f16devils
Saturday, August 2, 2008 6:27:00 PM
With Peter Gabriel

or without

They made more money without him, but which was better?

DrMaddVibe
Saturday, August 2, 2008 7:03:00 PM
With
herfsnipe
Saturday, August 2, 2008 7:38:00 PM
I think the lineup WITH both Gabriel and Steve Hackett was the absolute best, but many of those who know of Genesis us are not old enough to appreciate them. My first genesis albumn was Genesis Live. I was at a friends house and he owned it and I thought it was great, so I had to have it.

Gabriel might have been wierd, but I'm a fan and always will be. It's always been my wish that somehow, these guys could all get back together with Gabriel and Hackett for a tour or even one show.

f16devils
Saturday, August 2, 2008 8:10:00 PM
I seriously doubt you will ever see that line up again. I will say I saw a tribute band called The Musical Box and really enjoyed them. Steve Hackett was and still is a phenomenal guitar player.
jpotts
Saturday, August 2, 2008 9:01:00 PM
With.
edsbar60
Saturday, August 2, 2008 9:53:00 PM
With, but without is also one of my favorite all time bands. It's all good.
hoyodude
Sunday, August 3, 2008 3:44:00 AM
I first started to listen to Genesis around the time Trespass and Nursery Crime came out, the early years. Peter Gabriel's voice brought that band to a whole new level. Not to say that the rest of the band weren't equally responsible for their sound but Peter's voice was, to me, what put them in a whole new category.

When I heard The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway (the original version)I knew I was hearing something that I would be listening to for the rest of my life. I wasn't wrong.

That being said, I saw them twice without Peter Gabriel and loved the new incarnation of the band right up until about the Duke album. After that I really lost all interest in them. Sort of like, to a slightly lesser degree, what happened to Chicago in their later years.

So, the short answer would definitely be WITH Peter Gabriel.

hoyodude
Sunday, August 3, 2008 3:48:00 AM
BTW, there have been rumors that Peter and the original members have had some recent discussions about reuniting for one last tour. What I heard was the band would be doing a tour this year (or next?) without him but he might be interested in the next tour which could possibly occur in the following year or two.

Unsubstantiated rumor but.........? (Might just turn out to be like the old Beatles rumors.)

hoyodude
Sunday, August 3, 2008 3:58:00 AM
oh, yeah.................NINE!
pacman357
Sunday, August 3, 2008 4:16:00 AM
I think they were at their best when playing "Land of Confusion" and the band members were all replaced by the members of Disturbed.
hoyodude
Sunday, August 3, 2008 4:20:00 AM
alright pac,......I know you're just tryin' to hurt me, brother....