topper7788
Thursday, October 16, 2008 10:03:00 AM
I was perusing the trades and read this, just kind of thought it was worth a post...plus being an retail car guy ex-Floridian living in the Midwest I kinda relate..

Richard Truett

Automotive News

October 15, 2008 - 3:32 pm ET

One part of my job here at Automotive News is to scan the scads of auto-related Web sites daily to see what''''''''s going on out there.

As General Motors, Ford and Chrysler struggle through tough financial times and a changing market, the news coming from these companies is almost never good these days. Plant closings. Vehicles being axed. Communities suffering.

Here''''''''s what I find especially disturbing: Whenever there''''''''s a story about one of the Detroit automakers on a Web site that allows readers to comment at the end of the article, you can count on loads of vile bile from respondents who can''''''''t wait for GM, Ford and Chrysler to go out of business.

For the most part, these are angry people. But they don''''''''t seem to be unintelligent people who are just making uninformed negative comments only to incite and inflame and to see their screen names in print. They do have valid points. Or did have.

But I wonder: How long does GM have to be punished for making Chevrolet Vegas and Oldsmobile diesels or relying too long on the fat profits of trucks and SUVs?

When does Ford get forgiven for the Pinto and other crimes against auto mobility?

When will Chrysler be let off the hook for making everything out of the K car and for the rotten minivan transmissions in the early 1990s.

When will people -- environmentalists, especially -- chastise Toyota for making its share of gas-guzzling behemoths?

If any of the people who are hoping for the death of the Detroit 3 on the Internet could come to Detroit to see what I see, they wouldn''''''''t feel the same way.

When I moved to Detroit from Orlando, Fla., seven years ago, I was astounded at how friendly and warm Midwesterners are compared with Floridians. On a snowy day, if your neighbor makes it to his snowblower before you do, chances are your driveway will be cleared.

When you walk down the street here, people say hello, ask how you are doing and are interested in the answer. That doesn''''''''t happen often in Florida, where everyone is from somewhere else and there is little sense of community.

GM today is not the Vega or the Cadillac V-8-6-4 anymore. GM is my friend Mark Bradshaw, just a regular nonmanagement-level engineer who is working on some future GM small car. (He won''''''''t tell me what it is, and I don''''''''t ask.)

Mark is the kind of guy any auto enthusiast would love to have as a friend. He just finished a 10-year restoration of a 1969 Pontiac GTO Judge, making it one of the finest in the world. He also built a Triumph TR8 sports car with a beefy Rover V-8 engine. He''''''''s made some really impressive modifications to his cars, and he''''''''s always happy to share with others what he did.

On Saturday mornings, it isn''''''''t unusual to see GM''''''''s chief of design, Ed Welburn, and his awesome 1969 Camaro in the parking lot of a little store north of Detroit that sells car magazines and models. Ed goes there sometimes to look at other classic and exotic cars and speak with enthusiasts. He loves cars, obviously, and keeps up with what''''''''s going on at the street level.

GM is a guy like Tom Stephens, executive vice president of GM''''''''s global powertrain. Stephens heard about a member of my car club who needed a classic Buick engine to rebuild, and Stephens gave him one for free. And it wasn''''''''t just any engine. It was an engine Stephens has owned since he was a teenager. It powered his first home-built muscle car, a V-8 Vega.

I have friends at Ford and Chrysler just like Bradshaw and Welburn and Stephens -- the friendliest, most unselfish people you could want to meet, hardworking guys who are trying their best to hang on in a bad situation.

No one in America will benefit in any way if any of the Detroit 3 fold.

But the toxic comments attached to Web stories just keep coming, like this one: "With incompetent clowns like this running GM and Ford and Chrysler -- it is no wonder that the Big Three is well on its way of becoming the Big Zero. How could the leadership of these companies be this bad?"

They just rub a little more salt into a very bad wound that is starting to look as if it may never heal.

tdtall70
Thursday, October 16, 2008 10:12:00 AM
Too bad they weren't being proactive enough in engineering new fuel efficient cars. And where's my electric car? I won't "compare" them with Toyota, or Honda- but shouldn't they have had a forward-looking enough business module to realize what the issues were? It sucks, but hey- isn’t that how a capitalist society works?

Then again, I could just be missing the real point here- when "we, the (taxpaying) people" bail them out their execs will still be living high on the hog, right?

Thunder.Gerbil
Thursday, October 16, 2008 10:17:00 AM
That''''''''s an interesting story about GM''''''''s, Ford''''''''s and Chrysler''''''''s problems. Someday''''''''s the big three just really do have their head''''''''s stuck up their ass''''''''s.

Buckwheat
Thursday, October 16, 2008 10:30:00 AM
To hell with my electric car!! Where's my FLYING CAR??? And when will world be ruled by DAMN DIRTY APES???
Thunder.Gerbil
Thursday, October 16, 2008 10:34:00 AM
^

Moller is working on it. Should be ready within the next few years.

http://www.moller.com/skycar.htm 

Buckwheat
Thursday, October 16, 2008 10:37:00 AM
I didn't see anything about apes on their website.
plinytheelder
Thursday, October 16, 2008 10:43:00 AM
Speaking only about Ford, their problem can best be summed up by two words.

Jacques Nasser.

He damn near ruined the company.

topper7788
Thursday, October 16, 2008 11:03:00 AM
A little more:

The Detroit News is reporting that GM is considering absorbing Chrysler under a takeover deal, then phasing the automaker out of existence.

Similar to the Chrysler takeover of AMC in 1987, GM would eliminate overlapping models, integrate its own parts and engineering into the remainder and likely dump the Chrysler and Dodge brands. Analysts predict that GM would keep the Jeep brand as well as Chrysler's minivan models, adding them to its own product lines. If such a scenario were to occur, GM would gain Chrysler's roughly $11 billion in cash and remove a competitor who now accounts for approximately 1.5 million units per year. But is GM willing to risk the enormous political and economic pitfalls that would surely follow?

Gerald Meyers, former AMC chairman turned U of M business professor says, "The others (automakers) will be delighted to have Chrysler just die and take 1.5 million units out of the industry, which is about what the excess is." And indeed, the elimination of a major automaker may be precisely what's needed to right-size the industry. But the nationwide cost in terms of lost jobs and plant closures would be massive.

GM and Chrysler are both struggling with overcapacity and an oversupply of dealerships; combining the two would simply give the resulting entity an excuse to shed tremendous redundancy in one fell swoop. Problem is, most of those redundant assets have families to feed and bills to pay; the impact to Michigan's already-fragile economy would be devastating, but every state in the union would feel some of the effects.

So what do you to if you're GM? Save yourself at the expense of tens of thousands of jobs? Would the result lead to a GM that's healthy and profitable again, or would it stave off the inevitable bankruptcy filing and lead to a generation of ill-will toward the automaker from families ruined by its scorched-earth takeover of Chrysler? We don't know the answer, but we certainly hope GM's corporate captains are asking the hard questions before making any far-reaching moves. [Detroit News]