuzzy after the part that starts "In a closed system..."

...cigman

mrtelcom
Saturday, October 18, 2003 4:02:00 AM
The second post helped me, I have been guilty of restoring with more PG too often.
JonR
Saturday, October 18, 2003 7:22:00 AM
I'm neither a chemist or a biologist however I did sleep in a Holiday Inn once so I do concur with PHDs mrtelcom and SwimNaked. JonR
mrtelcom
Saturday, October 18, 2003 9:46:00 AM
When I said cut and paste, I meant from another author.

I hated chemistry!

sketcha
Saturday, October 18, 2003 10:08:00 AM
Nice! Thanks!
billyjackson
Saturday, October 18, 2003 12:51:00 PM
I'm lucky enough (so far) to be able to maintain what I need without messing with PG. No mold, steady RH...of course, I am able to maintain my temperature easily. I'm sure when my environment changes, I'll be gettin' some of that good ol' PG.
mrtelcom
Friday, January 9, 2004 6:30:00 PM
^
RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, January 10, 2004 2:28:00 AM
i don't know why, but every year i rinse the oaisis thouroughly with distilled water let it dry and start with a fresh solution.

i might be it unnecessarily, but it does make me happy.

AJ_CHICAGO
Saturday, January 10, 2004 5:43:00 PM
That makes perfect sense Rickamaven. While the PG doesn't evaporate like H2O, it does dissipate over time and starting over anually will get you back closer to 50/50 and closer to 65 - 70% RH. I'm not a chemist, but I got an A in Biology once!
grond
Saturday, January 10, 2004 6:20:00 PM
Florist foam will eventually begin to break down. It is best to replace the foam itself and recharge with PG/DW at least annually. Also, rinsing the foam good with distilled water will not necessarily get all the PG out of the foam.

At $1 a block for Oasis floral foam, I replace my foam inserts in all my systems every six months... but... I also own a floral shop. 🙂

fudge
Saturday, January 10, 2004 6:42:00 PM
"At $1 a block for Oasis floral foam, I replace my foam inserts in all my systems every six months... but... I also own a floral shop. :)"

ROFL

mrtelcom
Friday, March 4, 2005 3:35:00 AM
Top for LaVieja and newbies.
andytv
Friday, March 4, 2005 6:10:00 AM
I'm not chemist, but I did stay in a Holiday Inn Express last night.

I ditched the floral foam & PG for Climmax.